Not sure, but I think you are talking about alcove tubs as the alternative, which are relatively easier, but what's the point if it's not what you want? Sure, drop-in's can be a pain and more costly to install, but the result is completely different, such as room around the perimeter for accessories, candles, etc. Don't be steered by some vague feeling that it won't be installed right, which happens to be convenient for the plumber. Each has it's method for proper installation.

Thanks very much, Homebound.
So, drop-ins are a pain to install? Would you say more about that?

Also, what is your opinion about how the finished result would look if I did the regular, non-drop-in tub & had framing around two sides? Odd? Okay?

Thanks!

"Pain" was not a good choice of words. Drop-in relies on solid, level carpentry (deck and frame), so as long as that's good and the drain is put in the right place, there should not be an issue. Somebody has to do the framing properly.

Alcove tubs can be tough sometimes, such as when there's a foam base and the floor underneath isn't perfectly level. Then it can creak when you stand in it unless they foam it and shim it, install the stringer, etc, just right. Lots of trial and error sometimes. Dealing with this comes with the territory.

Free-standing tubs are another thing altogether, since they just rest on the level, finished floor, then get hooked up.

Just choose what you want, then find the right guy to do it. I think you are right about not seeing the apron of an alcove tub. I did a bathroom recently that did use an alcove tub with apron, and that was the biggest regret of the client. But we did not have the depth for a drop in, so it had to be that way. You, on the other hand, presumably have the luxury to do what you want. Go for it.

Thanks for the additional information, Homebound. That helps a lot.

This fellow seemed really smart & was so nice, & he did seem like a capable, experienced plumber. He said he was 50 years old, so he should have 20-30 years of experience, I would think. Haven't gotten his pricing in the mail yet, so I'm still waiting to see if I can afford his services.

From what you're telling me, the freestanding tub is less of a wild card; it's fairly predictable, while the drop-in could introduce challenges. Don't know if the Kohler Archer drop-in would require the pesky foam you speak of.

A good plumber is worth his weight in gold imo. I have all these ideas, but need someone to help me bring them to fruition. At least I think I've found a good tile guy. Say a prayer to the plumber God for me!...Thanks again!

This is the drop-in model (smaller size) of the Kohler Archer tub. The freestanding model is sold at HD too.

Here is a link that might be useful: Kohler Archer