Return to the Electrical Wiring Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Unusual Wiring - Comments please

Posted by whispertoo (My Page) on
Tue, May 11, 10 at 9:56

I was asked to change a ceiling light in a recently constructed commercial building. The unusual (and expensive) Florescent lamps used in the light were prone to frequent failure. When I took the lamp down I found the white lamp wire connected to the green (plastic insulated wire). The light didnt work when connected white to white and black to black as would be normal! Checking at the door switch we found that they used a single (2 wire with ground) bx cable from the switch box inside the door to control two lights. They used black for the feed to light one, white (marked black at the switch but not at the light) for the feed to light two, green for the neutral and the BX shield for ground. This cable went to light #one first, then the circuit carried on to the second light but with the green which had been used for neutral from the switch box connected to the white and the white from the second switch connected to black to feed light #two. How the green (or Bare) to the second light was connected I'm not 100% sure but it was probably connected to metalwork at both ends.

The whole several million dollar building was just completed by a GC so well regarded in this town that "he inspects his own work" (apparently didnt get an electrical inspection). The occupants have complained about frequent failures of computers and other electronics even when connected to good surge protectors.

My questions- Can anyone think of a legal justification for using a ground wire this way?
And- How should the owner proceed with the situation (building is less than a year old)?

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Unusual Wiring - Comments please

From your post it is obvious you are not an electrician, so why were you changing a light in a commercial building? It is also obvious that the original installer was not an electrician either. Do you see a pattern here? Maybe he should get a pretend lawyer to pursue action against the builder. Of course the result will be about the same as he has gotten so far by not using professionals.

RE: Unusual Wiring - Comments please

As groundrod said, if you are not a licensed electrician, you have no business doing work in a commercial building. This is one area where cutting costs can be detrimental down the road. From what you describe, whoever installed the original wiring was also not a licensed electrician, or a very poor excuse for one. There's a saying - just because you put two wires together and the light comes on, does NOT mean it was done right. Get a professional in there to correct this, and any other issues.

RE: Unusual Wiring - Followup

Now that the flames and lectures have subsided I would like to add a bit more information
in hopes of getting some useful discussion about this situation.

Disturbed by the wiring mentioned above, I discussed
the situation with an uninvolved Licensed Electrician who opined that the fixture wiring
would have been OK if they had marked the green wire white to show it as a neutral.
Is there any support for that opinion here on this forum?

I have a serious concern over the compromised ground system that was discovered
and wonder what else may be improperly wired in the building.
I recommended that the owner advise the GC of the wiring problem
that was uncovered and ask that he (the GC) engage a competent but
uninvolved Electrical Inspector to evaluate the buildings' electrical system- with particular attention to the integrity of the ground system.

Does this seem reasonable as a first step and should anything else be added to the recommendation?

RE: Unusual Wiring - Comments please

"Disturbed by the wiring mentioned above, I discussed
the situation with an uninvolved Licensed Electrician who opined that the fixture wiring
would have been OK if they had marked the green wire white to show it as a neutral.
Is there any support for that opinion here on this forum? "

if that's true, the "electrician" is an idiot and needs his licensed pulled.

RE: Unusual Wiring - Comments please

Ground is a safety, it is not used in the circuit till something fails.

Are these on/off switches or 3way?

Are there two switches?

Black at the switch and white painted black indicates a switch loop. You cannot have both wires from the switch go to two different fixtures, one has to be the infeed power and the other will go to the fixture. Check the first fixture again for a white painted black.

RE: Unusual Wiring - Comments please

Green is a ground wire. It can not by code be remarked white for use as a neutral.

RE: Unusual Wiring - Comments please

Why ask for comments if you really don't want any? What you described is a very dangerous situation and should be repaired immediately by a licensed professional. To answer your questions directly; No there is no legal justification. It is highly illegal and potentially lethal to use a ground wire as a substitute for a grounded conductor. As to how the owner should proceed; he should increase his fire and liability insurance before doing anything else, because you have posted publicly the situation and he is aware, his liability has increased dramatically. There are attorneys that are just waiting to find out someone was injured or died from this situation. I also don't know why you take the simple truth as flames. I have no dog in this fight, but your laissez-faire attitude could end in someones injury or worse, and at that point you may also be liable to some degree.

RE: Unusual Wiring - Comments please

Okay. I have no idea what in my post constitutes an "illegal string" but I'll be darned if I'm going to play some sadistic web designer's games.

A screenshot of my post:

Okay, let's see your string parser filter a jpeg.

RE: Unusual Wiring - Comments please

Thanks to all for the input.
Pharkus- Thanks for your input especially- I have no intention to fix it- but the fix you suggested would certainly eliminate the immediate problem.

My concern is about the hundreds of other parts of the system- some of which may have been done improperly as well- and which could be more dangerous. On the strength of this one example the day after this was discovered I strongly advised the owner to get the whole building inspected and repaired as necessary.

I apologize for misusing the handy term "bx"- it is of course MC. Showing my age I guess.

And Hexus- no he is not an idiot- just wrong this time. We usually discuss such issues thoroughly and come to a conclusion where he is right most of the time. But this time we didnt get to talk about it together- his comment was made to a third party and didnt get massaged by thorough discussion.

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Electrical Wiring Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here