Return to the Plumbing Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
toilet still leaking at floor seal

Posted by jvan (My Page) on
Fri, Jan 2, 09 at 22:21

Hello,
One of the toilets in my house has a leak again as the hardwood floor around the base where the water runs is dark in color and moist and rotten. i have changed the wax ring with in the last year after a similar problem. when i inspected the toilet then it appeared fine, i don't see how it can be leaking really the way these things are constructed. there's no visible water around the toilet anywhere... any one have any other suggestions? thanks!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: toilet still leaking at floor seal

Check the outside of the toilet after a good hot, steamy shower. Could be soaking wet.


 o
RE: toilet still leaking at floor seal

When you replaced the wax ring the last time, did you carfully inspect the condition of the existing one, i.e. was it squashed all around? If any portion of the ring was only "barely squashed" or not compressed at all, that's your problem. Try a jumbo size ring (extra thick wax).


 o
RE: toilet still leaking at floor seal

The toilet is in a 1/2 bath, so no shower.

When I replaced this ring I did it 2x as the first time i cracked the plastic flange/ring at the bottom when tightening the bolts to hold the toilet to the floor. the ring was in good shape at that time and i think it was when i did the second one.. but i can't think of anything else it could be so I'll just replace the wax ring again. and this time i will use a jumbo ring or two normal size ones. no cracks appear in the bowl - it seems they'd be easy to spot.


 o
RE: toilet still leaking at floor seal

From experience I had a toilet that would leak, changed wax rings, still leaked. The toilet were new. Turns out there was a real fine crack in the toilet. Replaced the toilet and the leak went away.


 o
RE: toilet still leaking at floor seal

What plastic thing did you crack the first time?? The flange itself? If so, that would be the problem and would have to be repaired/replaced.

Careful tightening those hold-down bolts - they need to be snug, but that's it. You don't want to crack the toilet itself.


 o
RE: toilet still leaking at floor seal

Yes, the plastic toilet flange that sits flush on the floor was cracked as the first time i tightened the bolts to much. i found this was attached to the pipe itself so have no idea how to correct that. is that something i can do or must enlist professional help for? seems like a big job. at the time, i bought a metal flange by itself and placed that on top of the platic flange and used that to secure the bowl. i didn't tighten it to much so the bowl rocked some for the first 3 mos. i finally tightened it some more but now it's leaking some based off of the rotten wood. i think perhaps due to the rocking the seal became compromised. so, i'll try replacing the seal.


 o
RE: toilet still leaking at floor seal

You need to get the flange repaired before you reset the toilet. (If you think about it, bolting a toilet down to a broken flange can pull it apart even more, making the problem worse.) Hire a plumber so you can be sure it's set to the proper height, etc.

BTW, if the floor needs repair (eg. some boards replaced), now is the time to do that, too. Might help (cost less) to do that before the plumbing work.


 o
RE: toilet still leaking at floor seal

"i bought a metal flange by itself and placed that on top of the platic flange and used that to secure the bowl."

What is sealing between the flanges?
That is one possible place it could be leaking.

"...so the bowl rocked some for the first 3 mos..."

This is another possible cause of the leaking.
Once the wax gets compressed it does not 'spring back' and fill any gap.


 o
RE: toilet still leaking at floor seal

you need to fix the flange...or its gonna keep leaking
and if it keeps leaking, rotten qwood floor, mold
all that good junk that comes with neglect...
pull the toilet
cut the flange off, and replace it.i can tell you how to do it. that is if you want to diy. or you can call a plumber
let me know whitch whitch is whitch frodo


 o
RE: toilet still leaking at floor seal

This is eerily similar to a problem I had at my house :-)

I did not have a cracked flange; however the toilet would NOT stop leaking. I tried an extra big wax seal; two wax seals...finally I scraped all that crap up, tossed it, and bought one of those gaskets that does NOT use wax.

I believe my toilet was leaking due to an uneven floor. The gaskets they sell these days seal tightly to your toilet, and then empty into your sewer well below the level of the floor, completely bypassing all problems due to flanges, uneven floors, etc. I'd repair the flange so you have a good solid connection, they sell kits for that too, easy as pie, and then use a gasket kit without wax.
Of course I'm a hardcore DIY'er, you should just call a plumber if you're in over your head!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Plumbing Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here