Return to the Remodeling Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

Posted by kellykath (My Page) on
Mon, Dec 28, 09 at 11:22

O.k. I just don't know what to do. Instead of blaming someone, we just need to come up with a solution. This baywindow (previously added about 10 yrs. ago) has a new facia that does not look good. I do not like how it hugs the window . . . see below. We have several hip roofs and as someone did not account for the 'enclosed eaves' that we will now have, AND the roof was not adjusted 'pitchwise', we have an issue as you can see. Does anyone have any suggestions that will make this look right? I do not want to get rid of the bay as it accomodates a couch in my living room giving me added space due to the room being fairly narrow. We are going to enclose the ceiling of the porch/entry. However there will not be a side window to the entry even though it shows one. I just don't have a good solution to this and don't want to completely redo the whole roofline. I hate the way this look though. Any input would be appreciated. Thanks


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

Kellykath, your picture did not post. I posted a few pics for you in the thread I started last week -


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

I hope these pics post this time, 2nd times a charm I hope.
Any photo shop or dormer suggestions appreciated. I need to get this right without having to redo the whole dang roof line.


 o
RE: Help... Here are my pics finally

Again, hope someone out there has some great idea!

Here is a link that might be useful: http://photobucket.com/kellykathbay


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

That's a tuff call! Typically when the bay walls have height above the header of the window, you can have extended overhangs not interferring with the plane of the window and not blocking the view/ light. In your case, the bay walls extended up would be addressed by having a hip/vally'd roof tying into the plane of the existing roof. The bay would have it's own seperate rooflines tying into the existing. The problem lies in tying the overhang/facia from the other perpindicular roof decently into the bayed overhang/facia. with a valley tied into the hip. Seems like this is something you will have to live with unless you can line up a decent framer that has extensive roof framing exoerience who can visualize tying this all in and most importantly, keep a decent drainage plane concerning the roof where it can be properly flashed by the roofer pulling it all off where it doesn't look like it was all hacked in. A challenge for the best framer/carpenter, for sure!


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

Thanks sierraeast, I might just have to take out the bay window (which is there for a couch) as the living room area is so narrow. I hate to do that, but it would be a shame to have to look at what looks like a mistake every time I drive up to the house.


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

Kelly:
How's this problem going? I know nothing about rooflines but have total sympathy for you. It does look awkward but someone must have some experience with rooflines! Bumping this up....maybe post on another forum too?


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

I wouldn't throw in the hat just yet. The bay would look awesome if you extended the wall height above the window and framed out it's own hip and valley roof. It's tying in the other roofline that is complicated. You might be able to reduce the overhang of the other roofline coming in by stepping it back where it will tie in at the side of the bay's overhang line. You might try scale drawing several top views of the rooflines to get you a better visual.


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

Thanks to those that have posted. I have a friend of ours who is in the home building business who is going to take a look at this. I am still awaiting someones brilliant idea/s! Keep them coming please. Kelly


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

Kelly, those two roofs are indeed funny looking together, never mind the bay window. Is that a chimney coming out of the roof behind the bay? That might make things much more complicated.

Are the two ridge lines at the same height?


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

Ouch. I have total sympathy for you....I agree something needs to change. It's a very weird fascia. Can you find an architect to hire for a really quick consult? Friend of a friend or something? I definitely think it would be worth a few hundred bucks on a consult to come up with a more elegant solution.

How did this happen in the first place?


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

I can't view your pics; they don't display for me, for some odd reason. Would some helpful soul directly post them here?
I'd like to take a look and try to help.
Casey


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

See if this works

Here is a link that might be useful: ranch


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

Thanks Sierraeast, I had a hard time getting the two previous pics to post so I appreciate your assistance. With regard to the chimney . . . it is fairly far back (it will also be extended due to the higher peak that we now have. I will attempt to take some better pics tomorrow for a better perspective. I like the idea of raising the bay somewhat and tying it in on the side somehow. I have been looking at roofs everywhere and this situation has me overly worried for sure.

To answer your question of "how did this happen.. ."? Our architect who drew the plans detailed on the plans that the eaves were to be enclosed (which was what we wanted). However, he forgot to take into account that several years earlier we added a bay window to get some depth in our fairly narrow living room. At that time, bumping out the bay shortened the eaves somewhat. Although it was brought to his attention that the roofline would need to be somewhat modified to accomodate proportionate distance from the window, our builder brought it to our attention this was not the case. I don't want to point any fingers at this point, what is done is done - - I want to solve the problem. We have run into numerous problems on windows, transom sizes, etc. but have been able to correct them.

If we enclosed the eaves as detailed on the plans, The eave would actually hit the window. We changed the porch entry area to make it more proportionate with the house/gargage roof. We have several hip roof areas and they all seem look fine but this bay is horrible. I am not a designer or architect obviously so I hope my explanation was fairly informative/understandable. Keep up the good ideas!!! They are soooooooo appreciated.


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

Well, 16 months later and just an update for those that have helped. The bay window/roof area was redesigned and completed. As soon as I get some time, I will post some pics of its completion. I appreciate those that helped with this issue or just added their ideas/opinions! Thanks again.


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

This was our solution . . .
Photobucket


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

Photobucket

The "before" pic was deleted so here is one view prior to being modified.


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

Looks much better!


 o
RE: Help... This looks ridiculous - HELP !

It all planes in nicely now. Good job!


 o
nice!

It all planes in nicely now. Good job!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Remodeling Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here