Return to the Soap & Candle Making Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Which is Your Favorite Soapmaking Method?

Posted by just_me_6 (My Page) on
Wed, Oct 20, 10 at 8:15

Just wondering which kind of soap everyone prefers to make and why . . .

Do you prefer Melt & Pour? Or do your prefer to make soap by rebatching? Or maybe you make your soap completely from scratch by the cold process method using lye?

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Which is Your Favorite Soapmaking Method?

I like Melt& Pour. It is simple and you can get some very high quality, all-natural bases. Also, I don't want to handle lye, in my home, so I do not do cold-process.

RE: Which is Your Favorite Soapmaking Method?

I have done hot and cold processes, as well as rebatching, I much prefer the cold process and have done so for over 8 years(maybe more, it doesn't matter).

I used to have 7 accounts (making 10 pounds of soap at a time, with thousands of bars under my belt).

Now, it's just a hobby.
I still like making soap, and our friends know where to get their soap.

RE: Which is Your Favorite Soapmaking Method?

I'm getting ready to attempt my first batch of soap tomorrow afternoon with a friend. I'm not sure which method she's going to teach me. Ronniner, why do you prefer the cold process method? What makes it better?

RE: Which is Your Favorite Soapmaking Method?


I prefer cold process because to me the cosmetics are better, and I don't have to worry about the soap trying to climb out of the pot over the stove (if this what you would use for heat).
The number of times I did hot process, it looks much the same as rebatched soap. (and I hate rebatching!)

Cold processed soap just feels nicer in my hand after unmolding the soap. I also feel that I have more control of the whole process from start to finish. Controling, additives (like colour, herbs, and powdered milk) , temperatures (I judge by feel (I aim for body temp)), tracing (if I'm splitting a recipe (1/2 swirled, and the other 1/2 recipe plain), pouring, and I'm more satisfied with the final product.

Good luck with your lesson.

RE: Which is Your Favorite Soapmaking Method?

I am brand new to soapmaking so asked this question as a way to pick the brains of those of you who make your own soap :-)

Rebatch seems to me to be the easier way to 'make' soap but I would like to try cold process soapmaking at least once. I realize rebatching isn't techinically making my own soap but it seems like a good introduction to soap making. Especially since I haven't been able to find a nearby workshop or class that offers lessons on how to make handmade soap.

I know there are books and internet instructions on soapmaking but I'd feel more comfortable working with a real person in a hands-on class for my first attempt. I live in a rural area of West Virginia so one would think there would be someone around that teaches this but so far I haven't found anyone. I have done internet searches and found people in my area who make it, but not anyone who offers classes. I also live near southern Ohio and eastern Kentucky if any of you know of people in my area who offer lessons.

As a beginner I am also having trouble finding detailed rebatch soap recipes on the internet (such as grapefruit, various herbal bars, lavender, strawberry, fresh laundry scent, etc). Most sites I've come across just give a list of ingredients without any specific guidelines as to how many drops of this or that, and what order to add them.

Can I take a cold process recipe and just ignore all the info at the beginning about lye, etc. and just follow the last few instructions about adding dried herbs, moisturizing oils, scents, and color? I have bought some pre-shredded rebatch base from so that's what I'm starting with.

I am especially interested in the beautiful, artisan soaps that I've seen on the internet (link below). I actually emailed the lady who makes these soaps and she is thinking of offering an online tutorial soon but, again, it's not a hands-on lesson like I'm looking for. I think her soaps are just beautiful but I'm wondering if a person could do ever do this with rebatch.

Thanks for your help!

Here is a link that might be useful: DeShawn Marie Handmade Soap

RE: Which is Your Favorite Soapmaking Method?

Hello just_me_6,

I haven't been coming here often lately, not enough traffic,and I've been busy doing other stuff
In rebatching, you need soap to begin with. The trick with this method is to get the amount of moisture right; I can't stress this enough. Depending on how much soap, I'm talking about less than a cup of water/milk/?. And only start with tablespoons of the liquid.
Then it is reduced, maybe by grating.
Heat is applied, crockpot or microwave, and other ways as well.

Normally, you need some moisture, depending on how recent the soap base was made; the newer the soap base, the less moisture is needed.

The soap is melted, this is very hot with crockpot or stovetop, enough to burn you.
All the while, you are over the pot stirring the melted soap, making sure that is not rising out of the pot and that it is not too dry.
Once everything is melted and maluable, you can add some of the additives, like botanicals .
If the soap is hot, do not add your scents, these will burn off almost immediately. Add your scent as late as possible and still be able to pour the soap into your molds.

Soapers, generally, are a generous bunch, so send ing an E- mail to someone in your area just may get you an invite, and only cost you some baking goods.

Good luck!

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Soap & Candle Making Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here