Return to the Buying and Selling Homes Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Foreclosure offer pricing

Posted by gmp3 (My Page) on
Fri, Jul 8, 11 at 22:45

What is the strategy on offer price for a foreclosure? We are interested in one.

The bank painted and carpeted but of course there are some neglect issues like the yard and front and back decks. Do you bid 70%, 80%? We will be super strong buyers (40% down, 780 credit, etc.) and high income compared to debt. We close on our current house in mid August so we could close quickly. So they care about that stuff?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

If you had started last year in August on the foreclosure you might have a chance of having it done by August this year. Banks are VERY slow in getting them sold.
Just finding out who actually has the paperwork on the property can take months and that's after they've taken their sweet time accepting your offer.

Been there,done it, would rather have root canal.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

I asked about this too recently. You should go back a little and look for my post. Some people said the same thing Carol said but others said it could take a few days to get an answer depending on the bank and the area. I didn't ask about what to offer.

I'm wondering if a bank who is selling a foreclosed home will only take offers from people who have no house-selling contingency? Will they take an offer from someone whose house is under contract? Do you actually have to be closed on your house before you can buy a foreclosure?


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

Realtor said we would know if offer was accepted within a few says, short sales are a completely different atory and can drag forever. Good point about contingency, I'll need to ask about that.


 o
wrong term...

I forgot to clairify this house is bank owned, so the foreclosure is over. I think I got my terms wrong. It is listed with a broker.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

If you had started last year in August on the foreclosure you might have a chance of having it done by August this year. Banks are VERY slow in getting them sold.

This is incorrect. Maybe this would be the case with a short sale, but definitely not with a bank owned property. I know people who have purchased foreclosures and have received answers very quickly and closed in about the same time as a normal sale. Even the short sales are going faster than in the past.
I work in a RE office and the foreclosures are not taking any longer than "regular" sales on average.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

Correct... short sales are a gamble, but REOs take about the same amount of time as a regular sale. Banks will not accept a contingency as far as I understand.
As far as making an offer, there is no magic formula that you can use to know what they will accept. If the home is priced right, you will pay close to full price; if it is priced high and has been on the market for a long time, your chances are better at getting it at a reduced price.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

"REOs take about the same amount of time as a regular sale..."

Not for the ones I have purchased (a total of four, with two last fall.

Banks HATE losing money, and will try and put off the event and diffuse the responsibility within the bank, dragging things out (the 'committee' makes the decisions so no single person has to sign off on the loss).

If they are NOT losing money they can move faster, but rarely as quickly as a wiling seller and wiling buyer seem to get things done.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

We closed on ours Dec 2009 in 2 weeks.

Listing price was $69K (after dropping from $120K) and we offered and they accepted 60K.

Next time I will be more aggresive in making a lower offer. I found out after our contract was accepted that they were already planning on dropping to $58K. I think they would have taken 50K from us.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

Thanks everyone. This one says in the listing "Close By 10/31/2011 & Request Up To 3.5% In Final Sales Price For Closing Cost Assistance. Homepath."

I looked it up and found the link below. Is this only for people using Homepath financing ? I looks like it is for anyone to get a deal done quickly.

Here is a link that might be useful: incentives


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

If the home is priced right, you will pay close to full price; if it is priced high and has been on the market for a long time, your chances are better at getting it at a reduced price.

And if the home is underpriced, expect a bidding war. That's what is happening in my area, especially for homes under about $150k.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

I wondered about 'Homepath' also. See it on some listings.

Jane


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

Homepath means it is a Fannie Mae Foreclosure and buyers can get special financing.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

"Next time I will be more aggresive in making a lower offer. I found out after our contract was accepted that they were already planning on dropping to $58K. I think they would have taken 50K from us. "

It can be anything from difficult to imposable to determine how deep the bank is into the property.

A review of recorded notes to find out the terms of the old not that was foreclosed, and how old it was can provide some information.
What you often cannot determine is how long ago the owner actually defaulted (2 months, 6 months, 12 months?), and how long the lender spent dithering around and the costs they inured (the folks they hire to pursue the foreclosure process do not work for free).

If there was PMI on the loan, the bank may not be looking at as much of a loss (if the PMI vendor can be forced to pay).


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

In our area, homepath houses often go for very much less than the list price. I've been kicking myself for just missing one that was listed at 79K and sold for 35K.

They evidently are more concerned about moving inventory than banks are.

I have a related question, if I may tag on to this. When looking up the tax records for foreclosures, what does the last sale price mean? I mean when the bank completed the foreclosure and listed the house.


 o
RE:forgot

Forgot to mention that homepath allows you to include a certain amount for repairs in your financing if you're going to be the owner occupant and they consider the property needs work, as well as sometimes covering a certain amount of the closing costs for certain buyers.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

Thanks writersblock, I guess we can make a low offer and are just dealing with a bank so they can go ahead and counter without hurt feelings. What is working against us is that it has only been on the market 30 days. It is listed at 325K, and a property in the same neighborhood that was 300' bigger, had an extra bedroom and a study, with nicer upgrades, new windows, professionally finished and 300' larger basement and a 10K carpet allowance sold for 310K. Any suggestions for the first offer?


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

It's hard to say. Have you tracked any other foreclosures in the area to get an idea of the spread between asking and getting? Also, how low you can start depends to some extent on how active the market is in your area. For a while around here you had to bid pretty high (often even above asking price) because there was some fierce competition from big investment groups that didn't bother much about realistic property values (must have had a program set up to bid on every property in the area below $xxx, but that's okay, because I foresee another big wave of stuff hitting the market when they either fold or realize what they've gotten into).

Also to clarify in my first post what I'm asking about the price listed for last sale on a foreclosure, here's an example of what puzzles me: The owner is listed as the bank, with a purchase price of, say, $44k. The house is listed at $59K, and given the date of previous sale, I would say the foreclosed owners probably paid about $200K in 2007. So where does the $44K come from? If they couldn't make the payments or did jingle mail, they must have owed more than that, so it can't be the amount of the debt. What would it be?


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

The property I am interested in is listed at $155 per foot (above grade) the non REO I mentioned above sold for $124 per foot plus had another finished 1200' in the basement. I live in a neighborhood now with larger homes of the same vintage but just one subdivision away. One on my street was sold to a flipper for 345K and was listed at $394K. That was on the market 6 month though.


 o
more info

The property on my street started at 415K


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

Well, given what you mention, it sounds like you would probably want to be proportionately higher than someone bidding around here. The fact that the whole concept of "flip" still exists in your area means it must be much less affected by the housing crash than my area has been, and it sounds like there isn't much available in your neighborhood.

Outside of ultra high end real estate (10 million+) the only buying in my area is bottom feeding, and that motivated not always by greed but by the realization that there's no reason to except prices to stop sliding any time soon, so it's a totally different world than yours, by the sound of things.

So the next thing to consider is how badly you want the house. Are you willing to make a low opening bid and possibly risk losing it to someone else?


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

Well the owner occupant period is over so I don't think they will have a bidding war. I want the house but it needs a lot of work so I only want it if it is a deal. I will ask the realtor today what happens if we make a low ball and they reject, and/or if you can present grounding for your offer, i.e., needs new roof, windows, patio, no finished basement compared to comp which sold $21/foot less than subject.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

Did you find out if they will take a contingent offer? I would be surprised if so.
You could submit comps along with your offer, however, I have found that when a foreclosure is overpriced, about the only thing that makes the light bulb go off with a bank is time on the market.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

I just went through this business in Fla. This is how it was explained to me.

Home owners default and bank puts the house up for auction. The bank doesn't have to accept any of the bids. If the bank doesn't accept the bids, or there were no bids, the bank buys the house back. That is the price you see.

Its all paper nonsense, but the last price is what the bank puts down as their buy price.

We looked at a house going up for auction and noticed the banks did not accept approximately 60% of the bids and bought the house back. We had considered bidding on a house which was going up for auction.

Maybe some Realtors can chime in an clarify.

Jane


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

Thanks, Jane. Yes, the auction is a standard part of foreclosure proceedings in FL, but I was under the impression that the lien holder usually made only a token payment, like a dollar or so.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

Well the offer is in, we went lower than what we are willing to pay hoping the bank will reveal their bottom. No contingency. On paper we can do it without our house closing, it wouldn't be pretty, we'd be bringing the last jar of pennies to closing ;-) but we could qualify, eat no, qualify yes. The realtor was not overly worried about us having this offer accepted and closing before our house closes.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

Good luck, gmp3! I hope it all works out for you.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

"I was under the impression that the lien holder usually made only a token payment, like a dollar or so."

No, the lien holder normally bids up to the value of the lien (plus incurred expenses) to ensure they get the property and preserve their ownership.

I do not know about Florida, but the standard Fannie/Freddie note defines the terms of the foreclosure and auction process.

The note holder bids like everyone else (since they are bidding on their own note it is not like money actually changes hands though).

Second mortgage holders bid also, since if they do not win the house their note is erased.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

Thanks, brickeyee. There was an interesting situation in our area recently where the bank didn't appear for the auction (they claimed afterwards they weren't properly notified of the date) and a third party bidder managed to get the property at a very good price (maybe 50K-ish for a house expected to sell for about 150K after it listed again). The bank wants the house back and the buyer claims he bought it legitimately. AFAIK there's been no final outcome yet on that one.


 o
RE: Foreclosure offer pricing

Since the auctioneer is normally an agent of the bank (or a subsidiary agent of the bank through a subcontractor) the may find themselves in a bad way depending on how hard the purchaser is wiling to fight.

It the trustee on the note issued the required foreclosure advertising (I am sure you have seen them in the paper) the auction mat very well have been correct and valid.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Buying and Selling Homes Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here