and I love the new navy homes but my next-door neighbor just went with a gorgeous navy so we cant be twins. LOL

Its looking great. Thanks for coming back and showing us the progress. Its not often people do that. Your view of the lake is gorgeous.

I would go with a charcoal roof. Pick paint, once the roof is done. This is not exactly what is called a MCM house. Its a fairly ordinary ranch house, and I wouldnt try to make it something its not. It is a very nice house. It has gorgeous brick. Once you get the new roof, then pick one of the lighter colors in that brick, for the sided part of the house. The roof color right now, and the paint color are all wrong together, but, it is possible that the paint color will look a lot better with the right color roof, so there isnt so much color clashing.

Is enlarging any of the windows in the plans? It's often not that difficult to make a window Longer if you keep the same width and lintel height. I am assuming that at least the far left window is a bedroom, and it would certainly make that bedroom safer if the window provided a means of egress. A front facing gable would have to have a shallow peak and be kind of broad to be in keeping with the pitch of the existing roof. As bland as the house may seem, the shape is distinctly contemporary ranch with that long shed roof over the garage, and that defines what the house is. I think it would be easier and better to make it a nice version of what it is. "Modern Farmhouse" is very vertical. That's not something that can happen here without completely rebuilding the house.