Return to the Pools & Spas Forum
| Post a Follow-Up
Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
Posted by dogbone10 (My Page) on Fri, Feb 29, 08 at 14:17
| I just starting a pool build (dig is today) and I definately want to go with the new Jandy variable speed pump. However they are telling me it is late March or early April. Does anybody have this pump in trials? thoughts? They claim they are doing trials in southern California. I need to know specs as soon as possible as the pool company is going to make me make a decision within the next couple of weeks. Jandy support says it is similar (but better...) than the Intelliflo as opposed to the 4-160. |
Follow-Up Postings:
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| They have been claiming it's coming since last fall. It's a 6 speed pump but not variable like the IntelliFlo 3.2. Figure about the specs on a JHP Stealth. I would not hold up a pool job on a maybe from a manufacturer. Why not go with what's available now? |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| I am not sure how the Jandy pump is better that the 4X160, or Intelliflo. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| They might mount the controller separately from the pump instead of on the pump itself keeping the controller less subject to the heat and vibration of the motor. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| They do. It's a wall mounted controller but the IntelliFlo does not run hot so that is not an issue. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Personally, I would rather go with IntelliFlo which has been out in the field for about 3 years now than a new just released pump. Just my two cents. I wish I would have taken my own advice when it came to Operating Systems. Vista was a nightmare... |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Like landa, I'd go with IntelliFlo because it's proven. One builder claimed Jandy's was inferior because it doesn't use rare-earth magnets (due to patents held by PentAir). I'm not sure if this was marketing fluff, or is a legitimate disadvantage. Unlike landa, I'm loving Vista. Glad I put it on when I did. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Jandy tech support is claiming it is a full variable speed pump. I don't know if they use rare earth magnets. I would go with the Intelliflo 3.2 but I would only get one year warranty with it compared to 5 years with the Jandy. That is a big difference. Pool builder will only warranty Pentair for the length that Pentair provides which I am being told is 1 yr. I did find out that Pentair sued Jandy because of this pump, trying to delay it's release. I would find it hard to believe that Jandy didn't do their homework on getting around the patents. All my other equipment will be Jandy given the warranty issue. If I have to go with Pentair it would only be the intelliflo 3.2 pump integrated into Jandy's one touch system. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| The 3.2 works great with an IntelliCom. The fact that on gives a 5 year warranty does not make it better. If you study the nature of the IntelliFlo, you'll find the usual suspects on motor wear are addressed pretty well. It has a 2+year head start on your unproven Jandy so it basically amounts to 3 years of uncertainty. Pentair will give you 3 on a total package but you are not going that way. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| I wanted to reply and hopefully revive this thread for any updates anyone may have about the Jandy Variable Speed Pump. As I am expanding my search for a PB (after being on hold for a while) I am going to have to consider Jandy dealers/equipment as well. As Dogbone10 mentions, you get can get a better extended warranty if you go with a builder who offers an equipment package (Jandy or Pentair) or other Builder extended option. The few others that I contacted previously mixed and matched so this option was not even presented. Expect more posts with questions on Jandy equipment :) and I don't care if you are a dealer or an employee--just want to find out what I can so I know what to expect. Unfortunately, I have found the Jandy customer service reps very pleasant, but they can never tell me more than is on the website already--or maybe they haven't been given any exact information as yet. The pool--if we ever get one built--would not be operational until late spring at most, so it may be a possible consideration. I have already read the other threads on the 2-speed vs. VS/VF and have considered this. It will also depend on how it might enhance/or not the operation with an optional in-floor system or circulation system (and even this may not be an issue as it may not be an option due to cost). Someone mentioned it might be a 6 speed rather than a true variable speed. I am curious to know if it will be more like the Pentair VF (where you can program/set a specific desired flow). Thanks to anyone who can provide more specific information. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Still looking for some info . . . anyone? |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| It's called the Jandy ePump. Last I was told, it was to be available this month. Requires O.2 firmware on the Aqualink. The O.2 firmware also has support for the Intelliflo VF/VS pumps. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Thanks Afnajs-- Thanks for the information as I am really leaning toward the Jandy ProEdge Builder at this point who offered the extended warranty as (opposed to others who also sell Jandy but do not). Let's hope that the company will price it "right" to get it out to the public in large numbers more quickly. And, if they offer a great warranty on the pump too it will allay a lot of the fears we consumers might have about trying something so new. Just a suggestion ;). I would really like the energy savings over time but there is still so much more to consider cost-wise in equipment options, including automated controls that would be needed to operate the pump????I assume? |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| I have been patiently waiting for Jandy to release this pump. In the meantime I went with a 21/2HP Stealth pump (although it is really not so stealth in my opinion) and have been using the low speed feature for the past 2 months or so, 5 days a week. It is keeping the pool clean even though I have a paramount in floor cleaning system. On weekends I run the pump at high speed to give it that extra clean as far as any dirt that might be left on the floor. This seems to help a lot and my electricity bill has dropped close to $85-90/month by going this route verses running it on high speed alone. Ideally I want to run a pump at a bit more water flow than what I get out of the low speed which is why I am most interested in the new Jandy pump. Run it somewhere in between the high speed and the low speed. Help the infloor system clean better too. As far as this pump being available this month, I wouldn't hold my breath. I have been in contact with Jandy's product manager for this pump in the past and their tech. support people both of which have claimed the wrong release date at least 3 times. Indeed the last I heard, it was to be release either "November or January" this is over a year late from when I started to track the release of this. I can hear a lot of you saying I should have gone with the 4160 and be done with it but I wanted that 5 yr. warranty and I didn't negotiate this upfront as this was all new to me. I am still hoping I can convince the pool builder to upgrade me at just the cost difference since the current pump is only 6 months old. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Hi Dogbone10-- A few questions for you . . . First, is the 5 year warranty you are getting from your PB a special offer? I thought the ProEdge dealers warranty was only 3 years? I think you did the right thing going with the longer warranty on an existing pump. If you have read some of my other threads you will know this is why I will ultimately select one PB vs another. I just can't see spending so much for high-end equipment and fancy electronics only to have them fail in the first year . . . and if you know any one that has a pool it can happen. Since my pool will be for next season I am thinking I might have a chance. I don't think they will release it until January myself so as not to throw dealers into having to get up-to-speed, so to speak, until the off-season. Second, I am guessing you are referring to the fact that the pump might not be as quiet as some of the Pentair pumps. How far away did you place your equipment from the pool wall? How far is your run to the spa? I am thinking about going to the 26-50 foot range, but hope this won't hurt the spa operation. What size plumbing did your PB use on the Suction Side and also the Discharge Side? Third, I am thinking of requesting the same pump the 2 & 1/2 HP, is your part # SHPM 2.5 - 2? Here is a link that might be helpful: http://www.jandy-downloads.com/pdfs/pumprefguide.pdf Fourth, Can you please, please, help with information regarding your in-floor system as I am agonizing over this expense. What model Paramount system did you have installed. My one PB offers the current PCC200, but I do not know anyone who has this particular manufacturer's system, although I have seen much older pools (10+ that had working Paramount systems). It would be tremendously helpful to me to know if this was an upgrade to their circulation system that the PB might offer as standard or was it a total system add on? If I could get this system at a reasonable cost it would help me to finalize a decision to go forward with the pool at this time. If you would prefer to send more specifics directly, I set up a g-mail account so that I could corresponded with people on this site: NJFolks4@gmail.com. Fifth, would you mind sharing your other Jandy equipment choices of filter, heater, lights and automation and the size of your pool. Hope you don't mind me asking, but I am trying to coordinate what would be the best in some cases while not duplicating electronics, oh and energy efficiency to keep those bills down too. I have heard about horribly high gas bills for heating here in NJ. Wow, a lot of questions, so I hope this is not too much. THANKS for any help you are willing to provide. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Hi Njfolks Sorry I didn't get back to you earlier. Got too busy to check these forums. Regarding your questions, I'll give it a try to answer what I know. The pool builder I used was Premier Pools out of Salida california (near Modesto, CA) They are a Pro-edge dealer and one of the reasons I went with them was references and their warranty service. They said it was 5 years and is written in the contract. Regarding the noise, I have nothing to compare it to. I tend to think that Stealth means quiet something less than a car engine at idle. That is the not the case at full speed with my Jandy pump. However at low speed it is very low noise less than a V8 at idle. The equipment is right next to the house (I live in CA so our neighbors fence is just 8 feet away) and the distance to the spa is about 35 feet. The plumbing on suction side is 21/2in and everything else is 2in. yes on the pump size you are looking at. Infloor - I did a lot of reading on this forum and talked to some people ultimately deciding to go with the Paramount PV3 system. My pool builder charged me $3800 if I remember correctly, an extra upgrade to the base pool. One thing that I got advice on doing was to make sure they run a pool sweep line just in case you have to shut down the infloor system (earthquakes or whatever bad things can happen in New Jersey) almost zero extra cost (they did it at no cost for me) So far (6 months) the system is working great. They followed Paramounts recommendations for head placement and I double checked with both Paramount and while the installation was happening. Leaves, dirt etc all get cleaned well. Paramount recommends 60gpm to effectively run it however as I said before I run it at low speed (roughly 30gpm with the Stealth pump) still works for both leaves and dirt. I did check with paramount on the longevity and about the only thing to break would be the floor heads (give you a lifetime warranty) and the zone switcher (for lack of a better term). This is the device that switches zones. Those will last about 5-6 yrs and cost $300 to replace. Last items: Heater is LXi; CL580 filter; jandy colored lights (not LED as they came out just after my lights got installed otherwise would have gone with LED); PDA 8; aquapure salt generator; The higher end control box (not sure the model number - there were two models); pool size is about 15k gallons 6.5ft deep 32ft by 17ft free form shape; one sheer decent and a 6 jet raised spa with chatterfall into the pool. Lastly, I did go with a solar heating (8 panels) system and never, never, never will heat my pool with the gas heater.... I'm sure famous last words... |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Hi Dogbone10-- Thanks so much for taking the time to reply. If you get a chance I have a follow-up question about the operating cost of the in-floor system. I am still deciding which way to go regarding equipment which will affect the choice of PB. So, your all your information is much appreciated. I have the same concerns about having the best operational speed (lowest effective speed for economy sake) that will operate an in-floor system. No word yet on the ePump. You mentioned your electricity bill dropping $85 - $90 a month when you didn't run it on high speed all the time. Any idea what the additional cost is to run the in-floor for the minimum necessary each day to clean (at least once) the pool. Well, without the year round sun to rely on most NJ people go with gas (not so concerned with earthquakes here if that's the concern besides cost in CA) although I would consider other options if it weren't for the spa. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Assuming the Jandy e-pump is out by now, can anyone compare Jandy's variable speed pump with the Pentair Intelliflo VS 3050? Many thanks! |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Operating advice from anyone with experience using this new pump from Jandy? If you've replaced a one-speed or two-speed pump have you noticed any energy savings? |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| In the NE there is very little if any need for a variable speed.... I have a 2 speed on my pool and it saves about $45 a month in electric.... you cannot operate a spa or a cleaner on anything less than 100%... variable speed is at home when you can operate a pool or a water feature on max flow and then turn down the speed to have max results.... I hope this makes sense.. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| njfolks, I'm in the process of replacing my 2 HP Jandy pump with the ePump. My system was originally installed about five years ago, so in addition to the ePump, my Aqualink needed an upgrade too. Thankfully, Jandy has a special upgrade program that keeps the cost down. I'm in California so we're subject to a tiered pricing program. With my 2HP pump, I'm almost always in the 300-400% over baseline so my energy bills are $300-500 a month. I'm hopeful that with the switch over to the ePump, I can get reduce my energy consumption enough to get me back into the 200% over baseline range. In any case, I know what my daily consumption is for the 2HP, so in a few days I'll have an idea on just how much the ePump is going to save me. I'm looking to run the ePump for about an hour a day at a higher rate for my suction cleaner, then ramp way down for maybe 10 hours of standard filtering. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Hi anfnajs-- Yes, I'm still following this thread, so anyone with real-life experience to report will be helpful. What type of sanitizer do you have for your pool and how slow can you do your turnover to save on electric? I am going to get a Paramount Clear O3 ozonator as a supplement to chlorine and want to know at what is the lowest speed to use this product at with the Jandy e-pump running pretty much 24/7 for filtration. Any advice from anyone who is using or has installed this combination? |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Why would you consider running the pump 24/7 ?.. Hi anfnajs-- Yes, I'm still following this thread, so anyone with real-life experience to report will be helpful. What type of sanitizer do you have for your pool and how slow can you do your turnover to save on electric? I am going to get a Paramount Clear O3 ozonator as a supplement to chlorine and want to know at what is the lowest speed to use this product at with the Jandy e-pump running pretty much 24/7 for filtration. Any advice from anyone who is using or has installed this combination? |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| I just spent the last two days converting my system from a 5 year old Jandy 2HP Stealth pump to the new Jandy 2HP e-pump. I chose the Jandy over the other options because I fully expected that I would be able to avoid any plumbing issues since both the older Stealth I had and the new e-pump had the same dimensions, same input/output locations, and presumably would use the exact same connections. Boy was I wrong. Jandy somewhere along the way changed the threads which forced me to seek out 2 and 2 1/2" PVC supplies to redo the plumbing. I expected the conversion to take 1/2 day to install and program the new Jandy RS8 PCB upgrade, and swap out the pump. Instead it took me 1 1/2 days. The Jandy e-pump instructions are not written for DIYers. I initially thought I would be hooking up the e-Pump to the Filter pump relay. I now realize that the pump gets wired directly from the circuit breaker because it is controlled directly by the RS8 OneTouch controller via the RS-485 serial connection. Once I figured that out and updated the information in the OneTOuch controller my OneTouch menu became less confusing. Although I have only had the e-Pump running for 24 hours I can honestly say I was blown away when I first powered it up. In fact, I thought it wasn't working at all it was so quite. I had to peer into the clear plastic strainer basket to confirm that water was actually flowing. I am really impressed at how little noise there is even when running at the higher speeds (>3,000RPM). My total cost for the pump and the RS8 controller update was just under $1,200 including shipping, and my power company gives me a $100 rebate for installing an energy efficient pump. I recently installed a solar system that dropped my electricity bill significantly ($546 Aug 2008 without solar to $86 Aug 2009 with solar). I am hoping that the addition of the e-pump will bring my monthly average to zero. The top tier rate for electricity in my area is $0.45/kilowatt hour. There was a real incentive for me to install the e-pump, and I hope it pays off. As a side benefit my pool equipment is MUCH quieter which I am sure my neighbors will also appreciate. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| The thread change was a surprise to me as well. Seems odd that given the versatility of having the quick-connects in the first place, it kind of defies explanation as to why they changed the thread pitch. Thankfully, I had all the 2 and 2.5-inch pipe so it was only a slight delay. Total time including an upgrade of the RS8 was about five hours (and a couple of beers). I was happy with the removal of the pump relay as it gained me a aux that I was able to put my misters on. The longer runtime of the pump does appear to benefit the salt-water chlorinator. I can run at lower output, and the constant circulation seems to help keep the chlorine levels consistent all day long. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| afnjs, Since you've been running your e-pump a bit longer than I have can you share how long you run the filtration mode for, and what speeds you are using for each of the various modes: filter spa solar cleaner % output for chlorine generator etc. Since the OneTouch displays the watts used for each speed I am trying to carefully balance the amount of power used vs effectiveness in each mode. Thanks for your information. As you may have found, there is very little information on the web about these pumps. It took me several months researching various web sites before I was willing to take a chance and order the pump and OneTouch upgrade kit. Hopefully your information can help others make the decision whether to switch. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| My pools 20K gallons, and I'm still messing a bit with the speeds. I'm in the process of adding a flow meter to the output of the pump (just before the filter) so that I can get a better idea of what GPM I get for a given RPM. For now, I've got the basic filtration running at 1700 RPM (about 220 watts per the display), for 10 hours a day. I've got the Jandy DE60 filter, and the pressure is running at about 4-6 PSI at that speed. Every other day, for three of those 10 hours, I switch over to my suction cleaner only, and drop the RPM's in the 1300 RPM range. I had tried running 1-2 hours per day on the suction cleaner, but I think the every-other-day with a longer runtime works better. Spa - Still playing with this. It is comfortable at about 2950, but it needs to be at about 3200 to really get the air/agitation. I have the AquaPure 1400. I've got it at 35% but I'm dropping it more every day as it's still producing too much. |
Pentair Intelliflo pumps
| | |
| Well, I have been happy with my Pentair Whisperflo Pump, but is time to replace prior to winter coming and the PG&E rebate expiring in 12/09. I have a Pentair 1 speed pump that is 13 years old and it is starting to suck air which means that sometimes it will not prime and gets too hot and melts the basket. And if I catch it in time, I can go outside and turn it off and see what the problem is and fix it. But, with winter coming and the freeze protection kicking on, I'm not about to stay up all night to watch it. Anyway, I'm looking at the Pentair Intelliflow VF or the VS-3050 pumps. I know that the VS-3050 requires the IntelliComm II relay to communicate with my Jandy AquaLink RS8 and to communicate to the inside house panel, but does the Intelliflow VF also require the IntelliComm II relay? I thought that the VF already had built-in communications? Also, from the materials that I have read, Pentair says that the elect savings on the VS-3050 is 30% and the VF pump is 90%. Has anyone actually seen this type of elect. savings? |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| You need the IntelliCom II for both VS and VF pumps if connected to a Jandy system. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| That is, if connected to a older Jandy system. "Also, from the materials that I have read, Pentair says that the elect savings on the VS-3050 is 30% and the VF pump is 90%. Has anyone actually seen this type of elect. savings? " That is a little misleading... The VF and VS have the same exact impeller, pump body, and motor. The only thing different is the drive, and the way it operates. If both pumps are running at the same RPM, both will consume the same amount of power. I feel that 90% number is because its easier to monitor the power consumption by the VF pump, and easier to properly set up. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Wanted to follow up on the ePump as I've now had it in service for a month. I still need to tweak a little of the higher-speed running for my suction-side cleaner as I think I can get the RPM's a bit lower, and thus drop the operation cost even further. That said, as it stands, here is what I'm seeing. Previous speed pump - Jandy 2.0 HP Stealth. New varible-speed pump - Jandy ePump Southern California Tier 5 energy cost: $0.36 kWh Tier 4 energy cost: $0.31 kWh Previous Single Speed Pump Costs per Month: $150 6-hour run per day Variable Speed Pump Costs per Month: $33 2 hours per day at 2750 (suction cleaning and skimming) - $17 per month 8 hours per day at 1750 (pool circulation) - $16 per month Savings so far: $117 per month ($1,404 year) With the introduction of the variable-speed pump, I've also dropped out of the Tier5 energy costs, resulting in a $0.05 drop per kWh!!! I paid under $900 for the ePump and got a $200 rebate from the power company. At this rate, I figure the pump will pay for itself in just under six months. Bottom line, be it the Jandy ePump or other variable-speed pump, the savings are significant and well worth the investment. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Sounds like my 2hp steath maybe going away. Tier 5 hurts Thanks SDGE |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| .36 cents a kWh? WOW!! For every kWh I use under 1000 it's approx $0.10 and then over 1000 it's $0.12. $0.36 is highway robbery! I'm going to have the 2 hp Jandy ePump on my new pool in about a month so I'll make sure to report back on the changes in my electric bill as well. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Yes leepoffaith I agree with you, it is about the same up here in Jacksonville. We decided to go with a 1 speed pump because I could not justify the increase for a 2 speed or variable. From what I can tell my power bill went up about $20 per mth. Last mth our power bill went up an extra $10 but that was because we used the heat pump 4 times. HTH |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
That's what we pay here in Southern California. Tier 1 is about $0.12 kWh but that's only for use within the ridiculously low baseline. It then jumps to $0.14 for up to 30% over baseline, then it's the pain cave from there... Tier3 (up to 100% over baseline) $0.26, Tier4 $0.31 (up to 200% over), and Tier 5 $0.36. Besides the ePump, I also replaced the halogen sAM pool lights with Intellibrites, and I'm still looking for a good alternative for the low-voltage under-20w halogen yard lights. With nearly 30 path, tree, etc. lights it adds up to another 900 watts with all the lights on. That's another $50 per month just to have all the backyard lights on. What's sad is that in 2004 when the pool/backyard was complete, we didn't have the rates we have now. I could keep everything on and I only added about $70 per month to the electric bill. Now it's over $200. :( |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Afnajs, just curious, but what is the "baseline" usage? I have a 2800 sq ft home and I use about 1700 kWh per month depending on the month. High summer it's more, low winter time it's less. Everything in my house is on electric as well because we have no gas (Water heater, dryer, stove, ect). |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| afnais, For the back yard lighting, LED lights are making a huge improvement in variety. They even come in X-Mas light strings! It makes a HUGE difference in consumption and still puts out enough useful light and ambiance. Scott |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Leepoffaith, baseline is 16 kWh per day, so for September, it was 480 kWh at the Tier 1 rate. In summer, I'm typically at 2200-2500 kWh, and in winter the low is about 1100 kWh. The change to the ePump should reduce my consumption across the board by 330 kWh per month. Pollguynj, I've looked at LED, but just like the christmas lights, they seem to produce a very odd pin-point light. Perhaps with the added benefit of the path lights covering it won't be noticed, so I'll need to give them a try. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| What speed setting would a Jandy e pump need to be for solar on a two story house 50%? I would think full speed to run the vacuum for a few hours. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Just got the 5.0 upgrade and 2HP epump today- cant figure out how to lock a different speed to the solar tap? Any advice? Uncle Dave (Davegvg) |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Did you set the controller dip switch to indicate that you have solar? If so, one of the options in the ePump speed defaults will say "Solar" and that's where you set the speed. |
RE: Jandy Variable Speed pump
| | |
| Thanks afnajs. Thats not it though I was setting the speed in the wrong place. Figured it out, there are 2 setting for variable speed- one is like a temporary setting the other seem to be its reference. Im pretty impressed I had the thing singing at full output today with the solar on and got 6 degrees out of the system in 6 hours of run time that's 166K+ btu and hour mid november. It really honks at full clip and is really quiet and efficient at low filter speed. Take a look http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kYN92oAcPgc Davegvg |
Post a Follow-Up
Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum. If you are a member, please log in. If you aren't yet a member, join now!
Return to the Pools & Spas Forum
|
|
|