Return to the Windows Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
HMI vs Precision patio doors?

Posted by goddi (My Page) on
Thu, Jun 22, 06 at 18:33

I am planning on replacing my patio french style doors and the front entry door. I was planning on going with Precision Entry doors but then one installer suggested HMI doors. They won't have a sample door for a week or so so I have not seen the HMI door yet.
I would like to have anyone's opinion on these two manufacturers.
Thanks... Gary


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?

As a contractor, I've purchased doors from Precision for over 25 years. Super people, great product, and fair prices for all you get. Not familiar with the other name you mention.

Good Luck!


 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?

As someone who worked in the door industry with dealers, I've seen that HMI doors tend to rust and they have paint and other quality problems. Then, they don't take them back or replace them.

Precision doors has always been a class-act in every way.

That was two years ago, but I would still go with Precision.

But it's just my opinion.


 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?

There is no comparison. Precision Entry, soon to be Pro-Via Door, has always delivered the highest quality product in the door industry.

Michael


 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?

I love my door by HMI. I did the research and the door is a better gauge of steel (thicker) than Provia's. The HMI doors also had better security features. I have serious curb appeal and people have been knocking on my door asking where I got my door. I haven't had any rust or paint problems . My friend has a HMI door and she noticed a scratch after it was installed. HMI came right out and gave her a repalcement door while they fixed hers. My HMI door is Energy Star and NFRC certified. I think Provia is a larger company but in my case HMI was great. Just do the research for yourself. I am not a big name brand person- I go for quality! Good Luck on your search.


 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?

"I did the research and the door is a better gauge of steel (thicker) than Provia's. The HMI doors also had better security features."

Nonsense. Both companies offer 20 gauge steel doors. What was the difference in security features?


 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?

Totally misleading!..ProVia Door is a Family owned company!

ProVia offers a 20 gauge door for residential use. The finish, quality and SERVICE far exceed their competition.

That is why the trades call Pro Via....the last door you'll ever need.

I hope you didn't buy HMI's 24 gauge door!

Michael


 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?/

This is a statement by HMI:

HMI is the only home entry door dealer to provide 20 Gauge Steel Surfaces on their doors.

That is untrue. Would you buy a door that uses lying to persuade you? I sure hope not.

Michael


 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?

Michael,

I have to admit I like the idea of having total strangers pulling over and rushing up to my Front door just because it looks so Incredible. Might be a great way to meet people. I wonder if I'd have to set up chairs on my front lawn.


 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?

I had a conversation with HMI this morning. The president of the company agreed to change the advertising to truthful advertising and eliminating the claim that their door is the ONLY 20 gauge door in the industry.

Michael


 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?

I have sold and installed Precision/Sugercreek and now ProVia products for 17 years. They have unparralled quality, support and service. Not to mention they are a great group to work with. For the homeowner a 7 year finish warranty is impressive and thats if they do NOTHING to the door. If they treat it a few times a year with a UV protectant such as Armor All you may get 15+ years on their paint or stain. Thats the key to a door's durability and long term beauty-the paint finish!


 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?

HMI makes one of the best doors in the industry. Whoever said HMI rusts, is misleading the public - they are obviously a competitor. I sell both HMI & Provia and they are both exceptional products. I have HMI in my own home for the past 6 years and it still looks like the day it was installed. I have installed over 100 HMI doors and have not had one complaint. They are the finest quality you can buy. Anyone in the industry can attest to that.


 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?

My experience with HMI hasn't been the greatest. They build a good product but quality control is seriously lacking when it comes to jamb assembly.


 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?

I find that hard to believe. We have been installing HMI Doors for years and NEVER had a problem with their jamb. its a fantastic door and the quality is second to none. as i sai,i do provia as well and its a very good door but HMI is all quality. can't go wrong with either. we just have been doing more HMI lately.


 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?

Jennifer ( Jen73452), you compete with hmi, hence your false and misleading post. i use both provia and hmi .
Both HMI and Provia make wonderful doors. I have had a provia rust a few years back which was a rarity. That said, it was a defect in the way they did the finish, they quickly took care of it. HMI is the same, an excellent door and made extremely well. Both doors will warranty any rust which if it ever happens, its extremely rare.
These are the only 2 doors i would ever install, at least where i am located. I stay clear away from doors like therma tru and jeldwin which to me are just builders grade doors and not made very solid.

This post was edited by doorproz on Tue, Oct 22, 13 at 9:42


 o
RE: HMI vs Precision patio doors?

I love My windows and doors. I find that hard to believe. We have been installing HMI Doors for 2 years by http://nycwindowsdoors.com and NEVER had a problem with their jamb


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Windows Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here