boyfriend has 5 kids

15 years ago

I need advice! I've been seeing this 44 year old man for just under 5 years. He is the perfect man for me, except that he now has sole custody of 5 kids between the ages of 6 to 12 (he's divorced, she lost custody shortly after we had met five years ago). I've explained when the situation changed that I think it would be best for a few years that we maintain separate houses (we're within walking distance of each other) until his children are a little older and less needy of him. From my own experience, I didn't think it was wise to interject myself on a permanent basis (yet) into a new and already stressful situation. This close co-location was affording us balance and seemed feasible until we could look into moving in together when his kids had reached some independence. I am a 45 y.o. working single mom of one 13 y.o. girl.

Here's my dilema - this arrangement seemed quite suitable to him and so we've been doing this. Now he's met someone else who is a mother of 2 (12 & 14). Although not an assurance that she will undertake his situation, he's apparently now changed his mind about everything. Now that I am aware, I'm hurt by the betrayal, but I'm wondering too for the sake of closure: was I wrong to not move in with him and become this instant "substitute mother" to 5 that he now apparently wants? Bearing in mind that this used to be suitable to him, was it not wise to allow his kids the right to a more balanced environment until a time for us could happen? Am I wrong?

Featured Answer

colleenoz

5 years ago

I’m sorry to say, but going by the evidence of everyone else’s experience, it will not turn out well. Your BF’s kids are unlikely to have an epiphany and suddenly like you, and you will come to resent their attitude and wish you had not hitched your horse to this particular wagon and wasted years of your life in unhappiness.

You really need to consider if this is truly the life you want- remember, at the beginning of relationships, people are on their best behaviour, so the politeness will eventually fade. Do you want better? If so, move on and wait for something better. Even if you don’t find another partner you will still be happier than being with a partner whose children treat you poorly.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

finedreams
15 years ago
i dated a guy once who told me isn't interested in marriage or children ever. but he said he loved me and wanted to be wiht me. Nonetheless I broke up wiht him because I wanted marriage and children. In few months he met someone else and they got married rather quickly and now have two children. My point? he was not interested in marriage or children WITH ME. but was prefectly fine wiht the other person. I just was not right for him. was i hurt? of course. But what could i do? he didn't want to marry ME or have children wiht me. In fact i was happy I didn't stay and wasted my time.

I have other examples from other people's lives.

it could be that he changed his mind because he has met someone else and she might seem more suitable partner for him. That's what usually happens.

it could also be that he got tired of just dating for 5 years and wants to live with someone. if i would date someone for 5 years wihtout formal commitment, i would probably move on on someone else too. 5 years is a long time.

it could also be that she didn't mind having that many kids while you did. Honestly I do not want to have 5 kids at home and I would not date anyone wiht that many chidlren just because it is not my cup of tea.

maybe next time you should date people with fewer children or none to eliminate the problem.

also if someone didn't want to live with me because of my daughter being too young, I wouldn't even wait 5 years and move on right away.
imamommy
15 years ago
In my opinion, you got LUCKY! L-U-C-K-Y !!!!!!!

It was suitable for him to have your companionship when it was convenient but taking care of 5 kids is a lot of work, and he was more than likely looking for an instant substitute mother for his kids and while you would have fit the bill, so does anyone that is willing apparently.

I think you should move on and be grateful you didn't put your daughter in a situation with a man that will change his mind about you because he may have a better prospect. If this prospect falls through, my suggestion is RUN RUN RUN. If he truly cared about you and a future with you, he would have discussed other options than meeting a new woman that 'might' be more suitable.
Related Discussions
5 kids, LG Tromm, Epic, Bosch or Harmony
Q
Comments (12)
If you need easy I would stay away from front loaders. I had a Bosch 500 for a couple weeks before I traded it for a Cabrio HE. You have to be very careful about the amount of detergent you put in. My Cabrio also uses HE detergent, I am using the same stuff I used in the Bosch (All Free and Clear Small and Mighty HE), but it is much more forgiving about the amount of detergent you put in. It is also much easier to use in general, and it rinses a lot better. I have serious skin problems and I had to use triple rinses on all my loads with the Bosch using a 1/2 TBSP of triple concentrated detergent, even then my skin was still itchy. With the Cabrio I use 1 TBSP of the same detergent and a single rinse. That said, if you have people that refuse to follow directions, I would stick to a traditional TLer. With the HE TLers you do have to be careful how you load them. I load my stuff around the outside of the tub leaving the washplate uncovered. I have never had a problem with tangling or wrinkling. And it will definitely handle a king size comforter. So unless you can find some way to train the others, or keep them away from the machine, I would think there could be problems. You should try Lowes if you have one near you, they have a great return/exchange policy and the extended warranty is cheap there. It does sound like you should definitely buy the extended warranty. By the way, I had a 10 year old Kenmore Super Capacity Plus washer that I replaced, I could fit my king size comforters in it. The Cabrio is a lot easier to load and unload the comforters, but they did fit and clean well in the old Kenmore. So you might want to look for the largest capacity traditional TLer you can find and see if that will fit your comforters.
...See More
my boyfriend's kids bad behaviour
Q
Comments (4)
Thank you for your input. I do believe that nothing will change and the kids will always just get their way and be spoilt to their own detriment. I can't live like this because myself and my brothers were not raised this way. I am not use to bad manners and no respect. It infuriates me almost daily and makes me not like the boys. Some people might think that kids don't know what they doing, but trust me they know exactly how to behave to get what they want and its always bad. Sometimes I think they just not normal kids because I have never seen this before. But i do understand that the father and grandparents are to blame because the kids learn from them. When I know the kids are coming to visit, the anxiety builds up every single time without fail and that isn't normal. I can't accept this for the rest of my life and I guess at the end of the day it is okay if I get out. I just had to come to terms with the entire situation and that it really isn't normal behaviour because my boyfriend made it seem like I'm overreacting and that I take things too serious. Thank you
...See More
Boyfriend has a daughter? 'Awkward?'
Q
Comments (23)
I'm glad to have some feedback on being a 'mentor' (assuming we do take our relationship to a more serious place). I'd think/hope that being a mentor of sorts would probably be the most beneficial and less awkward route to take for his daughter, myself, and my boyfriend. Maybe serve as a...mediator/bridge between the two? I want her to respect me and see me as somewhat of an authoritative figure, but I also want her to know that she can come to me with teenage things or frustrations a girl wouldn't normal be able to tell her parents. When my boyfriend and I first discussed his daughter (a while ago), he seemed to assume that I would be a mentor for her and help calm him from being a ridiculously overprotective/clueless dad; and I agree, I think that is definitely a position I could fill if this were to work out. But we'll see, it'll take some time and serious thought & communication to see if this is where I want to go in life. @Amber, I wasn't really suggesting coupling counseling, but more of an easement/adjustment counseling. And only if the situation needed it. Counseling is not only a 'fix' for bad things, it's also a way to PREVENT bad things; and the only time I would consider counseling, is if my boyfriend and I thought there might be a potential issue with his daughter. And it wouldn't be counseling to 'fix' a bad thing, but rather to help all of us ease into a new life. I imagine (IF we do get married...way later on) his daughter would find at least a little discomfort in having a 27 year old suddenly as an 'authoritative' figure in her 14 year old life. Plus, 14 is a difficult age for girls anyway. So if the situation seemed to need it, I think counseling would be a very helpful way in easing into the transition, establishing my 'role' in their family, and helping her to see I'm not looking to be a new mom or overstep my boundaries. Counseling would allow her to tell me what she wants/looking for, what I want, and what my boyfriend wants. But again, this would only happen if we were to marry later on and foresee a potential tension. So I'm going to have to disagree with you on the pre-marriage counseling being a bad omen. @mkroopy, thank you for making me sane again! I'll admit I definitely fell into the doubt 'trap'. I am confident in my boyfriend's loyalty, but when several people suggest otherwise, I do begin to doubt slightly (also doesn't help that I'm a serial worrier about everything!) But you are correct, men (& women) can definitely be faithful and it's disheartening to see that so many people think otherwise. So, just for the sake of pacifying anyone else's concerns...there is a very low chance my boyfriend is cheating, and if he is, then I will eventually learn my lesson, but I can't go about my relationship distrusting him. He works Monday-Friday from 11am-7pm, goes to the gym/runs errands, and then gets home at 11 pm. The only time he would be able to 'cheat' would be on the weekends, which is when he has his daughter, so he wouldn't be able to. I think he's much too busy and occupied with his daughter and me, that even if he wanted to, there would rarely be a time for him to cheat.
...See More
Should I leave my boyfriend?
Q
Comments (25)
sorry this is a long vent... Fingernails: aye, yes and it was difficult. his birthday so i agreed to go out one last time, i'm going away on business soon anyway so i felt like that would protect and reinforce that not seeing each other until that list is finished... i know it was screwed up to go out with him but somehow i really feel like everyone deserves a nice birthday... but then he wanted to "talk" about that list, started going over it, like "ok well, the thing about meeting with his teacher every week.... can you go with me? and, i don't know if every week is going to be possible, i mean, she might get really annoyed." I said "well, hello, i mean it just means contact once a week to get her observations on him... so after the first meeting or two in which you explain the situation you can just call her once a week." Reasonable, no? I mean, wouldn't any teacher have sympathy for a single father who appraoches her saying he's struggling and needs her feedback? But then he still wanted me to go with him... my heart was torn but I was like "no, listen, it doesn't sound like you really want to do this stuff on this list. if you don't agree with it, if you don't think you're at crisis point enough to tell the teacher, hey listen sorry Ms. Teacher to be bugging you, i'm only doing it because i'm at wit's end over my son" ... well if you don't think you're at crisis point yet that you're still worrying about what she'll be annoyed with and what she thinks about you... then you're just not ready. (And besides, I mean wouldn't it be strange for me as girlfriend to go along to such a meeting? it's not my kid! Plus not so much teacher's impression but my point that BF should be doing this stuff HIMSELF! though later i thought, maybe he's worried she'll think he's coming on to her and that's why he wants me along... and then i felt bad for refusing) Then he wanted to move on to the other stuff, and I sensed he was trying to turn it into some kind of bargaining session. He was like "hmmm maybe I can do 60% or 80% of this but not all..." Remember the list was: going to family therapy 8 sessions, hiring a baby-sitter every single time we go out, talking to boy's teacher once a week, reading 5 books on parenting, my ex getting a real bed for himself and sleeping in the second bedroom not in the living room.... I thought "what on earth?! an ultimatum is an ultimatum! this is not negotiable!" Like him saying "oh maybe it's going to be hard to get a baby-sitter, i mean if it were a regular job fine, but it would be hard to get someone say for the weekend if we go away, especially if it's only occasionally. (in the ultimatum it said, OR the child just comes along! simple no?) I blew my top then, not literally but just said "hey it doesn't really sound like you're ready to make real changes so whatever... it's your call..." which unfortunatley turned into this long coversation on whether he is truly ready, etc... at which point i said "listen there are some deep underlying issues here which i don't think it's good to hear about from someone like me, we're too close, but a therapist could help you figure it out reasonably quick if it's a good one." At which point he says "yeah well actually i'm thinking more about calling my cousin who's a pediatrician... " at which point i thought "great a pediatrician is really going to help you figure out your parenting... especially if it's your relative who needs to stay on good terms with you!" but i humored him adn said "that sounds like a great start, ask her opinion about the situatin, maybe ask her if she things family therapy would help" but then he continues "because you know she met my son a couple years ago, spent a day with us, and she told me she thought my son was going to have problems." INside i'm like "what the #$%$#!!! a professional told you that, two years ago, and you never followed up on that?! You never asked her why she thought that, and what you could do about it? I sure as heck would be concerned if a pediatrician told me that. I'd ask a thousand questions and call that person whenever problems did happen!" More and more I just can't believe this guy! we left with me saying "ok well call me way way down the road, and if and only if there have been radical changes." which he kind of took to mean never. so in that sense my ultimatum has failed, it seems by saying i wasn't going to budge on it and wasn't going to go with him to see teacher, like he gave up... I feel bad but I think I have to save my sanity no? Thanks all for just letting me vent. Sorry to have taken up so much of everyone's time!
...See More
lamom
15 years ago
I agree with finedreams, it could just be that this new person is a better partner for him with the five kids. You didn't do the wrong thing, you did what thought was best for yourself, your DD and your relationship.

I have a cousin with custody of her two kids who met her husband with two kids in joint custody. They decided together to NOT merge their households even when they got married. Their reason was it was easier for the kids at the time to not be forced in to a blended family situation, their ex-spouses were not thrilled about the marriage at the time, and since they had already been maintaining separate households financially that they would just keep doing it. Also, both had been through terrible and expensive divorces so they wanted to stay separate financially.

Theirs is one of the happiest marriages and blended families that I know in large part due to not forcing everyone to live together Brady Bunch style. You did the right thing. He just moved on, that happens.
cindy_pond
15 years ago
count your blessings. This happened to a friend of mine. She moved in with a man who had 5 kids she had 3. She did everything for his kids. they called her mom. He broke up with her while driving across the george washington bridge after a number of years. Real sensitive...He married someone else shortly after. lesson learned!!
disengaging
15 years ago
In my opinion, you got LUCKY! L-U-C-K-Y !!!!!!!

I totally agree! And I not only think you did the right thing, but made the responsible decision--first for yourself, but even more so for your daughter.

It may be hard to say with any degree of certainty, but it really does sound like he was looking for someone to play "mommy" and help him take care of his kids. I don't necessarily see anything wrong with that in itself, but after 5 years, I think the LEAST he owed you was to break it off with you first before starting to see someone else.

If he actually cared about YOU, he would have let you know, so the two of you could at least TRY to work out a mutually acceptable compromise. For example, buying a house together with an in-law apartment for you and your daughter and waiting a while longer before gradually blending the 2 families.

Any guy (or woman) worth keeping isn't going to go off in search of a "better deal" while they're still involved in a relationship with someone else. I personally would not want to be with someone who could disrespect ANYONE in that way. For me, there would alway be the question, "If he could do it to her, how do I know he won't do the same to me?"
Kasey Parry
5 years ago
I'm in a similar situation. I've been with a man for some time now, he has joint custody of 5 children. I love him very much just don't know what to do, because you see he has expressed many times he loves me as well but his children barley like me, thier polite when need be when I'm around, but I've caught a few things, a glare, rolling of the eyes, snickering, not saying thank you to me when I've done something for them, and a few complaints. Right now the situation is a bit complicated. I stay at his house most of the time when the weekend he has them comes my daughter and I are at my place. I'm not sure what the future holds for him and me, right now we are playing it all by ear. I have no idea what the future holds for us all I do is hope it turns out well.

boyfriend has 5 kids

colleenoz

Comments (7)

finedreams

imamommy

Related Discussions

lamom

cindy_pond

disengaging

Kasey Parry

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US