Return to the Windows Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Pressure-treated wood?

Posted by eleena (My Page) on
Tue, Mar 6, 12 at 21:44

Is it good or not when it comes to windows?

Jeld-Wen makes it a big selling point that all their wood windows are pressure-treated and won't rot.

A friend of mine just installed one, w/o any exterior cladding (aluminum, fiberglass, or vinyl) b/c she believed the dealer.

I talked to a Marvin dealer a few hours ago and they said that Marvin wood windows are NOT pressure-treated.

IDK what to think of it. Will they NOT rot faster than Jeld-Wen's then?

I could see that Marvin's aluminum cladding is extruded, unlike Jeld-Wen's which is rolled. Supposedly, extruded is better.

But if the wood is untreated, I am not sure that better cladding will help all that much.

And how on earth would a "mere mortal" know what to believe???

Could you explain which is better?

Thanks!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

Pressure treated wood is only an advantage when the wood is not finished/sealed with paint or stain (like on a deck or fence). Its pretty unlikely that this would be the case for a window, so I'm going to call that more "gimmick" than legitimate benefit. The extruded aluminum however is a major advantage. Roll formed aluminum on the exterior will result in a window that rots sooner... The Marvin vs Jeldwen comparison is Mercedes vs Kia.


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

I do believe that all wood windows are typically treated now.Jeld-Wen just uses a different process which I have no idea which is better. I have seen quite a few marvins with rot though, but Marvins are a little more common in MN. That being said, I have not seen a Jeld-Wen product that I am extremely fond of yet.


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

+1

This is merely branding and if I had to spend money with the expectation that it would last, your money would be better spent with Marvin.


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

+2, In addition by "pressure treated" they do not mean it in the true sense of the word. Basically Jeldwen and most every window company today treats there wood with a version of the product known as Dap Woodlife a basic type wood preservative. This will help but not entirely stop the problem. The key is proer installation, ventilation and maintenance (paint and caulk). Extruded exterior aluminum is far better than roll form (think soda can). Jeldwen basically purchased 3 mediocre at best window companies (Pozzi, Norco, and Caradco) that were not in the best financial shape and renamed them the 3 Jeldwen lines. Nothing that I am aware of made them any better than the units that were produced by the previous owner so I will say they are still mediocre at best. i personally would look at Marvin (previously recommended)and Kolbe (very small step below Marvin).


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

You "guys" are the best!

Thanks!

I have just talked to Marvin. It turns out that their wood IS presssure-treated - whatever that means :-)

And the funny thing is that even the price seems better on Marvin (so far).

OK, so Gled-Wen is out but I am looking at vinyl windows as well. A Simonton dealer rep is coming tomorrow.

Thanks again!


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

At least some of the window makers have tried to use 'pressure treated' to reduce the problems of moisture intrusion past cladding put on the wood (metal or plastic).

The problem is that wood moves with changes in moisture content, and no finish can stop the changes in moisture content.
While metal cladding can stop movement through the metal covered portion (and thick vinyl almost stop it), any exposed wood (like on the interior side) will allow water vapor entry.
The wood then changes shape and size, and starts to work on breaking the seals between the cladding and wood.

Eventually cracks develop between the materials and water enters.
It cannot easily escape, so rot starts in the wood.

Treating the wood is intended to further slow the rot.


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

pressure treated wood!!!
good luck with the aluminum capping..lol


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

Thanks, everyone!

mmarse1,

What do you mean?

A Marvin guy came on Thursday and also said that there would be a problem installing fiberglass windows b/c of the existing frame. I still don't understand the problem and none of them was able to explain it to me, they were just "hand-waving". We are going to go to the showroom again and try to understand better. If that does not work, I'll post a new thread about it. :-)


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

True pressure treated wood (i.e. the stuff you think of on a deck and at Home Depot that is green) is reactive (the chromated copper arsenate) with aluminum.


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

As I stated earlier most all companies use a variation of Dap Woodlife, a clear wood preservative.


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

"True pressure treated wood (i.e. the stuff you think of on a deck and at Home Depot that is green) is reactive (the chromated copper arsenate) with aluminum."

CCA was removed from routine store availability a few years ago.

The newer preservatives often use copper and even attack steel nails, aluminum would be even worse.


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

Ok, I understand the "pressure treated wood!!!
good luck with the aluminum capping..lol " part now.

And, does "The newer preservatives often use copper and even attack steel nails, aluminum would be even worse." mean that the new cladded windows are BS (forgive my French) or that they are NOT really pressure-treated?


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

As I stated all manufacturers that I am aware of use a Clear Wood Preservative and the wood parts are dipped or at the most pressure treated to retention not true "Pressure Treated" which is done until the wood has become saturated to a given point. The chemical they all use for the wood on windows will not nor does not react with metals at all.


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

Thanks for the heads up brickeyee.


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

"Thanks for the heads up brickeyee."

You are very welcome.

CCA treated is till available, just not at the Big Box stores, and at a higher price (it still excels at certain things like docks and bulkheads).

The new treatments EAT steel nails and hardware.

Stainless hardware and nails are around, but of course at a higher cost.


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

So you would run Stainless only in the PT lumber that is out there now.

How about the clima-seal type screws with the plastic coatings on them? I would think that stainless is still the way to go because the plastic coatings melt up a bit when running through the wood.


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

Exactly windows, Stainless is without a doubt the best and actually not much dollar wise more than the climaguard.


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

I simply do not trust any coating to remain intact through handling and installation.

I remember seeing galvanized nails with rusting heads from driving them.

Even thick galvanize (the thickness might have actually made it worse).

Long before stainless screws became required for the new PT chemicals, I was using them for all exposed work.


 o
RE: Pressure-treated wood?

Days in the past Sivaco (Canadian) Nail Co. made an excellent Hot Dipped nail, they were expensive but good. Everything else predominantly Asian or European Imports and even USA made Hot Dipped Galv or even Electroplated Galv nails were terrible and had the issue you speak of Brickeyee


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Windows Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here