Return to the Electrical Wiring Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
smart meters

Posted by dan1554 (My Page) on
Wed, Dec 21, 11 at 23:24

I just had my older style meter converted to one of the new "smart meters" offered by me electric company. I live in southwestern PA, and have West Penn Power as my provider. They claim it will save me money by monitoring my usage at various times.... this sounds like somehow, some way, it will end up costing me money. Does anyone have any thoughts / opinions / knowledge of the smart meters, and the end results?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: smart meters

Monitoring means "gathering information". We know that the power company will get that information. How much of it will they share with you and when and how?


 o
RE: smart meters

Well it's not the meter that's the key point but what their billing policy is.
If they are going to charge you less during off peak you get some benefit.


 o
RE: smart meters

We have had a smart meter through Texas Utilities along with a very low fixed rate for a couple of years. Big house in a hot climate with about $200 per month in hottest months. I can go on line any time and check our power usage.


 o
RE: smart meters

The smart meters are designed to make 'demand billing' possible.

You will be charged more at peak times, less at off peak.

Some commercial services have had things like this for years, though often not as sophisticate as the new smart meters can allow.
Sometime the rate for ALL the power used in the billing period was based on the peak usage during the billing period.

Of course it will be rolled out as a 'lower rates during off peak hours' program to obscure the higher rates during peak periods.

Since a very large part of this is controlled by state regulators, you will need to watch what the state allows to be altered in the billing rules.


 o
RE: smart meters

Thanks for the replies everyone. At this point, the POCO says it can only lower my bills, because if I reduce usage during peak hours I will save 50 cents per kilowatt, they say. Sounds too good to be true. I don't know what they are basing it on, since I already do as much as possible on off peak hours. At this time, they are not going to have tiered billing / peak hours billing rates.... but of course I realize the potential for that is there, and a few years from now, who knows what we will see. They will be replacing everyone's meter with this new type so it was inevitable, I just hate being one of the first.


 o
RE: smart meters

"I will save 50 cents per kilowatt, they say. Sounds too good to be true."

Doesn't sound true to me.


 o
RE: smart meters

"Sounds too good to be true."

Increases during peak usage will eventually follow.


 o
RE: smart meters

The kicker is they do not have anything in writing yet because they are only starting to roll this out next summer so its easy to promise the world now. I typically use between 900 and 1500 kwh per month and my bill averages between 80 and 140..... so if I believe their claim of 50 cents per kwh for peak reduction and I dropped my peak usage by 300 kwh then they would owe me money? I don't think that will happen. Just another way big brother is watching us.


 o
RE: smart meters

Watching us?

Here is a link that might be useful: Ray


 o
RE: smart meters

Smart meters have nothing to do with saving the customers any money. It allows the implementation of 'time-of-day' pricing, which is an effort to raise your bill, not lower it.


 o
RE: smart meters

depends.

what type of smart meter are they talking about..

demand use?? We've had one from 1993..love it..if you watch the ON peak demand(KW..yes KW not KWh)..you can drop your bill by close to $100/month..no joke..its Dec in NC and last month bill was around $115. for a 4500sq/ft house. all electric. we run around 160-180 in the summer.

IP/wiFi readable..I think just makes it easy for them to read you meter and you won't gain much..ie little savings

so what kind are they talking about?
-dkenny


 o
RE: smart meters

I'm naturally suspicious of any company that holds a monopoly (or near monopoly) and promises customers a savings through some new fangled device that doesn't cost the customer anything either. Why would they do that?

I can understand the devices that shut off high draw appliances during peak demand periods in exchange for a lower rate.


 o
RE: smart meters

IMO, the smart meters allow the various providers to read usage remotely thereby eliminating the need for meter readers. It's largely a personnel issue.


 o
RE: smart meters

"the smart meters allow the various providers to read usage remotely thereby eliminating the need for meter readers. It's largely a personnel issue."

Remote reading of meters did not requires the level of "smart meter" technology that is now being implemented.

Many water authorizes changed over to electronic meter reading a while ago, but they still use plain old mechanical metering to measure the volume of water used.

The "smart meter" craze is going to be another method to increase costs depending on time of usage.


 o
RE: smart meters

Brick is right. I've had a radio unit on my meter for years and there is nothing smart about it. It allows the utility to do drive-by readings.


 o
RE: smart meters

that's one type of smart metering..
a radio to read the meter is one way.
what about using wifi..each meter has an IP address..or is a server that someone drive nearby and reads it?
demand metering is a different type that could add all features above. mine doesn't have the radio or the wifi.. the use a IR handheld device to read it.

-dkenny


 o
RE: smart meters

Locally, one of the area power companies (there are two but rarely does the customer get to choose which. I have accounts with both and have an ownership interest in both) has had the ability since 2006 to do drive-by readings from short distances, apparently less than 1/4 miles, perhaps even less. They both use contractors to read the meters and to do limited service chores. Recently one of the contract employees with Scope Meter Services decided that a meter was dead when in fact, the premises was empty and the main was off. This clown threw the removed meter into the woods, installed another one and the POCO billed for three months estimated usage based on the previous year usage. The POCO claimed that they can monitor the meter from their central location which I knew to be untrue. They claimed that is how they knew the exact usage. So I asked them why they did not use the magical meter reading ability to read the new meter so that they would know that it also shows no power has been used. The bill was then corrected without comment or explanation. Technology can do wonders, but it is limited by the ability of those who are in charge of it. My investigation shows that the contract employees are not well paid. It shows in the ability of those they have working.
I found and now have the removed meter stored in a secure location.


 o
RE: smart meters

The other radio protocol being looked at is ZigBee. It uses the same frequency band as WiFi but is much narrower. It is also much lower power. The protocol allows the meters to set up a 'network' amongst themselves and pass their data to an 'aggregator' which usually sits on a pole. It can be read by drive-by or be net connected (cellular).


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Electrical Wiring Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here