Return to the Pools & Spas Forum
| Post a Follow-Up
ColorLogic 4.0 vs Pentair IntelliBrite - Pool Test which is best?
| | |
Posted by landa_mac (My Page) on Sat, Jun 20, 09 at 11:51
| You see all my posts here praising Pentair's IntelliBrite light and how it is the only LED light that uses advanced lens and reflector technology.
What does this translate to in a pool???
At the request of one of my customers, I recently tested Hayward's new ColorLogic 4.0 LED Pool light and compared it to Pentair's IntelliBrite Color LED Pool light. Both lights were submerged 18" and positioned at the same angle. Both lights were held approximately 6 inches from the pool wall on a plate of wood that I constructed. Both lights were tested in their White mode where all of the Red, Green, and Blue LEDs are turned on in order to simulate white.
Here are the results:
Hayward's ColorLogic 4.0 Color LED Pool light (uses 28 LEDs and consumes 95W):
Note that there are two dark spots. The first is very dark and is located within the first 5 feet of the light. The second is located about 10 feet out in the pool (bottom drain is about halfway between both).
Pentair's IntelliBrite Color LED Pool light (uses 32 LEDs and consumes 70W):
Note that the dark spots are absent. Also note how the light is illuminating the pool walls to the immediate left and right of the light. There is also less glare coming off the light (more of the light is staying in the pool). Finally, note the consistency of the light's color throughout the pool. This is the result of having a lens and reflector. Pentair is using optics to maximize the light in the pool by directing it. I can't say enough good things about this light!
Sometimes a picture is worth a thousand words! |
Follow-Up Postings:
RE: ColorLogic 4.0 vs Pentair IntelliBrite - Pool Test which is b
| | |
RE: ColorLogic 4.0 vs Pentair IntelliBrite - Pool Test which is b
| | |
| Wow, Thanks for the comparison. Thats a substantial difference in both energy usage and disbursement. Scott |
RE: ColorLogic 4.0 vs Pentair IntelliBrite - Pool Test which is b
| | |
| poolguynj - yes! My customer put 16 of the IntelliBrites in his pool (actually backyard water park!). So he was very interested in not only illumination but wattage consumption! |
RE: ColorLogic 4.0 vs Pentair IntelliBrite - Pool Test which is b
| | |
| How old is your interior finish? What is it? Thanks for the great side-by-side comparison on the light... |
RE: ColorLogic 4.0 vs Pentair IntelliBrite - Pool Test which is b
| | |
| This particular pool's finish is about 20 years old and in bad need of a new plaster finish! |
RE: ColorLogic 4.0 vs Pentair IntelliBrite - Pool Test which is b
| | |
| I've had the old style Colorlogics for 5 seasons and can't remember ever setting it on "white." Did you happen to compare depth of colors, etc? I don't see any need to upgrade but when these fail some future (hopefully distant) time I want to be in the know. thanks...Ralph |
RE: ColorLogic 4.0 vs Pentair IntelliBrite - Pool Test which is b
| | |
| Hi Ralph, Yes, we compared at all the colors. In general, the various colors resulted in the same effects as seen in the pictures above. |
RE: ColorLogic 4.0 vs Pentair IntelliBrite - Pool Test which is b
| | |
| thanks...we have some neighbors putting in pools and they love our lights. I'm going to suggest they look at these lights as well as view this thread. Very informative. Ralph |
|
|
|
|