Return to the Home Repair Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

Posted by WildBill (My Page) on
Sun, Jul 31, 05 at 21:08

Hello everyone -

I'm a frequenter on the Garden Web forums, but will be here more often now since my wife, Dena, and I just closed on a house in Manchester, Connecticut last Thursday. It was built in 1865, but updated in 1971 - electrical, sheetrock, etc.

We don't have to move in right away, so we can and will be spending some time to fix it up, have a new roof put on, paint, etc.

One of the things we cannot stand is the popcorn ceilings and want to remove it and repaint. Have any of you done it or have suggestions? We were thinking of scraping it off with something like a putty knife, or large wire brush scrubbing pad, or car ice scraper and using the shop vac to clean everything up. We've already started ripping out the carpets so the stuff would be easier to sweep up.

Any suggestions would be helpful. Thanks

Bill


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

Maybe this isn't the best or the cheapest, but one idea is to scrape it off, then add a new layer of drywall over it.

Maybe it's crazy, but I'd imagine the surface repairs would be a big headache otherwise. Just a thought (and I'm not experienced in repairing these ceilings.)


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

wet it down, don't soak it just get it fairly wet. then it wipes right off. i found this out the hard way when trying to clean nicotine off the ceiling. be careful not to soak it, or you may get waterspots. i usually use a spray bottle adjusted to a mist, but you could use a pump sprayer if you have a large area.

once done, allow to dry throughly and then repaint it. if it is a little rough, you can respackle it to smooth it out.


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

Yup, wetting it down seems to be the way to go, as lon gas it's latex/water based.

Google the subject for more details - it looks pretty straightforward to do.


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

We've done our entire house this way. Lot's of Blue Tarps
on the floor because THIS IS MESSY. Plant mister, sponges,
wide-bladed scraper, and stool or ladder. Piece of cake.
Usually took me two passes to re-spackle to smooth out
the irregularities. Prime and paint, and Bob's Yr Nuncle.

Don't over spray. Don't catch a corner of the blade of
you'll dig holes. Easy does it. Smooth.

chuck


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

Over on the HGTV remodeling forums someone mentioned recently that popcorn texturing from the 60s and 70s sometimes contains asbestos. I would definitely check that out before doing a lot of scraping and breathing that stuff. Or like soembody else said above, just sheetrock over it. Good luck.


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

Definitely get it tested for asbestos if it was put up prior to the late 70s. You don't want to be ripping the stuff up and breathing it in.


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

I found that the easiest way to remove a popcorn ceiling is to use a thick nap paint roller and wet the ceiling in small sections (Approx 3' x 3') till it starts to come off on the roller.(It is best to have a covered roller and cover the floor with plastic or paper. At this point use an 8" tape knife to remove the popcorn. It should come off very easy, if it does not come off just wet it more. It should come off in one stroke down to the drywall if that is what you have.

Good Luck,

Joe in North Stonington, CT


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

The part that gets me is, at some point in time people actually thought that stuff looked good! But I shouldn't talk. I think I've still got a leisure suit in my closet somewhere.


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

i still prefer a popcorn ceiling to a smooth one. they are a b! to paint, but they do help cut the noise level some. this i can speak to from experience, as i have compared the same room's echos pre and post popcorn ceiling. although in most cases the effect is not noticeable once furniture is in place.


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

WildBill,

I accidentally happened across your post on the Gardenweb about your popcorn ceiling.

It is possible that you may have asbestos in the ceiling and scraping it will really be bad news.

Please see the following at
www.epa.gov/asbestos/verm.html#Uses

Specific Applications for Vermiculite

CONSTRUCTION

Acoustic Finishes
Gypsum Plaster
Air Setting
Binder Board
Loft Insulation
Fire Protection (internal/external) Sound Deadening Compounds
Floor and Roof Screed (lightweight insulating concrete)

AGRICULTURAL


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

We have an old house that was covered with popcorn ceiling and textured walls over cracked plaster when we bought it. We used a garden sprayer to apply a mist of water all over and use large plaster knives to scrape it off. I hate that stuff!!!


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

Thanks for your great ideas everyone.

I think we'll have it tested for asbestos, & if it checks out OK, then do the wetting & scraping thing. Otherwise, we'll cover it with thin sheetrock.
Bill & Dena


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

this is kind of late to bring up, but here goes.
My husband misted our popcorn cieling with water, then vacuumed the popcorn off with a shopvac. He had a gortex filter in the shopvac so clogging wasn't a problem.
When the shopvac got full, he emptied the goop into a plastic lined trench. The sun dried it and then he scooped up the plastic full of goop and threw it out. He thought it was a peice of cake-We still had a mess, but maybe this way made it easier to clean up.
He and my son finished the cieling by using the knock down system? I believe that is what it is called-rented the machine from HD that blows the plaster onto the cieling and used a wide metal sqeegie to flatten creating a flat texture look. Then he primed and painted. It looks nice, he did a good job.


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

Go to your local home center or paint store. There's a chemical you can apply to soften up the popcorn layer then you can scrape it off. But I should warn you... the chemical has a strong citrus smell and depending on your abilities scraping the layer off requires time and lots of elbow grease!I did my ceiling and I would probably do it again versus hanging drywall.

Good luck


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

I see no one has posted in a while but I will respond in hopes that someone might hear me.
I have to get rid of the popcorn on my kitchen ceiling. I believe it is sprayed directly on the plaster.
The house was built in 1960. There is a slight bow in the ceiling and there is radient heat up there.
I would really rather not desterb the popcorn in fear of asbestos, so hanging drywall on top sounds good to me... could I NOT remove the popcorn and hang drywall on top? I can not afford to pay someone to do this so if I were to remove the popcorn and there is abestos would sealing off the room with plastic and wearing a resperator be safe?
I would like to try the green glue/floating ceiling... what do you think???


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

keley-
When you remove asbestos containing material (if that's what it is), the approach that professional removers use is to create an air-tight enclosure with "negative air pressure" so that fibres can't get through any cracks they missed; they use specialty HEPA vacuums that cost a lot of money, because asbestos fibres are so small they pass through regular vacuum filters; they wear respirators with asbestos-specific filter canisters (not those dust masks you get at Home Depot); they wet down what they're removing, and they bag the debris and dispose of it at a landfill permitted for hazardous waste. They also do other stuff like spray an encapsulant all over to lockdown stray fibres.

You can try to do this yourself, but the chances of making a mess and contaminating the rest of your house is high. Here is a link that tells you more of what's involved if you try to do it yourself, but you need to think seriously about whether this is a good idea.

Here is a link that might be useful: Popcorn ceiling removal


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

We are wanting to remove ours too....DH seemed to think wearing a mask would protect him. I finally convinced him to wait until I find someone to test it. Does anyone know the cost of testing it? We have no idea how long it's been in this house...we moved in here in 1984, but I don't want to assume it was done after 1978......scary stuff!


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

gwanny,

I paid about 20 dollars to have mine tested. The company had me go into a corner and wet a size no larger than a square inch. I took a small putty knife and scooped a sample and placed it into a good ziplock plastic bag. Look in your yellow pages and find an independent lab that does the testing. Don't use a company that also does the removal.


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

thanks for all the input. I have heard of a machine that takes off the popcorn; can you rent something like this? does anyone know?


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

Hi-my husband is trying to remove a popcorn ceiling in his parents 1961 home. There is no asbestos and no paint on it - he thinks. No matter how much water he puts on it, it doesn't soften up. He has chipped away about 18 square feet and feels like he needs a jackhammer - not kidding. Any suggestions?


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

And what makes him think it is asbestos-free? 1961 was prime time for such ceilings. You can only determine if something does not contain asbestos with a lab test, not by observation. It may be hard to remove because it has been painted. This makes for a messier and more dangerous removal if you do have asbestos.


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

Hello all! I have popcorn on the ceilings of my 1999 townhome. Do you think I should test it for asbestos, even though it was built after 1970? Also, if I decide to hire someone to remove it, can anyone give me an estimate of the cost (per sq. ft. etc.). Thanks!


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

I love the look of popcorn ceilings. Its all a matter of personal taste.


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

some popcorn is made of styrofoam; this reduces noise a lot. Don't paint it too much and it remains fluffy styrofoam, which reduces noise reflection. Paint it several times over many years and its surface becomes a hard (but textured) surface. A bit less effective.

Another advantage to popcorn is that the surface bumpiness means you don't need to get your ceiling to be perfect. Save time and money by not overdoing it.


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

Just FYI. Popcorn ceiling is done different ways. Some used styrofoam, some perlite, some foam bits. My sisters house, I helped roller brush her kitchen was done with ground up drywall/plaster chunks we found out. We ended up scraping it off because it immediately turned to mush when painted and fell off. Never did find out for sure it there was asbestos, we didn't even think or know about that. She ended up getting ceilings painted with a sprayer by professionals a few years later, was not willing to have the whole house scraped.


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

---just noticed ----this is a really old post---------
usually don't respond to these


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

Does anyone know the cost having professionals come in and remove the popcorn?


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

Boy, I wish this site was around when I removed all the popcorn ceilings in my 3-family.

I scraped all the ceilings of each apartment, dry with just a sharp putty knife. What a mess! All the dust in my hair and eyes, mixing with the sweat from working... Uhh! But cleanup was the worst, by far.

I never thought about wetting the popcorn to remove it. Brilliant! I have some spots around light fixtures that I was never able to get scraped off completely, I'm sure this post will help.

Thanks,
Nick


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

i saw a video of someone who misted their whole ceiling until it was so heavy with water that it started sagging and stretching and all came down at once like a snow avalanche. Pretty cool.


 o
RE: Removing 'Popcorn' Ceiling

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=74rr71tZN8U

Here is a link that might be useful: YouTube of popcorn removal - vinegar and water


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Home Repair Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here