Return to the Buying and Selling Homes Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Home inspection - lots o'problems

Posted by spucky (My Page) on
Sat, Jul 25, 09 at 18:40

I bought a house last year. Had an inspection from a licensed, ASHI inspector. He missed a furnace that was improperly installed - can't be accessed for repairs or maintenance. Said furnace was fine. His report recommended a maintenance contract and annual maintenance. I got the contract and the technician came out. Looked at furnace and laughed. Furnance installed so close to wall that he can't get inside. Former owner aware per gas company - had a repair down in 2007 and access problem identified. Lied on disclosure - said "no problems." Garage floods. Seller lied about that too. Inspector noted flat lot. After watching storm water flow down driveway and into garage called a paving guy. Driveway is clearly graded toward garage, not away. Signs of long-term water damage in garage. Cost to fix driveway $1500, cost to replace furnace $3500. Got recommendation to obtain a dispute home inspection and to go after first inspectors errors and omissions coverage. Any thoughts on going after the home inspector, seller or both? I'm in MA - inspectors can't limit their liability to cost of the inspection if they are negligent. Can I go after the home inspector myself without a lawyer? Notify him of my clain and tell him to contact his insurance company? Small claims court for the seller? I don't want to spend a fortune on attorney fees for a 5K problem. Thanks!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Home inspection - lots o'problems

Was the inspector recommended by RD agent? Broker? Could put in complaint to state board. Am not familiar with certification of inspectors, so you many need a legal consultation. Talk to realtor that sold the house.


 o
RE: Home inspection - lots o'problems

"Was the inspector recommended by RD agent? Broker? Could put in complaint to state board."

If you have a problem, this is a good place to start.

Here is a link that might be useful: Division of Professional Licensure


 o
RE: Home inspection - lots o'problems

The home inspector was not recommended by a RE person. The state board in MA rarely disciplines, and there is no compensation for damages. I'm weighing taking action myself as opposed to hiring a lawyer whose bill will quickly exceed the damages.


 o
RE: Home inspection - lots o'problems

Fully understand the cost/benefit roadblock of involving a lawyer in a 4-figure dispute. But consider that fast and satisfying results can often be obtained by:

a) paying a hungry lawyer just $150-$300 dollars to write an intimidating letter of intent, aka the NASTYGRAM! ;')

b) Loading up on intimidating legalese your own self, and writing your own NASTYGRAM. I've found the books from Nolo Press to be especially useful in this regard. Often stocked by your local public library. MASS is known for great public libraries.

If you're willing to invest the time, you CAN shame this inspector and/or their ins. co. to cough up the $$... the internet is your friend!

You can start by ID'ing the lax inspector right here in this thread! Won't help me in FL, but MA is a populous state, so a great public service will be performed.

The 2 oversights you've cited are so BASIC that you MUST get compensated for them. In fact, AFAIK, they are both OUTRIGHT *CODE VIOLATIONS*! Zero excuse for passing them.

Getting the lame inspector DE-licensed would be nice too.


 o
RE: Home inspection - lots o'problems

As I understand it, the inspector's contract is pretty ironclad in protecting him/her from almost any damages.

My daughter did have a septic problem (the septic had been re-done as per the inspection) however, it was apparently not done according to code (even though the county engineer had approved it)
Anyway, long story short -- an attorney made several calls to the septic company, county engineer & the result was that my daughter got a new septic at no cost to her (other than hefty attorney fees)

I'd try to consult with the best real estate attorney I could find to see if you have recourse from the inspector or former owner. It does sound like the disclosure was not true.
Good luck
Susan


 o
RE: Home inspection - lots o'problems

Spucky,

I've seen MANY furnaces that have limited access for maintenance. Usually noted on an inspection but not cause to sue. Does the furnace work? What do you want a new furnace?

>> Signs of long-term water damage in garage <<

Are these signs readily visible? High water marks, crumbling drywall etc? Otherwise the inspector is also off the hook.

Sounds like your biggest beef is with the former owner and "disclosure" of flooding/water damage.

Bob


 o
RE: Home inspection - lots o'problems

Sounds like the furnace works? This could get sticky if you are wanting to sue for $3500 just to get access to a working furnace. You really need to talk to a real estate attorney. The initial consulation should be pretty reasonable and then you decide what to do based on attorney's guidance.


 o
RE: Home inspection - lots o'problems

The Mass regulations do not require the HI to report on the ease of service for a furnace. HI's are not service technicians; as such, with the many varied models on the market, and not having had to service a furnace, they can't equivocally provide information in that respect.

As far as the water damge is concerned...if the driveway is clearly graded toward the garage, and there were signs of water damage in the garage, indeed the HI should have reported both...

That said, prior to closing, I'm not clear on why did not ask him about those two issues when you saw that they were excluded from the report.


 o
RE: Home inspection - lots o'problems

Thanks to all. I'm taking fixizin's advice.


 o
RE: Home inspection - lots o'problems

I'd have another HVAC guy come out and look at the furnace before you spend a lot of money tryng to "right the wrong". Where we live, most of the HVAC guys are like old busy bodies. They look at your system and gossip and belittle the work and choices of their competitors. Maybe someone else can figure out how to service your furnace.


 o
RE: Home inspection - lots o'problems

spucky, there is one problem with fixiszins advice...a home inspection is NOT a code inspection, by nationally accepted standards and most state's laws..including Massachusettes.

Code inspections are performed by CODE inspectors.
A home inspector does not pass or fail anything. They cite and describe visible defects. Somtimes those defects are also code issues, but the HI will cite it as a safety issue of deficiency...not a code issue.

So...if you try to use that argument, you will have little if no success.

From the Masachusettes regulations: '6.02: Purpose

(1) The purpose of a Home Inspection for Residential Buildings, including their attached garages, is to provide the Client with an inspection Report that forthrightly discloses the physical conditions of the systems and components listed in 266 CMR 6.04 which are Readily Accessible and Observable, including those systems and components, which are Safety Hazards as Observed at the time of the inspection.'

Here is a link that might be useful: Standards of Practice


 o
RE: Home inspection - lots o'problems

But Logic, suing is just soooooo PC!


 o
RE: Home inspection - lots o'problems

ncrealestateguy: "But Logic, suing is just soooooo PC!"

Sadly, so it is...


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Buying and Selling Homes Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here