I got it! I rescued the toothbrush from the pits of the toilet!

I tried to get it out with a coat hanger before I made the above post. No luck. After I posted here I went and played around with it a bit more and finally got it out.

After I got the toothbrush out I flushed a bit of tp down just to see if it would clog. Sure enough it did. I don't know if maybe he flushed something else down there? But I plunged it and ran the wire hanger down a couple more times just to make sure...Hopefully I got it all....

I guess I need to invest in one of those snake thingys.

Or purchase a toilet lid lock to use until your little guy is old enough to know better. Cheaper, and more effective.