|
| We are replacing windows and some rotted siding on our 1971 house and are wondering if we should change to another style of siding?
Currently we have a flat, plain panel sheet siding - 4 foot x 8 foot redwood plywood panel sheets that have been painted. The house is kind of busy, thus I am thinking of staining with the plain look, but would love any opinions. Thanks! |
Follow-Up Postings:
|
| Before changing the siding (unless it's degenerated and needs replacing), consider changing the garage door to something more interesting. Right now it looks a bit like a shoebox, and that's the dominant feature of your house. I don't think the house is busy at all. You could go with clapboards or board-and-batten (NOT reverse b&b) siding. I'd also add a pergola or some other interest over the walkway which I assume runs along the garage to the front door. Right now the entrance is rather hidden and under-emphasized -- you need to give it some presence. And, of course, landscaping. It will be a lovely house when you're done. |
|
| Thank you! Unfortunately the garage door is brand new, so I feel bad about replacing it right away. Is it possible to take out some of the panels on it and put in windows? Here is a better picture of our crazy siding from the side of the house. Not sure to stay with the same plywood siding or change to some T1-11 siding with a vertical line or something with some other design. The bottom of a lot of the siding is rotted, plus we plan to change out the windows and doors, so we figured now was a good time. I would like to stick with a contemporary or modern look. Thanks for any opinions. |
|
- Posted by EngineerChic (My Page) on Thu, Aug 9, 12 at 18:52
| Where are you located? I mean, what part of the country? That will help guide your choices. If it were my house (I'm in New England) I would look into adding a peaked roof over the garage and some kind of clapboard siding. But if you are in CA I'd suggest something else. Congrats on the new house, BTW, I'm guessing you just purchased it? |
|
| Thanks EngineerChic. We are in the SF Bay Area. Here is a picture of the windows on the side of the garage that lead up to the front door. Thanks for any ideas! |
|
- Posted by EngineerChic (My Page) on Thu, Aug 9, 12 at 20:12
| Ooh, fun! You can go with some really interesting options. Have you looked at Houzz.com? I think you could go for a mix of metal and beautiful wood (not clapboard but slatted). |
Here is a link that might be useful: Wood and metal combined
|
| Bluntly, I hate T1-11 siding. It looks cheap, in a bad sort of way. It shows seams. It has no good character. It says, "Oh, look, we ran out of money and taste at the same time." It's awful. But your current siding doesn't flatter the house, either. It's rumpled and looks one step up from tarpaper. Your house deserves better than either of these. The picture EngineerChic linked to shows board-and-batten, which is a simple but characterful siding which is also traditional for the California coast. It would work really well with the vertical lines of your house. Even better if it's in redwood, but I'm not sure that's even available any more. The board-and-batten would no doubt be more expensive than the other sidings, but would be worth it. Are you eventually going to change out the amber glass? Or will you keep it? |
|
| We are definitely changing out the amber glass. Two sides of our house is 2.5 stories tall, so we are worried about matching up lines. Other than board and batten, what else would work? The other houses in our neighborhood all seem to have the siding with the vertical lines in it. |
|
- Posted by EngineerChic (My Page) on Fri, Aug 10, 12 at 6:14
| Whoops! I linked to the wrong thing. Board and batten is pretty, too. I think you can do stucco in you area as well, right? There are a lot of stunning images with stucco and wood mixed. I've even seen some homes use corrugated galvanized steel as siding - though it can look low budget if it isn't installed well (and assuming metal prices are still high, it's not low budget). Having lived in NE or other "traditional-minded" parts of the country all my life, I would embrace the CA aesthetic and go for something with slatted redwood and stucco. |
Here is a link that might be useful: Better link
|
| Anything that is installed in a 4x8 sheet is going to have seams that show, especially on your tall wall. You can cover these seams with battens, but you will have to work that into your design. If you don't do something about the visible seams, it will look cheap. What about wide horizontal clapboards? Or the stucco mentioned elsewhere. And on your garage door, I believe certain manufacturers do make them so you can pop out one panel and replace it with something else. |
|
- Posted by Renovator8 (My Page) on Fri, Aug 10, 12 at 16:23
| Board & batten or shingles over the existing panel siding would add some architectural texture and weather protection. |
|
| hI everyone, I am back onto siding again (I have been focused on windows and a new front door). I spoke to a rep for certainteed about their cement board siding as well as hardie. Apparently they both carry a board and batten like siding. Any other options for installing board and batten? Thanks! |
|
- Posted by palimpsest (My Page) on Sat, Sep 15, 12 at 20:50
|
| I grew up in a California board-and-batten cottage. As is common for the type, the boards and battens were redwood, left natural to weather to a dark silver gray. However, I don't believe redwood lumber is available any longer; if it is, it's probably cost-prohibitive. Cedar might be a more affordable alternative, but it might also be more expensive than the fiber-cement sidings. Still, it's worth checking into. Two nice points about the fiber-cement sidings is that they hold paint well and they provide more fire protection than wood. |
|
| Thanks Chibimim, I might post about Hardie's board and batten and see if anyone has any opinions / experienced any issues! |
|
| Does anyone have any info on adding battens over existing siding? I was thinking if we could replace the sections that are rotted and then patch them up and add a piece of trim to cover the patch and then add vertical battens it might give us the board and batten look and save a lot of money |
|
| I've heard of people doing this, but have no personal experience with it. Can't see any reason why it wouldn't work. You'll also want to add some trim to cover the horizontal seams between the siding sheets. |
Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum. If you are a member, please log in. If you aren't yet a member, join now!
Return to the Remodeling Forum
Instructions
- You must be a registered member and logged in to post messages on our forums.
- Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review the contents and make changes.
- After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
- It is illegal to post copyrighted material without the owner's consent.
- HTML codes are allowed in the message field only.
- No advertising is allowed in any of the forums.
- If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
- If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.