Orange peel is typically the result of improper painting technique, and is caused by the quick evaporation of thinner, incorrect spray gun setup (e.g., low air pressure or incorrect nozzle), spraying the paint at an angle other than perpendicular, or applying excessive paint.

Staining maple is problematic. Maple blotches easily, meaning getting even color is difficult.

As much as I dislike gel stains(they are basically just modified paint), a gel stain for your situation may be the best short term solution.

Try to find a cabinet shop or even a paint shop--some auto shops have people who can do wood.

Thanks!

The guy says that the stain went on smoothly and looked good but the poly is the problem. The first time, he brushed it on and sprayed it on the second time, both with dismal results.

Thanks!

The guy says that the stain went on smoothly and looked good but the poly is the problem. The first time, he brushed it on and sprayed it on the second time, both with dismal results.

Once stain is dried, there is still residue that needs to be removed and a light hand sanding done before the finish is applied.

That can cause the problem.

Outdated poly can be the problem.

I remember that when I stained our front door many years ago that I sanded between the coats and got a very pleasing result and never had trouble with the poly.

Thanks for the help!