Return to the Wedding Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
My Shower

Posted by soon2brichmond (My Page) on
Wed, Jan 24, 07 at 11:56

My Maid of Honor is having a party for me, and it will be an out of state shower, and my fience and I have had 2 children together and have a house, which we've had for a few years. There isn't much that we need for our home. I've never been married and still would like to have all the things that women have when they get married. What I have asked my bridesmaids to do is to have a gift card shower, but have on the invite that your welcome to get a card from anywhere and that gifts are welcome. Do this seem to be an ok idea or does anyone else have any ideas?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: My Shower

Sorry, I think it is always tacky to tell people what to get you. If the host of the shower is called for ideas they can say you're all set and suggest a gift card, but to outright tell people to give you a gift card is very rude. Sorry, just MHO. Congrats on your wedding.


 o
RE: My Shower

I am going to have to agree. It's not rude if someone asks the host/hostess what to get for a gift and they say a gift card, but it is rude to put it on an invitation. Word of mouth a great thing though.

If people should purchase housekeeping types of items for you, they usually include gift receipts. Take them back if you have to and get what you need or want, but I really wouldn't put the word on the gift card/cash thing any other way but by word of mouth.


 o
RE: My Shower

I definitely agree. If you don't need gifts, then don't have a shower. From an etiquette perspective, it is considered poor form to ask for money or gift cards for shower gifts; it comes across as only having a shower for the gifts, not to celebrate with you. If you don't need household items, you might have a personal shower or have a tea or luncheon where gifts are not expected.


 o
RE: My Shower

Another vote not to ask for gift cards or have a gift card shower. I agree with all the other posters' reasons. It's rude and appears grasping for you or the hosts to tell people what to get you, which is bad enough if that takes the form of including a registry list, but asking for gift cards is just an inch away from telling people to cough up cash. Your guests may feel offended to receive, and your friends may feel uncomfortable sending out, invitations that in essence say, "You are invited to give money to Bride." As luvmytbear points out, too, as you said you don't care what store gift cards come from anyway, you can easily treat any gift as a "gift card" -- just exchange the item for whatever you want. I also agree that if you don't need anything, why have a shower? I know you want all the traditional fun, and I certainly understand that -- but you can have a recipe or advice shower, a tea, a lunch, a cocktail party; it doesn't have to be a gift shower.

The reason I am posting is not to pile on with the same reasons others have given, though, it's to make another point you may not have considered. A poster a long time ago on a similar thread pointed out that a gift card shower is not much fun. Showers are fun when you get to see all the pretty packages and gifts, especially if the givers didn't all choose things off a registry. Who wants to sit and watch someone open a bunch of gift card envelopes? But you certainly can't give a shower and then not open the gifts at the party -- it would look like a party with an admission charge, not a shower, then. I guess that's why it looks so bad in an invitation to tell or even hint to guests to give cash or gift cards; the invitation says "shower," but when you think of a shower, you think about watching the honoree open gifts, not total them up.

Congratulations to you! Have fun whatever you and your friends do.


 o
RE: My Shower

"f you don't need gifts, then don't have a shower.

Ah, but you aren't the one having a shower--your MOH is having it FOR you.


"all the things"--by "things," do you mean: a shower, a bachelorette party, people asking you about your dress, etc.? Or do you mean pots and pans, specially chosen china, crystal, etc.?

Since gift cards are your solution, since you don't need stuff, I'm betting that you mean you want to have some time when you're the center of attention, and your friends and family fuss excitedly over you.

What a very understandable desire! I think all brides SHOULD have people fuss over them, and I'm tickled that you have a friend who wants to. That means you can enjoy it instead of wishing someone loved you enough to bother.

However, i think I'm the person who said, gift cards aren't much fun at a shower.

So.....register for gifts! Give your hostess & other friends some ideas!

Or, let them pick a theme that will influence gifts (the way an "around the clock" shower does). Trust your friends and family to know that you have an established household. And enjoy the surprise that comes each time you open the present. (that's part of the fun of showers, and Christmas--the surprise. Sure, you'll get some "misses," but that's part of the fun, to me)

Maybe it would be nice to choose a china pattern, and end up with really nice things that remind you of that time every time you serve a special dinner.

Or maybe it would be nice to get fresh things, given with great love behind them. New sheets, in a new color scheme to mark a new time in your lovelife?

So, just let your friends throw any kind of shower they want--let even the theme be their gift to you, and bask in their attention.

And, stop trying to micromanage the guests at your shower or wedding.

"If the host of the shower is called for ideas they can say you're all set and suggest a gift card"
This seems even ruder, actually--if you're all set, then why is she throwing a shower for you? Why not a tea or luncheon?

I think you should register for at least a few things, and you should give your considerate hostess a list of ideas she can pass on if asked--that your decorating style is modern or country or Victorian, what color your bedroom is and whether you have a queen-size bed, how big your dining-room table is, whether your towels are starting to wear out, or that you really want to concentrate on the garden next year and would love plants from the nursery, or power tools.

what does it mean that it's an "out-of-state shower"--you'll have to travel TO the shower? There's a theme--a shoebox shower. Your hostess can point out that you'll have to travel back w/ the presents, and that it would be fun if each item they give you would fit inside a shoe box. Or that the total accumulation of them fits inside a shoebox, or something. They may think of gift cards on their own then, or maybe they'll buy you a neat gadget, or something.


 o
RE: My Shower

My husband and I already had lots of stuff when we got married but it was fun going to register--and a chance for me to see what he liked. How often can you make a guy spend that much time in Macy's expressing choices about towels, glassware, etc. They give them a bar code gun just to keep them feeling that its a "guy thing" and they get to shoot the item.
So I am not a fan of gift cards--and I still have one or two that I must cash in. I suggest you follow the advice others have posted--and not steer guests to only gift cards.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Wedding Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here