Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Shelved cabinets versus drawers

Posted by boone_2009 (My Page) on
Sat, Aug 4, 12 at 21:29

All you experienced kitchen remodelers :-),

What do you find most convenient and would do all over again with no second thought : having mostly drawers in your kitchen *or* cabinets with shelves( fixed and/or pull-out)?Of course, I am referring to lowers :-)

TIA!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

Dear Boone,

You are about to receive 99 votes for all drawers, and 1 vote that says that one or two roll-out trays is fine in addition to mostly drawers.

I am one of the 99.


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

Pull out and bump in or: open cabinet, then pull out. Bump in and then close cabinet.

That said, I do have an open cabinet on my island. It's to the right of my prep sink and while I initially had shelves, it changed to a paper towel holder (upper) and cutting board storage (lower). Good luck!


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

Definitely drawers, and full extension at that. My kitchen has/had shelves and a couple of the units were only 16 inches wide. They were the black holes of my kitchen. When we pulled out the units, I thought I had them emptied. It wasn't until they had been carried outside that I saw my pyrex double boiler at the back of of one. It's a wonder it wasn't broken. I had been wondering where it was.


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

I'm the 1 vote that @Angie_DIY referred to.
Mostly drawers and a few pull-outs.


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

I'm with the 99 -- love my drawers!!!


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

All drawers if you can!


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

here ya go. link to recent thread on roll outs vs drawers.

Here is a link that might be useful: roll out vs drawers


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

Thank you so much, Angie_DIY ( I envy you, my DIY skills are minimal), Oldbat2be and Marti8a ..oh, I'm so glad I asked!

Oldbat2be ( lovely sense of humor there! I think I qualify, too :-)) - Regarding "open cabinet, pull out, bump in, close cabinet" do you find that irksome at all? I currently have this type of cabinet beneath my cooktop and it has two deep pull-out trays which are great for all my pots and pans; I loved it for several years but now that I'm starting to be an old bat ;-) with all the attendant aches that old-battage brings, I find it a literal pain to keep opening and closing those doors. I'm wondering if I should just go with deep drawers.

Lol, Marti8a... just yesterday, I 'discovered' a frying pan in a cabinet - I never even knew I had it!


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

Decide what you want to put in each space. In my small kitchen, I included a 9" pan cupboard with a shelf, a 15" cupboard with a shelf, and a 24" cupboard with a pull-out. But I knew what I wanted in each of those cabs, and drawers would not have worked as well in those specific cases. The rest of the lowers are all drawers.


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

Oh, I just read the other posts --- you guys are amazing! Thank you for all your help.

Willtv: I'd like to give you company and make it 2 - although Fouramblues and Sochi have joined the 99 crowd and make it a bit hard for me to promise anything ;-).

Desertsteph: I thought I'd thoroughly searched this site before I posted, to avoid 'repeats' - dang. Thanks for being so helpful and giving me the link, and sorry, everyone, for not doing a better job with my search :( .


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

Ginny20: I just saw *your* post!!! Thank you for your helpful suggestion - that's exactly what I'm doing, using a yellow 'legal' pad and madly scribbling whenever I think of something new :-).


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

Love my drawers !
I have all sizes. 14-42 inches!
I have a couple cabs left.
The obligatory trash pull out, an angle cabinet, a corner super susan(no pole), and one small cab next to the sink. I was thinking of making it a drawer but so far, I like this one. Top shelf has cutting boards, second shelf houses the sink basket for my cascade sink and bottom shelf holds my mandolin.
I added a 13 inch pull out pantry which I love.
I have one taller drawer under the oven which originally had my bread machine and counter top oven. I moved the oven to the pantry.
Before I switched, I used stickies to identify what would live in each drawee. I was pretty close.
Search for a2gemini more pictures to see my drawers.


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

boone_2009: I do actually have all drawers/pull-outs... thanks to input from the forum. The 'open cabinet pull out drawer, then push drawer in and close cabinet' was something which really resonated with me.


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

a2gemini - Too funny, I read your post and thought, "gee, I wonder if she keeps her mandolin in the kitchen because the humidity is good for stringed instruments" and then I realized you meant the thing you use to slice vegetables. Being Italian, I always think of musical mandolins first. :)

boone - I had a pull out under my cooktop before, too, and I switched to drawers. So much better! I measured my tallest pot and made the bottom drawer deep enough.


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

Thread Deja vu...


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

A2gemini: Thanks for all the info :-).I , too, thought of the 'musical' mandolin first, lol! I will search your name for the pics..thanks!!! Did you specify the depth of each of your drawers or was that suggested to you by your KD?What do you find the shallower drawers most useful for and ditto the deepest ones ( apart from pots and pans)?
Oldbat2be and Ginny20 - Thank you very much for your comments.
CEFreeman - Sorry :-(. My fault.


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

Boone-
All the drawers are the same depth and pull out completely as most do these days.
It is the width that is variable.
I was not modifying the basic kitchen structure and some drawers were dictated by space but overall loving the design.
Hope to have final pictures in a couple weeks.

Guess I better take up music lessons. LOL!

Still helping DM so on phone vs computer.


 o
RE: Shelved cabinets versus drawers

Forgot to mention- our favorite restaurant has a musical duo who are amazing. One plays the mandolin and the other an accordion, so as I wrote the first post I also thought music.
Maybe I would do better with mandolin or guitar strings than I do with the slicer.
Actually small gauge guitar strings work great for cheesecake!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here