DH's Stepfamily Situation

ashley1979

13 years ago

I don't think I've ever talked about DH's stepfamily situation on here, but, believe me, he knows all-too-well how it feels to be from a broken family.

DH has 2 older siblings that share the same biological father. 40 years ago, DH's mom divorced her husband and married the man DH calls "Dad". FIL legally adopted the three kids, so they all have his last name. 9 years later, MIL & FIL had another child; the only biological child of FIL.

FIL was their "dad"...legally. But he didn't treat them that way, and definitely treated his biological son differently. DH has always known he had a different father, but he was only 5 when the other father gave up his rights and FIL adopted him. So FIL is the ONLY father he has ever known.

And he wasn't a very good father, other than providing necessities. DH told me of his struggles growing up knowing that FIL used to coach a baseball team before he adopted him and his siblings, but never came to any of HIS games. Even after all the kids were grown and had moved away, he mentored a kid that lived in their town. He went to this other boy's games and events. DH never understood.

FIL passed away last week and we went to their town to help with arrangements and the funeral. DH had this internal emotional struggle the entire time he was there. He wrestled with loving his dad, but never feeling like his dad loved him. He wonders why his dad would adopt three kids and take care of them, but treat them as outcasts.

So now there is this rumor that FIL put everything in a trust for MIL to be doled out to MIL by....guess who? Yep FIL's only biological child. Leaving teh other three kids out.

For the record, the three older kids don't want anything as far as a will. What they do want is their very capable mother to be able to manage her own money and do what SHE wants.

If the rumor is true (MIL doesn't know if FIL did something behind her back) it was yet another way to favor his only biological child. FIL knew that MIL would want ALL of them to have an inheritance. So by not giving the money directly to MIL, FIL could ensure all the money went to MIL's care or his biological son.

MIL is still very independent and can live on her her for quite some time. It just doesn't seem fair for her to have to run to her kid every time she wants to do anything.

Plus, it would break her heart (as I'm sure FIL knew) if her were not all treated equally. She is such a kind and wonderful person; making sure EVERYONE felt loved and included....even me & DS. DS was even listed as a grandson in the funeral program.

I am thankful to FIL for giving DH a father. God only knows if he would've had one with his biological father. But FIL was cold to the older kids most of the time they were growing up. So it's been such an emotional tug-of-war dealing with his passing.

For my part, as well as DS, we loved FIL. But we only knew him after he was already 70 and more mellow. I never really experienced the coldness the others talk about, but I did experience the favoritism of the bio child.

I don't know. I just needed to talk. Has anyone else experienced any feelings like this?

Comments (2)

lovehadley
13 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Oh gosh, hon. I don't know what to say. That sounds complicated and terrible, so gut wrenching.

I totally think it sounds terrible if MIL would have to go to her son for money, when she is still quite capable herself. How can anyone verify that this trust thing is, in fact, true?

I feel for your DH. :( i'm not sure what to suggest except pray about it, and maybe some grief counseling if the feelings become unmanageable.

I don't know. It is so hard to know peoples' motivations---why FIL adopted the kids, etc. I mean, I suppose one way to look at it is that he gave them a stable home life and provided financially in ways they would otherwise not have had. But still. That doesn't take away the pain or hurt. :(

(((HUGS))) to your DH.

I know what you mean about including, too. My SS was listed---recently, my grandfather received an honorary degree from a university---in the program as one of the great grandchildren. At my grandparent 65th anniversary, he was also listed.

I was so touched by that--and I am not even his mom. It still meant a lot to me that they would include and recognize him.
imamommy
13 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Given that he adopted the older kids 40 years ago, I might assume he did so out of sense of obligation maybe? Or perhaps for his wife, so the children would all have the same name as illegitimate kids used to be treated differently or having kids with different names was not as acceptable back then? I'm only speculating & it's hard to understand what we are not familiar with so I don't really have any advice. I know my grandparents (who would have been in their 90's today if they were still alive, were raised differently. My grandfather was out on his own at 11 or 12, washing dishes & struggling to find a warm meal & bed. He raised three children, giving them the basic essentials but not much else... he didn't have a father to teach him how to be a father but he was a good provider. My dad is also a good provider but has taken it upon himself to work at being different from his father in his parenting of his kids... so I think part of it is finding an understanding of where a person came from than trying to understand why they would do something that someone from THIS generation would consider appalling.
Related Discussions
Complicated StepFamily Situation
Q
Comments (7)
There are a number of issues at work here... And it sounds like you thought your 'belle' might be the solution to all your problems, and jumped in too quickly -- but now, you're seeing the flaws, and there are lots of them. First off, the immigration solution you contemplate is illegal. Not to mention the harm it would do to your daughter. There are many kind and loving women who would accept you, your children and your HIV status. Of course, you have to be available and unattached to look for them. Secondly, your daughter's attention-seeking is also very, very normal. What child would not want to see her father before heading off to school? And what normal child would not want frequent reassurance from the parent who clearly loves her when forced to live with an adult who clearly doesn't and constantly nit-picks. Thirdly, your "belle's" manner of correcting the children is harsh, demeaning, degrading, and perhaps worst of all, contagious. Witness how her own children now scream back at her. Is this the type of conflict resolution or parental correction you want your children to learn? Frankly, 'belle' is not the b-word I would choose to describe this woman. You sound like a gentle man with a lovely way with words. Don't you want your children to learn how to use kind words and deeds to solve their problems? To me, this point is so, so important. And finally, to your HIV status. You should not be forced to keep a secret like that in your own home. Living a lie, as if you were, in fact, a pariah, the way certain unenlightened elements of society may portray you... Every day you 'sneak', you validate that treatment. But at the same time, I am sensitive to the legal and practical realities of things -- Is there an HIV-support center where you could find how courts generally rule in cases like these? You don't want to cost this woman her children... On the one hand, given what we now know of HIV and 'casual transmission' chances, I don't think it's any of the kids' father's business what your medical status is. But on the other, as a parent, if my child were living with someone with HIV, I would want to be sure he was taking all appropriate steps to keep himself safe. Bottom line -- Lose this 'belle' and the last point becomes moot.
...See More
Estate Planning in Stepfamilies
Q
Comments (151)
If SM is the wife than she gets the inheritance. If exwife had put in money towards any investments or insurance than I would assume that would have been handled during the divorce. It may suprise you to know, KKNY, that even though most of us are SMs our role in life is not singularly defined by this. We are actually wives and "real" mothers who want happy lives. If a man marries a woman after his children are grown than I suppose it is up to him to decide who would get his inheritance. If my dad died today, God forbid, I would not expect a dime of his money. It would rightfully belong to his wife and she should use it to enjoy her life. I am an adult! You, KKNY,are just so insanely jaded that it is crazy. All SMs are not evil people lurking around waiting for their spouse to die so they can reap all the benefits and say screw you to the skids. Get over it. "as to Mom1SM2 -- there is a difference between kids having to grovel to SM or otherwise watch all, including what dad worked for go to SM kids. That decision should not be left up to SM." Did it ever occur to you that said father would think his kids need to get up of their knees and get a job???? Again, it is up to the person who has the inheritance to decide who gets it. The decision is not up to the SM it is up to the wife of the deceased who may also be a SM.
...See More
This has nothing to do with stepfamilies
Q
Comments (4)
Apparently, my navigation took me the shortest route and obviously didn't know someone put a chain across the road. I did a google map and looked at it from a satellite and saw an alternate road in. I got better directions from that and instead of the short route (37 miles), I had to go 58 miles but I found it. Unfortunately, nobody was home so i go back in the morning.
...See More
Stepfamilies
Q
Comments (31)
"Ima, FD clearly said, as you quoted EVERY TIME. Which means just what is said." What are you babbling about??? I only addressed TOS. I didn't say anything to FD. "In that case it is up to the mother to convince her daughter to come - which shouldn't be too hard if she has "big plans." Presumably if her daughter didn't want to go because her mother had embarrassed her by yelling at her in public, she would have to sense to apologize. It is not, however, acceptable to cancel at the last minute - either the parent or the child - except in an emergency." Agreed. The father in OP's situation should be allowed to try to convince his children to come see him. He has big plans (a wedding) and without knowing them, nobody can say how the kids feel about it. If they resent dad getting married, then of course they'd refuse to go. But, if mom has guilted them into declining, then he should try to convince them how important it is for them to be there. It really isn't acceptable to cancel at all (not just last minute) unless something more important (emergency) were to come up. If the kid has a championship or activity they are really looking forward to, dad should understand. If they have no plans, then they should be encouraged to spend time with the other parent. The parent should only cancel if they might lose their job or some other major reason, not because they just don't feel like it or they have a date or some stupid reason that is going to make their child feel unimportant. Showing our children they are a priority will teach them how to prioritize their own lives. (and I kinda think that is what finedreams is saying and I agree. If the parent doesn't show them they are their priority, then eventually, the child will decide on his/her own that the parent isn't a priority either) [makes me think of that song: cat's in the cradle]
...See More

DH's Stepfamily Situation

Comments (2)

lovehadley

imamommy

Related Discussions

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US