Problems with planning, MOH view

14 years ago

I was asked to be the maid of honor in my friend's wedding some time ago. She had moved away from home a few years ago and didn't have many friends she kept in contact with back home (besides me), so I said yes. I'm not that close with the bride, so I felt that this could be a way to become better friends. Unfortunately, she's using her mother to take care of all of the MOH "duties". She even went as far as to ask me when I was going to plan her wedding shower because her mother was starting to get worried that I wouldn't take care of it (the wedding is in December, it's April now). She and her mother picked the venue, the reception hall, the menu, the dress, the decorations, etc etc etc. I feel a little left out but, on the other hand, I don't know her well so I don't really mind her mother stepping in if that is what they want. Besides, I'm happy her mom wants to help because there are things that I need help with (Ie: I have NO idea who to invite to the shower, because I feel like I barely know the bride!)

My problem is that the bride continues to get upset with me and say that I'm "not involved" and "not interested". I'm confused because I repeatedly ask her about all of the details, if she needs help planning, wants help with invitations, etc, and her reply is ALWAYS, "My mom and I already did that" or "my mom is going to do that". How can I "help" when things are already being taken care of, without being pushy? And further, how can I escape the bride being upset with me when I'm not doing anything wrong??

Comments (10)

duckie
14 years ago
For the shower, pick a couple Saturdays a month or two before the wedding and ask her which would work best for her. She might actually need to know that day quite early if she is traveling back home for wedding prep and Thanksgiving and such. Nailing down which days she will need off from work might be a real concern even though it seems like a long way off.

For the rest, ask her specific questions so that she can gush a bit. End your e-mails with 'let me know how I can help'. I supect she is quite happy planning things with her mom, but needs some reassurance that someone has her back if/when she needs it. You might even offer general help to her mom directly. Maybe Mom is getting overwhelmed but not really comfortable letting Bride know, though Bride might well sence that something is wrong.
sweet_pea10
13 years ago
It is a fallacy to assume that the MOH MUST be involved in the wedding planning, host a shower, plan a bachelorette party and all the other things that go with a wedding. Do what you can afford to do and have time to do. I assume the wedding will occur in your home town, and not where the bride currently lives, which makes it more difficult for her. Dickie has given good advice on ways to approach the bride and her mother. It may be that mom knows her daughter's taste and it is simply easier for her to do many things, but she may appreciate your assistance, at least with some things.

The bride and/or her mother can provide a list of people to invite to the shower. If the bride is coming home for Thanksgiving, that weekend might be a good time to plan a shower unless the wedding is in early December.

Do what you can do and what the bride allows you to do and don't become stressed about what her mom is doing. It will all work out in the end.
Related Discussions
Critique my floor plan - small, budget house with a view!
Q
Comments (23)
If you do two stories (walk out basement plus main floor) and have master bedroom up and other two bedrooms down, I would think you would want two bathrooms (or at least two WCs). People sleeping downstairs who wake in the middle of the night needing to use the toilet should not have to climb a set of stairs to get to one. If you want the master upstairs, consider putting the laundry room down next to a downstairs WC and cluster both directly beneath the upstairs bath and WC. That will allow you to cluster the plumbing which helps keep costs down. With a second WC and the cost of building stairs, it might or might not be more economical to build two stories than to spread the whole house out on a single floor. But, given your sloping property and your desire to maximize views, I'd go with two stories anyway. Having a second WC or even a second full bath won't cost THAT much more if you can cluster the plumbing. As for critiques of your latest posted plan. I would agree with previous comments that your living room/dining room area won't work very well. With three bedrooms, one assumes that at least occasionally you will have 3 to 6 people staying at the house. The living room would not be at all comfortable for that many people. Plus, do you expect to watch TV, or converse in the living room. No place for a TV and no room to create a conversation area where people sit so that they can look at one another. As designed, you don't really have a LIVING ROOM. You have a dining room with a sofa off to one side. The trip from the master bedroom to the WC requires you to walk thru your closet (wardrobe), out into the dining area, and then turn back down a hallway. Not a trip I would want to navigate during the middle of the night...especially since I have to admit that I often leave my shoes scattered about in my closet and I'd be tripping over them in the dark. Maybe you're a neat-nick and ALWAYS put shoes away exactly where they belong. But, do you really want the only path to your master bedroom to be thru your closet??? Also, you show no closets except the Master bedroom closet and a very small broom closet. Most of us have tons more stuff that needs to be stored away than will possibly fit into those two small closets. Eg, X-mas decorations, extra blankets, towels, and pillows, off-season clothing, the big bag of dogfood, the vacuum cleaner, the ironing board, board games, umbrellas, recycling bins, etc. With no garage, any of that stuff that you own is going to have to be stored somewhere inside your house. The biggest complaint I hear about new homes when people move in is that they don't have enough storage space...and that is often from folks who have a two or three car garage!. And, the space you have allotted a staircase isn't nearly long enough. Even in Australia, I suspect there are building codes that restrict just how steep a staircase can be. Here in the U.S, for a house with eight foot (2.44 m) ceilings and 1 ft thick joists between floors, you would need a staircase run about 13 ft long (3.96 m). Anything less will result in a staircase that is too steep to meet code. Plus, even if you're not restricted by a building code, if you make the staircase steeper than about 40 degrees, it is VERY uncomfortable to use and pretty dangerous. Definitely NOT something you want to deal with in the middle of the night when trying to get the the WC! Suggest you look up the building codes in your jurisdiction and find out exactly what the staircase requirements are. Then you can do a bit of trigonometry to figure out how much linear space you need to devote to your staircase...assuming it is a straight line staircase. (BTW, please don't think that if you design a bent staircase - a U or an L or some other shape) that you can squeeze it into less space. Every bend makes the staircase take up even more room. You need to understand staircase requirements before you begin trying to design two stories and then block out the necessary staircase space first on both floors. Trying to design any two story space without knowing up front how much space must be dedicated to the staircase is an exercise in frustration.
...See More
A House with a View floor plan
Q
Comments (12)
Thank you all so much for all the suggestions. Goodness, thepond, you really went above and beyond.... You all have given me a lot to think about. I will have to ponder. There are some interesting and surprising points here. In addition to the looks, we chose this particular kind of elevation to have a house from which you could see the long view from every main room--DR/music, family, kitchen, and every bedroom. Transoms over and perhaps sidelights on the 5-ft. wide doors between main rooms downstairs will allow light to flow on a minimum of three sides in the main rooms. Garage needs to go to side (barn or carriage style), not front, to keeps interior views clear and avoid a suburban feel. The full bath downstairs provides for those days when people come into the house too dirty to go any further (happens more often than you think!--I'm also considering another one in the basement). Also, we have one now off the kitchen and I really treasured it when my kids were younger--so much easier (and warmer, in the winter) to let them take a bath there than trompsing up the stairs--but better closer to kitchen, to be sure, I'd like to figure out a way to do that without losing master bath space upstairs. It is also just nice to have an extra full bath when you can, I think, especially if you need to host someone who can't do stairs. My thoughts on the d/music room, fam, kitch placement were as follows: most of our traffic and room-to-room interaction is kitch-family room, it would be bothersome to traipse through the d/music room to get to the fam room. Said traipsing would disrupt the quiet space provided by the d/music room. The quiet/music, usual tidiness and nicer furnishings of the d/music room makes for a pleasant entry into the home and provides a buffer against the chaos happening elsewhere. If you visualize the table area without leaves, brought down to five or six feet and perhaps a little more seating near the piano (may be an upright, we have one now but will be getting something else), the idea of stepping into that space might seem a little more logical? If not, please let me know as I had seen plans entering the side of the DR and had liked them for that reason. The comments about the closets really took me by surprise. Coming from a 200-year-old house, I thought there was enormous amounts of storage space in this one except Bedroom 4. As is, there is actually plenty for the intended occupant and my thought was that anyone following us could easily throw up a wall across the back if they prefer the storage to the view and floor space. Ditto the other bedrooms. Given the amount of usable basement and attic storage we will have, I will be happier with windows and floorspace. On the MBr closet, I thought of the larger space as more of a walk-through dressing area. Our "mess" wouldn't be out, it would be behind doors of some kind. I had been thinking about shortening either the hanging or the other side to put in a dressing bench. But it doesn't seem to be clicking with some of the posters as a dressing area, so I will think on it more. Interestingly, the original floor plan for the elevation swapped the kitchen and family room. The pro to that is that the kitchen then gets all day sunshine and is adjacent to both DR (still to the left) and family room. Also, fam room and mbr can share a chimney for fireplace. The downside is that it throws off the very traditional and practical garage-mud-laundry-kitchen progression...but maybe there is another way.... Please keep the thoughts coming. I would really like to know if this plan is completely off-putting or the flexible, sunny gem we are aiming for.
...See More
GC found problem with kitchen floor plan design
Q
Comments (105)
Looking at bbdf's mock-ups made me realize something: I forgot to add spacers between wall and cab for the cab next to the DW in Plan D. You'll lose at least 3 inches and perhaps as much as 5", depending on door and door handle depth from this cab. If you don't allow for door and door handle depth, you won't be able to open the drawers because they'll hit the fridge door or door handle. Same will be true if you do doors instead of drawers. That means that the cab next to the DW in my Plan D could be as narrow as 15.5". Looking back at the plan posted in your OP, it doesn't look like the drawing (created by the cab maker?) included spacers between wall and cab to allow for the fridge door and handles. That's a big uh-oh. So I went back to bbdf's #7 option and one of LL's lay-out suggestion for fridge placement. I think it's the best solution for your kitchen and one you should revisit. Yes, it takes a bigger bite out of the budget but there are ways to accomplish this without breaking the budget. For instance, choose inexpensive backsplash tile and laminate or wood counters instead of stone (wood would look very true to your kitchen's age, IMO). You can always update finishes later but it's not nearly as easy to update lay-out and function later for minimal investment. Plus you can opt to do the full plan in stages as budget allows. You can either opt for the wider opening and fridge location as bbdf drew up in her post of Wed, Nov 12, 14 at 23:01 or you can remove the wall completely. You'll need to install a beam for either option but moving the doorway and recessing the fridge will require new headers so the cost difference may not be as great as you think to widen the entry or remove the wall completely. Widening the doorway or losing the wall will also open up the view to your backyard from your kitchen, which you only get through the one window now. If you choose the lose the wall between kitchen and laundry area: You gain 4.5" to use along the sink wall (I'm assuming based on the age of your home that it's 2x4 construction, not 2x6 construction). I butted the fridge up against the existing upper cabs (you plan on keeping them, right?). I allocated 39" of width for your existing 36" wide fridge and a surrounding cabinet. Depending on cab construction, that could change by an inch or so. In case you missed it, this plan allows you to keep your existing fridge, which is money you can put towards widening the opening or removing that wall. With the fridge next to the sink run cabs, you don't lose cab storage between fridge and DW. I added a cab with counter across from the fridge. I estimated its height, based on where the window sill is compared to the back door handle. This could be as far as you take the plan for now, keeping existing W/D closet in place. Or you can remove the W/D closet, stack the W/D at the far end (I realize the ceiling slopes but unless it's lower than 6' 6", you should have room to stack the W/D units) and add a 30.5" wide pantry between W/D and fridge. This would give you loads of storage for broom, mop, kitty litter, pantry goods, small appliances, etc. Across from it, I added another 30" high counter above kitty litter pan alcove, dog feeding station, etc. The W/D could be visible, as they are in this kitchen: [[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/san-francisco-white-kitchen-traditional-kitchen-san-francisco-phvw-vp~602970) [Traditional Kitchen[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/traditional-kitchen-ideas-phbr1-bp~t_709~s_2107) by New Holland Kitchen & Bath Designers Rutt Regency Cabinetry Or you can put them behind cab doors like they are in these two kitchens: [[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/chelsea-home-renovation-transitional-dining-room-atlanta-phvw-vp~6950087) [Transitional Kitchen[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/transitional-kitchen-ideas-phbr1-bp~t_709~s_2112) by Ridgewood Architects & Building Designers TerraCotta Studio Now you see it [[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/cow-hollow-residence-traditional-kitchen-san-francisco-phvw-vp~43688) [Traditional Kitchen[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/traditional-kitchen-ideas-phbr1-bp~t_709~s_2107) by San Francisco Interior Designers & Decorators Amoroso Design Now you don't [[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/cow-hollow-residence-traditional-kitchen-san-francisco-phvw-vp~43687) [Traditional Kitchen[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/traditional-kitchen-ideas-phbr1-bp~t_709~s_2107) by San Francisco Interior Designers & Decorators Amoroso Design I changed the small bistro table to a fold-down table attached to the wall. Fold it up when you need it, fold it out of the way when you don't. This will make accessing the buffet storage and side cabs much easier, plus the beauty of that buffet will no longer be blocked by a table. This is the idea but not the execution of what I envision for your kitchen. [[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/alterman-eclectic-kitchen-new-york-phvw-vp~2948642) [Eclectic Kitchen[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/eclectic-kitchen-ideas-phbr1-bp~t_709~s_2104) by Jersey City Design-Build Firms Brunelleschi Construction [[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/alterman-eclectic-kitchen-new-york-phvw-vp~2948640) [Eclectic Kitchen[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/eclectic-kitchen-ideas-phbr1-bp~t_709~s_2104) by Jersey City Design-Build Firms Brunelleschi Construction This style is more what I have in mind for your kitchen: [[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/exterior-traditional-minneapolis-phvw-vp~352298) [Traditional Spaces[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/traditional-home-design-ideas-phbr1-bp~s_2107) by Edina General Contractors John Kraemer & Sons bmorepanic did something like this in her even-smaller-than-yours kitchen but I can't seem to find links to her old kitchen threads (her kitchen was finished several years ago) nor does her kitchen show up in the FKB. She still posts periodically so you could always give her a shout-out asking her to show you her table. As with my Plan D, I moved the range to the left to give you more counter between sink and range. The upper cab to the left of the range would have hinges on the front (facing the kitchen) and side (facing the DR doorway) so that you can access items from either side. Shoot, I can't find the example of this that I had in mind on houzz right now. Pretty sure a GWer (maybe beekeeperswife) has done this so you could also ask for examples of this. Anyhoo, having it open on 2 sides means that you won't lose things in the back reaches of a fairly narrow cabinet. Or you can just have it open to the side and put a false panel on the front. Oops, I forgot to note that the sink cab is 30". I think a 30" apron front sink would be period appropriate. This post was edited by lisa_a on Mon, Nov 17, 14 at 12:59
...See More
Plan review . . . View home on narrow lot . . .
Q
Comments (60)
bubbafide I'm also undertaking new construction on land we bought a few years ago. Like you I sketched some plans myself and saved lots of pictures that I liked. Then we met last July with a custom home builder in the town near our property. We liked him a lot. He told us which local home designer he thought was the best and we signed a contract with her to design the home. Meanwhile the builder visited our site and told us the best place to build and which direction to face. The designer didn't like my plan but I think it helped us with thinking about the functions we wanted in the house. It took us about 6 months of intense discussions and back and forth to finalize the floor plan with the designer and the builder. The home builder and his construction supervisor made a lot of critiques and suggestions to the floor plan. Then we had another intense go-around with all parties on the electrical plan. Then there was a month for the builder to cost out the plan and give us a price quote. They started construction two weeks after we approved the budget. I'm not sure on your utilities but we also had a three-month wait during the design phase for a water well digger to get around to us. (hope you don't have that problem) Last week they started construction on our foundation. This is all to say that I think your next step is to select a custom home builder and then use a designer or architect they recommend since they need to work closely together. I'm in Texas so can't help with specific suggestions but perhaps you could start with looking at home builders who have done a style of house that you like. We went with a home builder whose specialty is environmental issues. Please let me know if you have any questions on the general process.
...See More
gellchom
13 years ago
I wouldn't expect the maid of honor to be involved with planning the wedding. The bride/couple and family/ies do that, and that's what they are doing. Perhaps you'd participate in choosing attendants' dresses, but did you really expect to be involved in choosing the venue, the flowers, the reception menu? Unless they are co-hosting the wedding, attendants don't plan the wedding and reception. It's nice to volunteer to be of assistance with anything they might need, but I certainly don't think they are snubbing you or marginalizing you by doing the planning themselves.

The thing I do think they did wrong was to tell you they expected you to host a shower. But I may be reading that wrong, too -- perhaps you had already offered to do so, and Mom was just asking you WHEN you were thinking of doing it? Nothing at all wrong with that; they have to make sure they keep their calendars clear. It may have been simply that, not a push -- can't tell from the facts given.

As for the bride complaining that you aren't interested or involved -- well, maybe she just feels like you aren't as excited about it all as she wants you to be. Of course you're not -- no one is going to be as interested as she is -- but she seems to need someone to share her excitement. I think that's the most important (really, the ONLY real) job of an attendant: humor the bride and groom through this temporary insanity and help them and their families have a happy time of it. That can be a lot more work than addressing invitations, by the way!
scarlett2001
13 years ago
Little rule of thumb: don't be a MOH for a bride you don't know well. That rarely works out.
nancylouise5me
13 years ago
scarlett, I couldn't agree with you more! I was MOH for someone I knew as an acquaintance not a friend and ended up pushing a cat in a stroller down the isle in a dress I hated. My husband and daughters sat in the back of the hall trying to cover up their smirking faces but I could still see them standing up front. The whole thing was a disaster. It was horrible! So I learned a word I very seldom said....NO! I think beebee is getting off pretty good from where I'm standing. LOL NancyLouise
sweet_pea10
13 years ago
NancyLouise, you have mentioned the cat in the stroller story before, but it cracks me up every time I read it. What in the world was that bride thinking. I feel sorry for the poor cat (and you).
nancylouise5me
13 years ago
Yeah SP, it was horrible. The poor cat didn't like it either. He tried jumping out of the stroller a few times. The FOB finally took pity on the poor thing and just held him for the rest of the ceremony.
Try having a bridal shower and none of the invited guests show up! It was just me, her mother, the bride to be and the one other brides' maid. Total disaster! And the marriage only lasted 1 year. She filed for divorce. Wayne and my daughters still tease me about it.
Maybe we should ask for a new forum on GW. Worst Wedding disasters. Do you think I would win?! lol NancyLouise
scarlett2001
13 years ago
Wow, I haven't heard the cat in a stroller story - is there more? And why a cat in a stroller?

As the wife and sometime-assistant of a photographer, I have seen a lot of weird stuff: dogs in the wedding, kids who screamed through the entire ceremony and once a fistfight at the altar, but never a cat!
nancylouise5me
13 years ago
First let me apologize to beebee for hijacking her post. I'll keep it brief.
Met this woman through girl scouts. My daughter and hers were in the same troupe. Chatted a few times, the girls had same friends, saw each other at birthday parties, etc. She became engaged, left a message on my answering machine that she had some very important question she would like to ask me. Called her back and she asked me to be her MOH. Said I was very flattered to be asked but wouldn't she be happier with a family member or closer friend. Nope it had to be me. So silly me said yes reluctantly. Had one shower at my home for her...well attended people actually showed up. Her mother had a more intimate wedding shower at her apartment...no one showed up. Wedding date is getting closer. Week and a half away. Let's me know that I'll be pushing her cat down the isle in a stroller. Her cat was very old and had been like another child to her. Didn't want to leave him out of the ceremony. My jaw dropped but not wanting to rock the boat kept quiet. Come the wedding day down the isle I walk pushing the stroller with the poor old cat in it. I smile so as to not wreck the pictures being taken. But inside I was dieing of embarrassment. And yes we do have pictures and NOOOO I'm not posting them! lol. I can laugh about it now, sort of. So as I said before I totally agree with scarlett's post. It rarely works out. NancyLouise
robins143
13 years ago
I am late to chime in here bee bee, but I just hosted my daughters bridal shower last month, assisted by her MOH, who lives across the country.
It was easier than you may think. We did it all by email. I did all of the leg work, but I didn't mind. She is my only daughter. I left the contacting the bridal party up to her. She initiated the group emails and collected the $. She asked my opinion on themes, menu and locations. I made suggestions and luckily she loved them. We went with a Breakfast at Tiffany's theme as my daughter is a huge Audrey Hepburn fan.
Each girl volunteered for a specific job and I did the decor since I am crafty. The MOH had a timeline for the shower, and kept it going, with all guests engaged. It was lovely. I got to sit back & enjoy.
Also, don't forget to include the Mother of the Groom in the planning. She is important too and may be a good resource and want to help out. Ours made all of the florals!
So, I suggest you ask the bride for her mom's email and any other bridesmaids to plan the shower & bachelorette.

As far as your role in planning the wedding... your job is to be there to be a sounding board for her ideas and shoulder for her to cry on when she has her meltdowns about the wrong shade of chartruse or green beans almondine instead of asparagus : p The day of the wedding it will be your job to try to keep preparations rolling on time and keep her stress free.

So, as a Mother of a Bride in 18 days (and Groom 4 weeks later, yikes!),it is my opinion that it is not the MOH job to plan the wedding! My daughter & I have happily planned everything together. I say let me savor those last few moments with my little girl, before she is all grown up. And I bet her mother may be feeling that way too.

Problems with planning, MOH view

Comments (10)

duckie

sweet_pea10

Related Discussions

gellchom

scarlett2001

nancylouise5me

sweet_pea10

nancylouise5me

scarlett2001

nancylouise5me

robins143

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US