Okna Window construction vs replacement

10 years ago

Hi. I have been reading about windows on this forum for some time and it has really helped me in my search for new windows. I have decided on the Oknawindows because what I have read here. I do have a question though. I was told by a Simonton seller that new construction windows are made of lesser quality than replacement windows because home builders don't want to spend a lot on windows. Is that true?

I asked the Okna seller and he said yes, but that what he is selling me is replacement windows with a full tear out. He said "we know how to install them with a full tear out" so that I am not buying construction grade windows.

Does this sound reasonable?

Thanks. Love the forum.

Featured Answer

HomeSealed

10 years ago

Carmel,
I agree with my colleagues above are saying, however if you analyze what was said by the contractors I don't know that I would say that it is flat out wrong, just in need of clarification.

-Most new construction windows that are used are indeed lower quality, but not because of any inherent defect in the design of a "new construction" window, it is simply because as he was alluding to, most new home buyers are more concerned with their granite countertop color than the quality of their windows. Thus, most "new construction windows" are indeed junk.

-Regarding the Okna guy, I'm going to speculate here that the intent of his comments was to convey that Okna is not primarily a "new construction" window manufacturer. They supply the high-end remodeling market primarily, where folks are far more discerning in their window choices after having been burned by cheap or deteriorating windows. Okna does however offer each of their lines available with a nailing fin for new construction installation. It is the same window, just with a nailing fin added.

Ultimately all comments above including those by the contractors that you've spoken to can be correct, it just depends on in what context these things were said. Technically speaking, in most instances a new construction window and a replacement window are the same save the addition of a nailing fin (and in some cases jamb depth) so no, the quality is not different. That said, many guys will speak in reference to the poor "builder grade" products normally associated with new construction when referring to those products in general, and I'd assume that is what the Simonton guy was getting at....

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

millworkman
10 years ago
Technically speaking they are both wrong! The windows are basically identical with the difference being new construction windows have a nailing flange. I would have serious doubts about any window supplier/dealer/installer who told you that and would be looking for another dealer.
PRO
Windows on Washington Ltd
10 years ago
Ha ha.

Like MWM said, they are both wrong.

Most windows that are used in new construction track building are crap, but not because they are new construction.
Related Professionals
Auburn Window Contractors · Jupiter Window Contractors · East Renton Highlands Window Contractors · Waupun Window Contractors · Fairland Window Contractors · Whitman Interior Designers & Decorators · Endicott General Contractors · Fredonia General Contractors · Randolph General Contractors · Towson General Contractors · Atlanta Carpenters · Bonita Springs Carpenters · Laguna Niguel Carpenters · Sudbury Carpenters · Tucson Carpenters
CarmelClown
Original Author
10 years ago
So, they are using the replacement but doing a tear out so they can charge more money? Should I insist on the new construction Okna's? There is only one dealer in my state that uses Okna.
floryjoe
10 years ago
Whatever the type of window used make sure that the window installation process is done correctly. You will need to find a reputed dealer and if you are doubtful about the dealers intentions, it is better that you find a new one. Of there is none in your state go for the a neighboring dealer or else find some online shops.
mmarse1
10 years ago
You can use a replacement window for new construction if needed... The labor is the same which is much more than standard replacement.

Some window companies do offer new construction that indeed are lesser quality; thinner walls. I can name a few off the top of my head...

Okna uses the same extrusion whether new construction or not which is a good thing. Not all companies do this though.
CarmelClown
Original Author
10 years ago
Thank you all so much, that really eases my mind. I am a widow trying to make a decision about something I know absolutely nothing about. Like I said, I've been lurking on various forums for months reading all that I can. The window company I am dealing with was recommended by a co-worker who had Okna windows installed and loves them. And they get very good reviews on Angie's List. And Home-Sealed, it is good to know that Okna provides the same window for inserts or tear out. I was afraid this guy was going to jimmy-rig a window that wasn't meant to be full tear out.
PRO
Windows on Washington Ltd
10 years ago
Sounds like you are covered then.

Post up some before and after pictures.
HomeSealed
10 years ago
Sounds like you are on the right track :)
Be sure to post back with any questions that you have throughout the process.