Return to the Paint Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Have the Ben Moore guy mix 2 colors...possible?

Posted by Starling333 (My Page) on
Sun, Mar 18, 12 at 10:54

Hi All,
New to the forum. I've lurked a bit & find everyone very helpful :-).
I'm having a luxury problem & need some advice - I absolutely love Hot Spring Stones from BM. However, it shows up pretty dark in my bedroom. (the walls are currently white). I tried Cedar Key as well and it looks too modern/cool, but I like that one too.
Has anyone ever had two colors mixed? Is it crazy? Will they guy even do it?
I would appreciate any input.

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Have the Ben Moore guy mix 2 colors...possible?

Just get a couple sample sizes or quarts and mix it up yourself so you can have a look. Just make sure it's a 50/50 ratio. 50/50 because it's easiest to duplicate in a large enough quantity to paint the whole room and have some leftoever for touch ups.

If you find a different ratio is what it takes to get the color you want, then it's easier to paint up a sample, let it dry thoroughly and then have the tinter make you a custom formula to match your sample.

The tinter at the store may or may not want to get involved with your color designing escpades. Bottomline is you'll be buying whatever paint is used so might as well start small with samples/quarts on your own.

RE: Have the Ben Moore guy mix 2 colors...possible?

As a tinter in an upscale Paint/Hdwr. store, I think Fun-C hit it on the head!

Sure, we love to help with colors, a point...
* When people start requesting BLENDING though, that's a different animal.
* Some responsibility tends to fall on the STORE (in a customers' eyes), where none should exist. It's the CUSTOMERS' choice to alter colors in these cases.
* Yes, keep track of your ratios. Use dixie cups, or other small/cheap mixing container.
* Brush each "ratio" out on FOAMBOARD squares, maybe 1'x1'. Let them dry a day or so, then move them to different wall areas, check @ different times of day, etc.
* Do TWO average coats though! You want a "real life" coat thickness/appearance.
* When you're set on "THE Mix/color", buy a gallon of each, and blend each color, using scaled-up mixing containers.
* It may be as goofy as..."1 butter-dish of X, to 2 butter-dishes of Y"!
* Store the excess mixed paint into GLASS canning jars, leaving as little airspace as possible in each.
* Keep track of the colors/mix-ratio in a "Home-paints" folder! Get a 2nd formula print-out from your store too. I'd even save the whole label from the can!


RE: Have the Ben Moore guy mix 2 colors...possible?

Thank you both for your replies. Your suggestions make a lot of sense. I guess my main concern then would be mixing the colors well enough. I'm not confident that the standard wooden paint stick & some elbow grease would do the trick. I'm off now to google the best way to mix your own paint.....
Thanks again!

RE: Have the Ben Moore guy mix 2 colors...possible?

Great info and insight from Faron - as usual. :)

Starling, the key when mixing your own color is to keep the quantity small.

You don't have to mix - and stir up - whole entire gallons.

Just a few ounces. For the 50/50 mixes, just a 1/2 cup of each color is enough. You end up with 1 cup to paint out samples and take to the store for custom color matching.

Like Faron said, just keep track of the ratios.

I stir up small quantities like that with plastic knife or fork.

When you arrive at the color you want, it is helpful to take in the dried sample, of course, but also sharing with the colorist *how* you arrived at the color can help.

All that information they'll want to know because it will help them duplicte your color work in larger quantity.

RE: Have the Ben Moore guy mix 2 colors...possible?

I have mixed a little bit of another color into a gallon and not had a problem getting it evenly mixed. The bigger issue is getting the color you want. Starting with a couple of sample pots is a good way to play with how the colors mix as well as trying the pure colors on test boards -- or even a large area of wall so you can see if the color really looks too dark or too cool when you see less of the white.

RE: Have the Ben Moore guy mix 2 colors...possible?

Thank you everyone, for all of your suggestions and insight. (I'm actually a makeup artist so I'm always mixing & playing with colors).
I have a bunch of paint samples to play with. Jeez...those Sherwin Williams sample sizes are quite large!
Thanks again, much appreciated!

RE: Have the Ben Moore guy mix 2 colors...possible?

Sherwin Williams. When they say "Color to Go" they're serious.

RE: Have the Ben Moore guy mix 2 colors...possible?

If the people at the paint store can't help you here I'd find another place to buy your paint.
you can do a 50% of the formula. You can change the rec. tinting base. You can do so many things to adjust and do it simply. Just be prepared to buy a sample quart with each try and be very diligent about documenting what was done. Don't make it their responsibility to know the color and formula. Take ownership of YOUR color.

RE: Have the Ben Moore guy mix 2 colors...possible?

Doing 50% of a color only works in the 2 "Whiter" tintbases, if there's 4 bases.
In "3-base" paints, it usually only works in the White base, depending on the formula. If a color is heavy on Reds, Magentas, or Yellows, it doesn't work, unless you want a "glaze" appearance....


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Paint Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here