Return to the Buying and Selling Homes Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Install new boiler before listing?

Posted by oicu812 (My Page) on
Wed, Sep 19, 12 at 7:27

I'm wondering what everyone's thoughts are on replacing major mechanicals (water heater & boiler) before listing.

We plan to list (and hopefully sell) our home next spring. I started going thru the house with a critical eye, making a list of 'to do' items to fix/replace/update to work on over the winter before listing next spring.

I noticed some corrosion on our (gas) hot water heater. The occasional drip from the relief valve down pipe has caused some rust on the exterior jacket of the water heater. Maybe a 2-3" spot. Had it looked at. It's only surface damage. Inner tank still looks fine. It's 12yo and nearing the end of its expected life, but still works fine and probably would for a while more. But I fear the rust might raise suspicions during showings or inspection and lower sell price.

Thinking about replacing the water heater, I then notice it's sitting next to our ~25yo boiler. Again, it works fine, has been regularly maintained and serviced. But looking at it with 'buyers eyes', I see a 25 yo boiler that'd most likely need replacing in 5-10 years.

So my options are to do nothing, just replace the water heater, or go the "Full Monty" (new 96% condensing boiler with indirect water storage tank). Financially speaking, $0, $1000, or $8000. As I see the risks, it's either lose money on the sale due to end-of-life mechanicals, or upgrade but not make the money back at sale time due to the buyer not placing any value on new mechanicals.

Thoughts? Anyone gone thru similar decisions?

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Install new boiler before listing?

I think as long as that stuff is working, you should leave it alone, unless there is something about your local real estate market that would make it advantageous to replace those items. We had to replace both of those things in our current house within probably 6 months (a guy who came out to look at the furnace actually put a lock on it or something and said it would be dangerous to use because of CO2) but it didn't faze us during the inspection when the inspector said that both things were in working order but near the end of their expected life.

RE: Install new boiler before listing?

It might be worth paying a house inspector to see what they think. Plus there may be other things that you're not noticing that will show up on an inspection. A furnace nearing the end of its life will affect your price, and may result in a lost sale, as some people want a move-in ready house. Of course, you won't get your money back on a new furnace or water heater.

RE: Install new boiler before listing?

You might want to look into offering a home warranty with $550, depending on the company you go with.

RE: Install new boiler before listing?

Personally, I put a premium on new mechanicals, I would rather not have the hassle of replacement. But I may be unusual, and thus I doubt it would cause you to lose a sale unless there are a lot of very similar places for sale that have newer mechanicals and similar prices.

RE: Install new boiler before listing?

You probably wouldn't recoup your investment in new heater, boiler, etc. but I would do it anyway. It may help sell the house faster or tip things to your way if there is a decision for the buyer between your house and another. You won't have to be getting lower offers because the buyer will be deducting monies off the asking price due to the age of your heating system. NancyLouise

RE: Install new boiler before listing?

I might replace the water heater because it is rusted and wouldn't cost nearly as much as a new boiler.

I would not spend the money to replace the boiler unless your competition has new boilers. Especially since you won't recoup the cost and you think the boiler might last another 5-10 years.

RE: Install new boiler before listing?

"think the boiler might last another 5-10 years."

That is pretty far out to be replacing a boiler.

If the water heater is already showing problems it would not be very expensive to get it off the table as a possible sale condition by replacing it.

RE: Install new boiler before listing?

Thanks for all the feedback. I'm still undecided.

I'm told one of my figures might be higher than expected. The cost to replace just the hot water heater (gas, 40-gal) was quoted at $1000. But it was also mentioned that I may need a flue liner also, which might double or triple that price. Currently the gas boiler & water heater just dump out into the chimney. I was told that now I need a liner. Not sure if that's code or upselling.

In the case of 'replace everything', the high-efficency units now vent directly outdoors via PVC, so there'd be no additional cost above the ~$8000ish.

So my choices are spend nothing and risk sale/inspection issues, spend ~$2000+ for just the water heater and still have an old boiler at sale time, or $8000 for the whole shebang (and maybe sell quickly to someone who recognizes appreciates new mechanicals.)

RE: Install new boiler before listing?

How important is selling quickly?

Will you have carrying costs besides regular expenses of living in the house as your residence?

How good is the market for houses the age of yours?

What condition and improvements is the competition offering at your selling price?

RE: Install new boiler before listing?

I faced the same question, new water heater with 10 year warranty is costing under 1500$ and I am doing it. The existing one is over 27 years old, works fine for us, but well past average lifespan and it makes a lot of noise.

New boiler 6-8k, I decided to wait on. The boiler works fine. It is a gamble since a new energy efficient boiler would make a difference for some buyers. But I would rather wait and see if that is what a buyer would ask to replace. The high cost just seems too much to go ahead. I would rather fix whatever other miscellaneous the buyer requests then the boiler PLUS whatever other miscellaneous they are likely to request.

I am having a boiler cleaning and servicing when the water heater is replaced so I can document that it is in good working order.

I do plan to clean the area the boiler is in and remove all dust so it looks nice and tidy. Is there a way you can give the current unit a good cleaning?

Good luck!

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Buying and Selling Homes Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here