Return to the Remodeling Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Baseboards, trim, crown...MDF of primed pine?

Posted by caroline (My Page) on
Wed, Mar 12, 08 at 19:57

We're preparing to trim the three bedrooms with fluted casings and rosettes around the windows and doors, baseboards, and crown molding in each room.

This is not a high end house (by a long shot, LOL) but I want it to look nice. All the trim will be painted a cream color.

Would it be better to go with pre-primed pine stock, or pre-primed MDF stock?

Thanks for any help you can offer!

P.S. Do I put the fluted trim and rosettes on the windows only, or do they go around the interior doors also?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Baseboards, trim, crown...MDF of primed pine?

I vote for the MDF. I think it takes the paint better as there is no grain, like with the pine. It is also more dimensionally stable (doesn't shrink and expand as much as due to temperature and humidity changes). Pine would be a better choice for moist/wet areas like bathrooms since MDF and water don't mix well. In general, MDF is available in larger sizes, if that is a factor for you. I would put the fluted trim and rosettes around the doors also to give it a more unified look. BTW, I've seen MDF used in some fairly high end homes, If the moldings are painted, it's next to impossible to distinguish them from wood. As an aside, there are some poor quality MDF moldings out there. Make sure the profiles look clean and crisp.


 o
RE: Baseboards, trim, crown...MDF of primed pine?

Depends on the look. If you want that clean, perfect, plastic look, go mdf. If you want the look of old world and the natural graining of wood, go pine. Pine dents but mdf chips, making for harder repairs. In that respect, pine is a little better at abuse.


 o
RE: Baseboards, trim, crown...MDF of primed pine?

We used a combination of pine/MDF. We used MDF were we could, as it is quite a bit cheaper than pine. In my experience, the MDF is easier to paint and cut, and won't crack if you nail close to the edges. We wanted to recreate a more "old farmhouse" look without too much work. Our house would never have had any "fancy" woodwork to begin with.

For the pine, we used high quality, well sanded, and you can't see the grain through the paint anyway. I used a brush as I wanted the old, hand painted look.

We created "corners" also. These are sort of like the two we found in a back closet.

I think you would want to match the windows with the doors.

And in case you are wondering, the flat peices are clear pine, and the moulded peices are MDF. We used a combination of MDF and pine to build the caps. The trim was cut and painted before getting put up (after the walls were painted).

We uses 1x6 pine for the base with an MDF top. The top peice is flexible enought to conform to the variations in the wall, so helps to minimize those rather large gaps that can happen when using thicker base boards. Or you can use a lot of caulk and repaint (done that too).

BTW- the actual window will get primed and painted once the weather is warm enough to have the windows open all day.

Cathy


 o
RE: Baseboards, trim, crown...MDF of primed pine?

MDF is cheap and looks nice painted. It is also considered a 'green' product since it is waste material from other processes.

Poplar is a better choice than pine for about the same money. Very little grain shows thru poplar.


 o
RE: Baseboards, trim, crown...MDF of primed pine?

One issue with MDF crown molding is that it's less rigid then pine and needs more support to hold it up and secure. Small intermediate,"T" bars can hold it in place until it's nailed.
Ron


 o
RE: Baseboards, trim, crown...MDF of primed pine?

We used MDF and PVC to make the trim shown below, and we have been very happy with it (over 2 years now...)

Here is a link that might be useful: Greengate Ranch Remodel


 o
RE: Baseboards, trim, crown...MDF of primed pine?

randymeyer,
Just curious, when I have priced poplar versus pine poplar is about twice the price. Where do you get it?


 o
RE: Baseboards, trim, crown...MDF of primed pine?

Decker, In our area, the evil orange is the only game in our small town as they drove everyone away. Poplar is actually less than a closed grain clear pine. Poplar accepts and finishes nicer when painting than even clear pine,imo. Clear pine looks nicer stained. Poplar doesn't accept stains well,imo. The quality of the species is questionable at h.d here as well, but any wood type is hard to keep decent here in the desert.


 o
RE: Baseboards, trim, crown...MDF of primed pine?

Check the local hardwood shops - poplar is priced to move. Poplar is easy to work with - stays very straight - and doesn't split when nailed. It should be used for painted surfaces - not stained. The color goes from green to white so it looks a little odd stained light colors and tends to look a little fuzzy. Paints up nice. I believe it is a fast growth tree which is why you get a nice piece of wood at a reasonable price.

Clear pine can get pricey - priced similar to oak.

The preprimed stuff they sell as pine is usually some sort of fir tree that looks like pine. I doubt anyone ever notices.


 o
RE: Baseboards, trim, crown...MDF of primed pine?

For crown you might consider poly urethane molding for about 1/4 wood unless you touch it one ant tell the difference. Its glued up instead of nailed. You can also get Decorative Ornate Molding that would cost a fortune in wood for 1-2 per foot. Here is one of many sites and even home depot sells it. You can get it primed or not.
http://www.creativecrown.com/store/index.php?p=catalog&parent=80&pg=1


 o
RE: Baseboards, trim, crown...MDF of primed pine?

ttfweb

Very nice trim job. I've never seen inside corners like those. Was there an effort to match them on outside corners?


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Remodeling Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here