Return to the Electrical Wiring Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
GFI in garage, can't find it

Posted by jbander (My Page) on
Wed, Mar 7, 12 at 20:03

The three original plug ins, in my garage don't work. The one on the farthest to the electric source has "protected by GFI" written on it but inside there just seems to be a switch and a plug in it but no reset button, for the life of me I can't find a GFI. The house was built in the early 70's. What should I be looking for, do they look like the way they look now or are they different?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

No they still have the test and reset buttons check the bathroom gfci outlets if you have them that may be the problem or check the panel for a gfci breaker or check elswhere check all the gfci outlets in your house odds are one is tripped that protects the garage they used to do it that way.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

As ranger points out, the common mode in the 70's was to have one GFCI receptacle protecting all the receptacles (bathrooms, outside, garage) that required it.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

Success, The main (GFI)was the one that the automatic garage door opener is plugged in, in the ceiling. Now since I took every outlet apart to look for the GFI , I will be spending my morning putting things back together. Thanks everyone


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

"The main (GFI)was the one that the automatic garage door opener is plugged in, in the ceiling. "

One of the few places in a garage that does NOT require GFCI protection.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

Yeah - I'd replace that GFCI with a single outlet and move the GFCI downstream to a more accessible outlet. Or install separate GFCIs at each location - they're no longer prohibitively expensive.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

In the 2008 and 2011 NEC, I do not find an exception that would exempt the garage ceiling receptacle from the GFCI protection requirement. If it was up to me, that location would be exempt. Why any thinking electrician would install a GFCI receptacle on the ceiling and use it to supply other receptacles downstream is simply beyond reason.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

"One of the few places in a garage that does NOT require GFCI protection."

That is not true. Garage door opener receptacles DO require GFCI protection as of the 2008 code.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

Then I'd leave it. But install a second GFCI for the other outlets.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

I would change it to a duplex or single receptacle and install a gfci breaker. That way, if it ever trips again, you don't need a ladder to reset it.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

Thanks everyone, you people are great!


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

HEXUS.....Our local AHJD or head electrical inspector does not make us put the opener on a GFCI. Instead he allows that outlet to be a single outlet that only the opener is then pluged into. Thus eliminating the issue of the door not being able to open when you return from shopping in the rain and cant get into the house cause the outlet is tripped.....Some of us dont have keys for any of the house doors with us and we always just open the garage door to get into the house so he lets that one go. LOL.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

"HEXUS.....Our local AHJD or head electrical inspector does not make us put the opener on a GFCI. Instead he allows that outlet to be a single outlet that only the opener is then pluged into."

then he isn't following 2008 and up NEC. If you're under 2005 code, that's wonderful. It's not an issue if you or I agree with it. I especially don't agree with local AHJ's changing things to fit their opinions if that's the case. People can't do what they want because they think they're smarter and know what's better than the NEC.

All receptacles in a garage are required to be GFCI protected.


 o
because I know people will argue

since I can't edit my post...

make the last line of my above post "All 120V 15 and 20 amp receptacles in a garage are required to be GFCI protected."


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

Recently we had a lengthy power outage in our neighborhood because a poll fell down. Many neighbors could not get in their homes because the garage opener wasn't working and they didn't carry door keys! All of the doors in our home all use the same key which I always carry on the car key chain. Also, my garage opener is NOT on a GFCI.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

The risk from a ceiling mounted receptacle to power a garage door opener not being GFCI protected is infinitesimally small.

That is why the exception was there in the first place.

It sounds more like lobbying by the GFCI manufacturers than anything actually safety related.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

It really doesn't matter what you think or how smart you are, or think you are. Unless you're on the code writing panel and can actually implement the exception again, you can complain all you want.
The SER exception removal, required neutrals at every switch, arc fault implementation, etc... etc... were all lobbyist too, right?


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

I actually have participated in code panels (I was a second for my employer for many years) though not for the past few cycles.

It requires an enormous amount of support from an employer, and I am simply no longer active in that area.

That does not mean my knowledge suddenly evaporated.

There is plenty of industry lobbying on many of the panels.

It is an excellent method of ensuing sales, especially if you can also establish patent protection on the underlying technology.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

"I actually have participated in code panels"

that matters why? Are you on a panel currently? Can you change the current code requiring GFI protection to all garage receptacles?
No? Then you're argument means nothing, and telling people to do things against code just because in your opinion it doesn't matter is complete BS.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

I saw no post advocating code violations. The NEC panels are populated with, among others, representatives of manufacturers of electrical equipment and devices plus labor union representatives of both the installing trades and the manufacturing trades. Combined, their interest is in requiring the use of more material and more labor. The consumer pays.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

his post of
"One of the few places in a garage that does NOT require GFCI protection."

I would say that he made a mistake and didn't know or understand the code except he kept arguing that he doesn't agree with it and how foolish it is.
You're missing the point. It doesn't matter that lobbyist, representatives, or drunk monkeys are on the NEC panels. If it's in the book, it must be followed. You and no one else are exempt from following the NEC just because you think you're smarter and know better.
If you don't like it, get out of the trade, or do something to change it.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

It was a legitimate excretion for many years.

Since no one probably continued to ask for its inclusion, out it will go.

I am not under the most resent NEC revision.
Virginia adopts codes under the 'Uniform Statewide Building Code' law and adopting every version of every code is not a high priority.
We typically do no better than every other version.

No one claimed an exemption, just a comment that it is a foolish requirement, and mot in keeping with numerous other code exceptions like 'n place equipment' exceptions.

Your failure to realize that there is politics at play among the code writing participants is just foolish.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

The exception was removed two code cycles ago...
I never said I didn't realize politics play a role, but I'm not going to sit around and complain about it. I have to play the game and jump through hoops and do things I don't agree with. However I don't claim that I'm superior to the nec and smarter like you do though.
The SER cable exception was removed two code cycles ago too and I don't agree with it. So I guess I can go around telling people to use the wrong size cable for their sub panels?
Arc faults? Pssshh just a scheme from the manufacturers to get more money, you don't need them.

Your arrogance and repeated attempts at trying to argue your opinion over hard written laws and rules is ridiculous.
Trust me, you're really not as smart as you think you are.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

The NEC is not law until adopted by some body with lawmaking authority. Federal law incorporates the latest version of the NEC into OSHA by reference. States and/or cities may adopt it with or without amendments if they wish. The easy path is for lawmakers is just to adopt it as written. Takes only few moments and no effort. To show the careful deliberations that occur with respect to codes, one state building code council goes on a week-long vacation, expenses paid, to the beach in an adjoining state and then comes back with a few amendments to the code. The jaunts have to be justified somehow.
It is best not to watch while sausages or laws are being made. Individuals can express their concerns to the officials in their state or city.


 o
RE: GFI in garage, can't find it

A 'legitimate EXCRETION',. ..KEWL!!!
I had one of those this morning, Brick.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Electrical Wiring Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here