Return to the Home Repair Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Rot - Old Wood Vs New

Posted by weed_cutter (My Page) on
Thu, Nov 5, 09 at 19:16

A little rant here. I do home repairs for a living. I face this situation all the time and just don't have an answer.

Why does 50 year old wood (doors, jambs, windows, siding) just seem to keep going and going. When it's finally gone if I replace it with "new" wood the stuff rots in 5 years.

I use PVC jambs and fiber cement siding whenever I can, but many times PVC isn't in the budget and fiber cement won't match the existing stuff.

Is there a place to buy "good wood"? Is there such a thing anymore? The local lumber yards carry the same quality as the box stores as far as I can tell.

I've used both latex and oil primers as well as back priming. I don't use cheap paint. Might make some difference but not much. The old stuff certainly wasn't back primed. Finger jointed trim just blows up in a year no matter what I do.

The eve overhanging the new door isn't any less than the old door either.

Thanks for listening and throw me a bone if you have one.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Rot - Old Wood Vs New

Lumber back in the "good ol' days" was typically harvested from old growth lumber compared to new growth used these days. While I dont condone the timber methods back in the day, the lumber certainly was better. Also faster proocessing from the mills,ie; kiln drying, has negative effects on certain species as well.


 o
RE: Rot - Old Wood Vs New

Try woods like mahogany and Spanish cedar for exterior woodwork. They seem to be the new equivalents of old white pine in terms of longevity. You still need to backprime and seal all end grain, and practice proper caulking techniques (summed up by: "always leave the water an escape at the bottom")
Casey


 o
RE: Rot - Old Wood Vs New

(summed up by: "always leave the water an escape at the bottom")

Very important to have a drainage plane in many applications.


 o
RE: Rot - Old Wood Vs New

You do not have to have old growth to have better wood, just slow growth.

Much of the managed wood is from softwood trees bred to grow as quickly as possible.

This produces larger growth ring spacing and wood that is not as rot resistant as even slow second growth wood.

True old growth wood has very tight annual rings and is denser and stronger than modern fast growth trees produce.


 o
RE: Rot - Old Wood Vs New

Many folks will opt for a Mahogany front door, but I couldn't even talk myself into parting with that kind of dough for the side garage entrance or the shed. A door with just a PT jamb is always special order, double in price and I get an attitude from the millwork guys like "why do you want something like that".


 o
RE: Rot - Old Wood Vs New

Jambs are easy to make with a table saw.

A split jamb is not really required if you make it up from scratch.


 o
RE: Rot - Old Wood Vs New

Weedcutter, you're absolutely right.

Brickeyee,

You're in NoVa, right? Do you know what kind of exterior trim boards (corners, fsscia, etc) they typically use around here, particularly on the multi-unit developments? That stuff also rots like crazy after 8-10 yrs (if not sooner) and I'm just wondering what it is. A couple apt buildings just went up in Bailey's Crossroads with what appears to be the same stuff - can't wait to see how long it lasts.


 o
RE: Rot - Old Wood Vs New

"Do you know what kind of exterior trim boards (corners, fsscia, etc) they typically use around here, particularly on the multi-unit developments?"

Finger jointed white pine is the one I replace most of the time.

Often with the cheapest primer and a single coat of cheap paint, sprayed and not back brushed.

The lousy finishing makes it go even faster.
With a good finish it would last a lot longer.

I just replaced some trim on a rental in Arlington.
It was the original trim from the 1950s the house was built with.

The previous owner did little to no exterior maintenance, so there was some rot at the ends of the fascia, and the small pieces wrapping around to the gable.
The rest of the wood remained solid enough to make cutting away just the ends and replacing only about 4 feet on each end worth the effort.

I have a house from the mid 1930s that still has some original trim (where additions did not cause removal).

The older stuff looks better than the newest stuff from the mid 1970s.


 o
RE: Rot - Old Wood Vs New

I just got back from a "door jamb" call. Finger joints swelling all around the jamb, rotten at the bottom, about 6 years old. Factory glass care label still on the lite was in better shape than the door (owners not into cleanliness).

Earlier this week I ordered a door, one of the options was a "rot resistant PVC jamb". That caught my attention due to the "resistant" not being "proof". Turns out the option was for the bottom 6" only being PVC. I went for the full monty.


 o
RE: Rot - Old Wood Vs New

I had to replace all my windows only 15 years old due to extensive rot. I had even scrape sanded primed 2 coats of high quality paint when they were about 5 years old. My grandparents 100 year old house, windows needed paint badly wood is just fine. If I could my house would be decay proof. Walls cement, 2 ft thick, metal roof, cement/tile floor, plastic and glass. No wood anywhere. The guys who installed my windows were from Russia/Yugoslav area. I got to talking with him and he said in Europe, most newer construction is built way better than what we do in USA. Stupid Americans! I said that, not the window guy.


 o
RE: Rot - Old Wood Vs New

Ok, folks.. this is an older post but it's about the resins in the wood. As noted here, old wood on houses, some exposed to water without caulk, is very slow to rot. The newer woods used after the late 80's, like Douglas Fir are candy for the fungus and resultant rot. The old trees were full of resins that resist rot.. Slow grown second cut trees prob have good resistant, alway look for the tight growth rings. I'd suggest using vinyl, hardyplank, or a product called miratec instead of wood..


 o
RE: Rot - Old Wood Vs New

per above, they don't really wood-frame in europe. that avoids a ton of rot. we have a crazy timber industry here in good old les etats unis.


 o
RE: Rot - Old Wood Vs New

The stuff that rots out rapidly is "windsor one" or "all-trim", a finger-jointed pre-primed trim product. There used to be a version of that made from redwood which was not bad at all, if the glue-up held.
Casey


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Home Repair Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here