Return to the Buying and Selling Homes Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

Posted by southernmum (My Page) on
Mon, Feb 15, 10 at 15:26

Just wondering what buyers will think...We bought this house with squeaky floors. Should clarify - squeaky on the carpeted floors, NOT the hardwoods we have all downstairs. Anyway, the carpet looks fine, but the only way we know how to fix squeaks is to remove carpet, screw into floor joists and put carpet back down. With five bedrooms upstairs (where we all currently SLEEP), this kind of project would be very disruptive. We are ready to list and the house is perfect other than this. Many updates -- new kitchen, new pool, etc. BUT all the rooms upstairs have squeaks. Would you buy a house like this, or would it make you reconsider?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

I would overlook as squeak here and there, but if it sounded like a mouse stampede as I crossed the floor, it would raise red flags.


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

What's under the carpet upstairs? If it's hardwoods why not just remove the carpeting. The hardwoods would probably be a great selling point!


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

I had friends who couldn't stand their squeaking floors. So they drove hundreds of nails and screws through the carpet and hardwood underneath till everything was quiet. I pity subsequent owners who thought there was beautiful hardwood underneath the wall-to-wall. In an old home, the sounds of silence make me very wary!


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

No, there are not hardwoods beneath the carpet. Just typical subflooring you find under carpet and pad. Wish there was hardwood! Anyway, I guess we have to try putting screws thru the carpet to silent the squeaks, but that worries me! I could see really messing up the carpet! Thanks for the replies.


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

I remember seeing something about squeaky floor fixes on TV a while back -- I think it was on "Ask This Old House." You might want to have a look there. It didn't look too bad, really.


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

If you're selling the house, you try to remove as many buyers' objections as you can beforehand.

I'd say excessive squeaking will be really offputting in a house less than fifty years old. After that, houses--and people--show increasing signs of wear.


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

Screws through the carpet? Is this really considered OK?

As a prospective buyer, I'd be TICKED when I found out about that. And if I happened to find out before the sale had closed, I'd back out in a hurry. To me, that kind of 'repair' is worse than duct tape, and signals the kind of seller that probably cut corners everywhere possible.

My advice? Do it right! Peel back the carpet, screw down your flors, put the carpet back down.


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

You don't screw through the carpet, you have the carpet pulled back and then restetched. Please don't screw through the carpet.


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

No, I would not buy a house whose whole upper floor squeaked. It'd make me very uneasy and give me the feeling like the builder wasn't very good.


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

" Anyway, I guess we have to try putting screws thru the carpet to silent the squeaks, but that worries me! I could see really messing up the carpet!"

Don't do that!

Do it properly, or prospective buyers will wonder what other half-@ssed fixes have been done throughout the house.


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

Yes, you can fix he squeaks without removing the carpet. Below is a link from this old house explaining how to do it. You shouldn't just start driving screws through the carpet though.

Here is a link that might be useful: this old house


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

Good link.

Here it is. Available from Amazon etc.


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

Cool Tool! Who knew?


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

Calm down, people! Of course I would do it the proper way, and I was referring to the method shown on the link posted above by Worthy. Someone on the flooring board referred me to this tool a few weeks back, and YES, you do go thru the carpet. Their tool trims off the nail/screw head so it doesn't damage your carpet. And as I mentioned in my original post, the other option is for us to pull it back, put the screws in, and then have the carpet put back down. Thanks to you guys who are truly trying to help me, and thanks Worthy for posting the link. Interesting tool... Some others are so quick to judge and think that every seller is out to take shortcuts and cheat the buyer -- but that's definitely NOT the case here.


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

I think the point is that a repair that seems to be half-a$$ed will turn off prospective buyers by making them think the sellers were out to take shortcuts.

That video shows how the repair can be done well, even through the carpet -- so it would no longer qualify as a 'duct tape job.'


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

You can cut down on the squeeking, but you can't be squeek-free! It's guaranteed, just like cracks in concrete.


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

"You can cut down on the squeeking, but you can't be squeek-free! It's guaranteed, just like cracks in concrete."

Funny, my early 30s house does not have any squeaks.


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

"Thanks to you guys who are truly trying to help me."

Why are you being a jerk? People were trying to help you. Maybe you should learn to write more clearly. Re-read your own posts. You never mentioned you were going to use a special tool, you said you thought your only option would be to screw through the carpet since you didn't want the disruption of removing the carpet. The vasy majority out their would assume you meant what you said. You know, when you hear hooves think horses, not zebras.

I think you should look around at the rest of the house. If the subfloors are that squeeky the subfloors were likely not screwed to the joists. The house was probably cheaply built.


 o
RE: Would you buy a house with squeaky floors?

Here is the product that was on This Old House.

Here is a link that might be useful: squeek no more


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Buying and Selling Homes Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here