Return to the Pools & Spas Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Another DFW Pool Quote

Posted by jennyn (My Page) on
Tue, Oct 13, 09 at 12:03

Hi All,
Ive been lurking the site for the last month and have gained so much knowledge from you folks here. Thank you for all the posted questions and the expert advice answers. We have been busy getting quotes for our pool, and like most of you have stated on here, the quotes are so different and its really hard to compare it. After receiving 5 quotes, we are thinking about going with this plan. Can you please review our quote and advise if its reasonable as well as if we are missing anything? We are going with a salt water free foam pool with a spa. Thanks for all your help.

Pool
Pool Type: Play Pool
Size: 30x36
Area: 743 sq ft
Perimeter: 124 ft.
Depth: 4x5x4
Pump Type: Jandy
Pump Size: 2.0hp
Filter Type: Cartridge
Filter size: CL 460
Cleaner: Polaris 280
Sanitizer: Salt
Skimmer: 2
Drains: 4
Returns: 6
Overflow: yes
Backwash: no
Pool Light: 2
Deck Area: 1474 sq ft
Deck Type: Stamp Concrete
Tile: Standard Choice
Coping: OK Flagstone
Plaster Type: Stonescape

8 Ton Waterfall

Spa
Size: 7ft
Elevation: 18"
Jets: 6
Blower: 2hp
Heater: 400BTU
Control: PDA
Light: 1 color

Total Cost: $60,875

Option: Add a 17x20 Arbor: $3,700

Also, can anyone advise their thoughts on Stonescape vs Pebbletec vs Pebblesheen. We are planning to stay at this house for a long time and did not want to re-plaster the pool in a few years. This PB quoted us Stonescape, and would like to get your opinion it. Again, thanks for your help.

Image and video hosting by TinyPic

Image and video hosting by TinyPic

Image and video hosting by TinyPic
Jenny


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

Does not look too bad with all the decking. I would upgrade the cleaner the the 480, it is belt driven with less wear parts.

Who is the builder?


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

Hi garageworksguy,
I will check with my builder about upgrading the cleaner to 480. The PB is Hopkins Pool in Rockwall, a friend of ours build a pool with them a few years ago and referred us to them.

Jenny


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

The 280 is more reliable.

Scott


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

Stonescapes is the "generic" version of pebble-Tec. Pebble_Tec had a lock on the technology for 7 years and that is now up so Stronescapes came out. They are the same thing. I started installing Stonescapes last year in Florida and have not had any problems at all with it.


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

Jayster,
Thanks for your input on the stonescrape. That is the same thing our PB told us, it's a generic version of Pebbletec and the material is the same. My only concern is the warranty. Is pebbletec worth the extra 1K?

Also, I have a question on the infloor cleaning system. We are debating about adding it and don't know if it's worth the extra 6K. Any input is appreciated. Thanks.

Jenny


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

If power costs in your area are rising or you expect them to, you might want to consider an E-Pump. A 2HP is a lot for circulation without the waterfall running.

A separate pump for the waterfall would be useful so you can run the E-Pump with the spa at the same time.

Scott


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

I agree with Scott, the 280 would fine for your pool.

There is no reason to spend any more on Pebble-Tec than Stonescapes. You said that you are concerned about the warranty. Does that not concern you about your pool builder?

What were your main reasons for choosing such a small builder?

FYI, in-floor systems are great if they are in the right kind of yard and properly installed. Make sure there is plenty of experience by the plumber.


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

Scott & Adpoolman,
Thanks for the input on the 280 cleaner. The reason why I was concern between pebbletec & Stonescape was because I read pebbletec has 20 years warranty vs Stonescape, which I thinks only have 5 years or so. After looking at both materials in person and talking to the pb, I'm leaning toward the stonescape. I have interviewed several different PB and I get different recommendations on the infloor cleaning system, so this one is still up in the air. Thanks for your inputs.

Jenny


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

It's my understanding that Stonescapes has a lifetime warranty; I was under the impression that it is actually better than Pebble-Tec (but, then again, that could be a factor of which pool guy I'm talking to!). Has anyone else heard this?


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

That is a great deal. Here in Raleigh, I am building a similar pool except:
4 ton waterfall
Badujet
589sqft 23X36
Polaris 480
one LED light in pool and One Led light in Spa
6inch elevation 7ft spa
620ft of concrete (my own stone mason is doing the entire pool in Varigated tennessee flag)
BlueRidgeGranite finish
All Hayward equipment
$58,000


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

Jencjudd,

If the builder wants to put that warranty in writing before signing...I suspect he was talking to hear himself rather than knowing what he was saying.

Soap Box Note: Personal preference, In-Floor systems are expensive, need a substantial amount of flow to work well, and have issues when an algae bloom strikes. I prefer the Polaris 280 and Legend and Legend-II pressure side cleaners. Cheaper, highly effective in most situations, and reliable.

Jennyn,

If the difference in price is only $1000, go with the PebbleTec. Its worth it for the fact that it's a proven product and will continue to be around a long time to back the warranty.

Terryibra,

The Badu is Speck. Have two broom sticks handy so you can set the jet nozzles direction to suit your needs.
What Hayward equipment?
I assume the flagstone is just the coping?
Its going to be a very cozy foot well with more than 2 people in the spa.
I suspect that one LED in the pool may not be enough, especially when you go from white to colors. White tends to travel better than red, blue or green and will be dim and washed at the perimeter.


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

poolguynj, this is off my contract....
h400 heater
2.5 2sp pump
550 cart
VID cleaner + booster
The flagstone is the entire pool and decking but I am doing that through my own sub outside of the pool price.
I wanted two lights but he told me one is enough. We are pouring the deck this week. Can the light be added later if needed?


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

Let us know if it's a Universal series or H series heater.
I assume the pump will be a Tri-Star.
The 550 is an Above Ground filter. Might want to check that.
Let us know how the Viio cleaner works. It replaced the Viper, which was a problematic product for many end users.
Hope you got credited for the 620 sq. ft. of deck in that price or was that including the stone mason's bill with the pool cost?


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

All,
Thanks for the inputs. We have signed the contract a few weeks ago, and decided to go with stonescape due to the lifetime warranty. Also, instead of going with the polaris 280, we are going with the Paramount In-Floor cleaning system as well as a ozonator. We are waiting for the city permit and I'm expecting to break ground within the next week. Looking forward to this build job.

Jenny


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

poolguynj, the 620sq is the subdecking for the flagstone. it is suppose to be 2 inches of stone and 4 inches of concrete. The heater is h-series. I am looking into the filter... it is the cartridge kind I am going with Blue Haven Pools and it is the smart filter 550 with microban. The vac is the smartvac vip pool cleaner. I also added the smartflow jetsystem with the added returns to circulate the water for my heater. I think the pump is tri-star but I will have to ask him to double check. I asked him about the light today, he says it is 50% brighter and should be fine We have already finished the gunite so I hope he is right because it is too late now. thanks, Clark


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

BH usually uses, at least in my area, Haward gear. Sometimes it is rebadged with a BH name.

The Hayward 4.0 lights are brighter than it's previous generations but get two, one fixture won't evenly light it. It's worth the upgrade. This has been discussed here many times. There was even a fellow that posted pix of Pentair vs Hayward's LEDs.

The filter is probably going to be a rebadged Hayward SwimClear 525 sq. ft. 4 cartridge unit and not what I thought was the Hayward above ground unit.

I suspect the SmartVac is a RayVac. They work well and usually don't require a booster pump.

Scott


 o
RE: Another DFW Pool Quote

is it too late to add the light after the pool has been gunited in? I will talk to him about this again. maybe there is a retrofit option?


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Pools & Spas Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here