Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
cindyinct

Rolled vs Blown In Attic Insulation

cindyinct
12 years ago

What are the advantages/disadvantages of both types of attic insulation? Currently I don't use the attic, but if I had to get up there to run electric, etc. would one be better than the other?

Comments (5)

  • brickeyee
    12 years ago

    What insulation?

    More than one kind can be blown.

  • energy_rater_la
    12 years ago

    this will probably start a big discussion...
    but I don't have a problem with rolls of fiberglass.
    easy to move if you have stuff to do later in the attic
    and if fitted into joist bays without stuffing and voids
    will perform as rated.
    the advantage with blown is that it settles down in
    all the joist bays without fitting.
    later work in attic can be problematic.

    there is blown fiberglass, white (not itchy), yellow
    and pink (itchy) blown cellulose (borate treated newspaper)
    and sometimes/some areas blown rockwool.
    so there are different types.

    you can also blow foam insulation. we use open cell
    on the roofline (6" to cover faces of 2x6 rafters)
    this is the most expensive option but provides
    other advantages.

    if not using foam, air sealing between attic and
    living space below should be done before adding
    insulation. same for duct sealing..do the sealing
    before insulation.

    best of luck.

  • SpringtimeHomes
    12 years ago

    Good advice above. If you dont have ducts in the attic, blown cellulose should be cheapest and most effective, especially if you DIY. Big box stores will rent you the blower for free if you buy a certain amount which usually isnt much.

  • dedtired
    12 years ago

    I had blown cellulose put in my attic last year. It's made a huge difference in the warmth of the house and in heating bills. The installer left some space for storage. My electrician said they are used to wallowing around in the stuff to work in attics. They can just push it aside and put it back when done. My two cents.

  • brickeyee
    12 years ago

    "My electrician said they are used to wallowing around in the stuff to work in attics. They can just push it aside and put it back when done. "

    A small adjustable rake works well.