Return to the Remodeling Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Quartzite vs granite countertops

Posted by libby-momsy (My Page) on
Tue, Jan 29, 13 at 13:45

We are building a house. I have always wanted to use marble on my countertops, but am finally giving that up in favor of durability. (Why do all the magazines show marble??) I do love the marble look, however; thus I'm looking at granite and quartzite that have the look of marble. I currently have granite, so I know it is tough. I'm leaning toward quartzite (not quart). But would love to hear from someone who has experience with it. Anyone?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

Marble is the cheapest stone you can get. It's simple and traditional. I have just seen quartzite in person. It's beautiful! The colors and the veins are so amazing! The color is more vibrant. The white is so much whiter and brighter. The veins are more pronouced. I never had it in my house before but the stone people told me that it's easy to clean because it's more dense like granite. Here are some photos I have taken.
http://stickybee.blogspot.com/2013/01/lets-get-stones.html

Here is a link that might be useful: stickybee.blogspot.com


 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

Try searching on the kitchen forum for quartzites and white granites. There are many who have used them. Some quartzites have similar characteristics to marble, i.e. they will etch. You need to get a sample and try various acids on them to make sure you're getting the durability you want.

I chose marble for my island and Caesarstone for perimeter counters - the best of both worlds.


 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

We are in the process of looking at Granite and Quartzite for our kitchen. We have dark cherry cabinets. I want a leathered stone and am leaning toward Quartzite. Have people found it to be alot more expensive than granite? Wondering how people are feel about their installed leathered countertops. Are they holding up to stains and scratches? Any advice is welcomed and needed for this tough and expensive decision!


 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

I don't have any experience using Quartzite but I know the price is less expensive than Granite. At my local stone yard Super White Quartzite is about $1,000 a slab. Compares to Granite that would be about $1,500-2,000 a slab.


 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

Consumer reports rated all countertop materials recently. Quartz beat Granite by 2 points, but they're both widely regarded as good against chips, scratches, stains, and heat. Marble came in dead last with a 14/100 I believe. For comparison, Quartz and Granite were in the 90s.


 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

Aren't quartz and quartzite two different things?


 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

yes these are 2 different things. Quartz is something like Caesarstone. Which is stronger than quartzite and not likely to etch. And not to mention more expensive.


 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

Quartzite is a metamorphic rock largely composed of quartz, which is a mineral.

 photo MasterBathroom2_500-1.jpg

Natural quartzite floors from China; granite counter

What most of us refer to as "quartzite," as used in kitchen counters, is a manmade agglomeration of crushed natural quartzite, resins and fillers.

I have used DuPont's Zodiaq brand manmade quartzite counters and natural cut quartzite flooring quarried in China.

I was happy with both. The counters required no maintenance and were easy to keep clean. However, they do chip from surprisingly small mishaps--even a ceramic mug slipping from your hand can do the deed. I liked the unusual colouring of the quartzite in a master bath.

Zodiaq quartzite kitchen counter. Polished slate flooring.(below)

This post was edited by worthy on Thu, Jan 16, 14 at 9:51


 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

I was of the understanding that quartzite is a natural stone. DuPont's product is a manmade product made from Quartz. Check out dupont site.


 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

Mags438:

You are correct.


 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

Quartzite is usually harder than granite and sometimes more expensive. It is the most expensive item in my kitchen. I believe granite was going to be $45.00 less per square foot. (at least the granite I had looked at.)

It all depends on which granite and which quartzite. I know some granites (blues) are super expensive. Some granites are rare so they are expensive. My Sea Pearl quartzite was not the most expensive stone. I think it was around $98.00 per s.f. One of the beautiful Labradorites was the most expensive slab in the huge slab warehouse where I went. It had been there for a year and no one had bought it yet. I have seen Cristallo or Kristallo for $175.00 per s.f.
I have seen other slabs going for over $250.00 per s.f.

Go to marble world online to see pricing. Your pricing will be higher due to fabrication costs, but it will give you an idea of which stones are in your price range and ideas of the various colors.

I fell in love with a beautiful quartzite that was as soft as marble. I hope to get it for my bathroom since it is too soft for a kitchen. My Sea Pearl was babied for several months. My husband had left spaghetti sauce splotches, mustard, and many more scary food products on the countertop. When I moved his tools, I found the splotches. They had been on the counter for 2-3 weeks by then. They wiped right off. No stains. Whew! I thought I was going to have to kill him. He also scratched my SS Bluestar rangetop when it was a week old and I let him live. LOL

Good luck in your search. Remember that sometimes the stone yard people really know about some stones and sometimes they don't. Do your own testing. Don't take anyone's word for anything. When I was looking, they called quartzite as a granite.

Here is a picture of my Sea Pearl quartzite. Left one is polished and right one is brushed. Some Sea Pearl slabs have linear stripes and some look like mine. You just have to look at every slab or have them send you a picture. Peke


 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

Just a note above (and to reinforce what Peke wrote), many of us found that what was claimed to be Super White "quartzites" were indeed a dolomitic marble. Thus, in my experience the Super White was priced at the lower end of the spectrum (slightly above say marbles) but at half or a 1/3 the price per sq foot of commonly accepted true Quartzite. Thus, I found (for retail comparison on a full slab purchase), fake "Super White" at $19, real "Super White" at $50-60, White Macaubus at $36, and "Princess White" at $60-70. Comparably, certain lower tier granites were at $13-20 and quartz at $15 to 25.

YMMV, according to where you live.


 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

My wife and I are looking to buy quartzite. We got this stone (not installed yet) and it has failed almost every test.

It stains
The polish is etched by lime juice, diet mt dew, ketchup, strawberry (also significant staining) red wine did not etch.

The glass cut test was slightly inconclusive. The corner of the stone wasn't very sharp and it had some scratching on the bottle, but not much.

After the etching test failure, I decided to try and cut the stone with an old crappy steak knife. I was able to cut into the stone quite easily. I was able to drop the knife on the stone from less than a foot and the stone was visibly marred.

Based on the rocks 101 -103 forums, I think this means I've got a marble slab with some neat crystalization. Could this be a granite? I'll post more pictures


 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

More sample pics


 o
RE: Quartzite vs granite countertops

@ILstinks, if your stone scratches or stains it is not quartzite. We had beautiful 'super white' quartzite installed last summer when we remodeled our kitchen and couldn't be happier. They are so durable!

They look like marble without the hazy patina. Nothing (so far) harms the
- hot pans, red wine, even sliced lemons! We love them! They were more expensive than granite but worth it. Work with a reputable stone shop because lots of places try to pass off impure quartzite which will scratch. Good luck!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Remodeling Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here