Return to the Pets Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
What's in dogfood that cause thirst?

Posted by ritaweeda (My Page) on
Wed, Nov 21, 12 at 7:42

We switched dog food (dry) to see if the dog would eat it and noticed that after she eats, she drinks a LOT of water. I looked to see if it had salt and it isn't listed. It's supposed to be one of the good ones but this has me concerned. We only bought a small bag to try it out, and we are going to switch back but I'm just curious. We have always fed her dry food so it's not like she's used to canned or fresh to cause this.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: What's in dogfood that cause thirst?

Dogs often gorge on new food. If she ate a lot more of the new food than she typically eats of the old food, that could easily account for her increased thirst. Kibble is dehydrating.


 o
RE: What's in dogfood that cause thirst?

We gave her the same amount as the previous one. When she eats she always wolfs it down quick. We have a problem with her eating well for a couple of weeks, then she starts to leave it untouched until the next day. After a couple of times a week of doing this I start to worry. Don't know if she gets tired of the food or is just quirky on her appetite. But when she does eat she eats with a healthy appetite. I suggested to DH that maybe we should add some canned food to make it more palatable but he doesn't want to start doing that.


 o
RE: What's in dogfood that cause thirst?

What kind of food was she eating and what kind did you switch to? Also, you do know whenever you switch dog foods you do this slowly mixing the old with the new, small amount of the new first and gradually adding more until you are at all new food. Switching cold turkey can cause stomach distress.....


 o
RE: What's in dogfood that cause thirst?

We switched from Taste of the Wild to 4Health. And no, we didn't know you should switch gradually.


 o
RE: What's in dogfood that cause thirst?

My dog eats the same way.....eats well for a while, then may eat nothing one day. He's healthy otherwise so I started giving him canned food on those off days. He loves it of course, so our feeding schedule now is about every 2 days he gets 1/2 can of food for one of his 2 daily feedings. My dog is only 22 lbs so the amount you feed will depend on your dog's size.


 o
RE: What's in dogfood that cause thirst?

If the new food is of significantly higher quality than the old one, the dog likely doesn't need as much of it, yet may need more water just to wash it down. Cheap food has so much filler in it so more is required to provide enough nutrients. I am surprised how little kibble it takes for my 45 pounder to maintain her weight - meal-for-meal it is likely no more expensive than the supermarket crap.


 o
RE: What's in dogfood that cause thirst?

I always just assumed that my dogs drank water after eating because the food is, after all, dry. Kind of like when I eat something that is dry, it makes me want to drink something.
But if the dog is gorging on water, I too would be concerned.


 o
RE: What's in dogfood that cause thirst?

I am not familiar with 4Health, actually have never heard of it. Where is it on the dogfood rating scale? We feed TOTW. How is your dog now, has the thirst decreased somewhat? It could just have been from the sudden switch in the foods since they should be switched gradually and not all at once. Or maybe just the indgredients in the new food made your dog thirsty. I would just keep an eye on her. I am thankful that all three of my girls are good eaters for the most part...


 o
RE: What's in dogfood that cause thirst?

Well she is back on TOTW, a different flavor, and she's eating it so far. But this usually happens then after a week or so she starts leaving it until the next day a couple times a week. I'm probably over-concerned about it. But the 4Health had a pretty high rating, 4 stars on petfoodtalk. We bought it at Tractor Supply. I won't give it to her again due to the excessive amount of water she always drank right after. Maybe nothing wrong with it but she doesn't do that with TOTW.


 o
RE: What's in dogfood that cause thirst?

Generally, when a dog is not accustomed to a single food, there is no need to do the gradual switch-over to a new brand. We have always switched back and forth every bag or two between several of the super-premium brands and never do any gradual switching. Our philosophy is just like for our own food - a variety of food decreases the likelihood of nutritional deficiencies. Different brands, different formulations also decrease the liklihood that any recall or food accident will have an adverse effect on our dogs because they are never on one particular food for long.


 o
RE: What's in dogfood that cause thirst?

I could not agree more with you, Nancy! Feeding a single brand and type of food was a marketting invention of the dogfood cos, but it is not healthy for pets or any animal. Back when I used to feed commercial petfoods I varied the brands from week to week, and fed a mixture of wet and dry. Since the petfood poisoning debacle of 2007 I have home cooked for my pets, using a variety of meats (except for Miss Picky Cat who will eat only chicken). What one meat or brand/type of commercial petfood lacks, another will likely have. Except for koala bears, no animal in the wild eats a steady diet of just one food. Variety is key to good nutrition, for humans and pets alike.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Pets Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here