Return to the Woodworking Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Broken router collet - what did I do?

Posted by hoosierdoc (My Page) on
Mon, Dec 1, 08 at 7:44

I just bought a 2.25hp Dewalt router kit. I was using the fixed base with a 3/4" Skil bit to cut a groove in four 2x4s laid side to side. The first pass went fine. The end of the second pass, the bit fell out, along with a piece of the collet. We're talking sixty seconds of use. I had the bit set in the collet per directions, even pulled it out the 1/16" as suggested. It was tightened, base was flat, I dunno. Manufacturing defect? User error? It's my first "good" tool and it breaks after a minute of use. Rather frustrated, not to mention the day of routing and shelf construction I lost out on.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

I should add... this was my first time using a router too...


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

I'm wondering what "piece of the collet" fell out. Could it have been undertightened and simply unscrewed itself? Could you have overtightened it, breaking the collet with excessive force? Can you post a picture?


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

I can post a picture later, but to summarize: approx 30% of the circumference of the collet was missing, I loosened the nut then the other pieces fell out. It's like someone cut each little piece off the circular housing that holds it all together.


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

What kind of Skil bit?


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

If it's the removable portion of the collet, I'd make them replace the collet. If it's the conical recess in the shaft itself, they have to take back the router and give you a new one. I've never had a collet break in any case, with Bosch (x2) Porter Cable (x2), ancient Skil, Makita, or Dewalt.
Casey


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

Here's the image of what I have. On closer inspection, I didn't do a very good job getting a perfectly straight cut. I was using a piece of wood clamped as a straight edge. The bit is a straight cut 3/4" Skil.

Here is a link that might be useful: Broken Collet :(


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

My guess is improper heat-treating of the collet. It's exceedingly unlikely that this is your fault. Return for warranty repair/replacement.


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

OK... so back to lowe's, exchange the router, get a "new" one. I get it open and it's a used model. Hrm. Back to the same project. 17.5" of routing 1/4 inch at a time to total depth of 3/4". I get done with my 12th pass and pop, out comes the bit after a noisy pass. Another broken collet. When I went to unscrew the nut, it was loose.

Is it like a lug nut where you tighten, drive, then tighten again? The instructions specifically say you don't have to really strain to tighten, and I give it a good tug, then stop.

At this point I'm blaming my novice (read, first time ever) routing skills rather than a quality manufacturer for a double break.


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

Return the thing and get a Porter Cable router.

The bit shank may also be undersized and causing the collet to break.

If you have a dial caliper (or micrometer) that measure to 0.001 inch you can check the shank diameter.

Dewalt is owned by Black & Decker, and is getting to be just as bad.
B&D trashed there own name so badly they have had to change to other names they have purchased.
The have recently purchased Porter Cable, so expect the quality there to tank next.


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

Try getting some better bits. I would also use the 1/2" shank bits for 3/4" diameter cutters like what you are doing. Make sure your router bits come from a quality manufacturer. Look for bite made in USA, Italy, Germany, or another first world manufacturing place. Most bits made in China are poor quality. Cheap router bits are a safety hazard, brand new ones will lose the cutting tips on the first use- sending the tiny sharp projectile like a bullet across your shop. One of the best values in quality made router bits is Woodline.

Here is a link that might be useful: router bits


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

I took the advice and returned the Dewalt for a Porter-Cable. Just feels like a better tool in my hand. Nothing is loose, balanced well. Quieter operation, smoother cuts, and no broken collets! I couldn't find a half inch shank or a better bit for the cut so I just went with what I had. Instead of three passes, I did 3/8" twice and worked great.

Thanks for all the help with this! I'm sure I'll be back with another roadblock for my workbench in a month...


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

FWIW, I'm very happy with my DeWalt plunge router. I can only speculate about what went wrong, but the sort of breakage you were seeing is not typical.


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

3/8" x 3/4" is way too much to chew at one pass.

And on a 1/4" shaft to boot!

Get a router book and learn how to use the tool correctly before you hurt yourself.


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

The bit keeps slipping out of the collet no matter what force I use in tightening. Is this a replacement item? Can anyone suggest a fix on the problem?


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

Are you bottoming out the bit when you stick it in the collet, i.e. pushing it in all the way until it can't go in any more? That will prevent the collet from holding the bit properly. If you already know this than try another bit. If it has the same problem get a new collet. Collets are a common replacement item any real tool place (not Blows or Home Repo) should have.


 o
RE: Broken router collet - what did I do?

hacker9-
Proper technique in inserting and tightening should prevent this problem. Do you have any friends who are experienced with routers and could give you a hands-on lesson?


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Woodworking Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here