JOIN NOW LOG IN
iVillage GardenWeb iVillage GardenWeb THE INTERNET'S GARDEN & HOME COMMUNITY ADVERTISEMENT
Blogs Forums Photo Galleries Ask The Experts Tools & Directories        
Return to the Old House Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
House in It's a Wonderful Life

Posted by bama320sycamore (My Page) on
Fri, Dec 29, 06 at 12:37

As you can probably tell from my username, I'm a fan of It's a Wonderful Life. I've always wondered what style of house 320 Sycamore in the movie is meant to be. My best guess so far is an Italianate Villa with some Victorian elements. Best picture I have handy is linked.

Personally I love turrets (they remind me of lighthouses), but I've seen them primarily on small-footprint tall massings like typical Queen Anne houses. This house is different in that it has a larger rectangular shape. Looking closely at stills from the DVD it appears the house is brick as well, which is different from the typical Victorian shingles or clapboard.

Here is a link that might be useful: Bailey House


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: House in It's a Wonderful Life

I guess you could call it a turrented Italianate Villa.
19th c builders mixed and matched styling elements, especially later in the century. For every pure example of a house built in style X Y or Z, you'll find many more houses that are mixtures of x and y or x and z or y and z or even xyz and a.
Whether or not a house was built in brick, stone, clapboards or shingles also depended on the region where it was built. There are some places where most of the Victorian residences are brick or stone and wooden ones are not the norm.
This house was designed and built for a movie. The designer needed to convey the feeling of the dreary, creepy looking house everyone but Mary saw. For this reason the house was designed as a large heavy block, with the big tower that sort of stands guard, and the rows of blank, staring windows.
Personally, I always loved the little house on Green Acres. My son was watching the show this afternoon and everytime I see it I just want to possess that house. It would be such a perfect jewelbox of a house. Whoever designed it or picked the plans for it really had to love Victorians.


 o
RE: House in It's a Wonderful Life

I'm not at all sure that I would call that house Italianate style. The Mansard roof is a give away. To my way of thinking, that's Second Empire style.

Here's a line drawing of a Second Empire house with similar massing...

Italianate was more of a high Gothic style from the middle of the Victorian age.

Homes of either style would have been VERY out of style in the 1920s when George met Mary.

Brick is also VERY Victorian and also very characteristic of the Queen Anne "superstyle."

This is a picture of my parent's house (Dad grew up here, Mom and Dad bought it from Grandma and Grandpa's estate several years ago). No, that's not me out front, either. :-)

Image Hosting by PictureTrail.com

The massing on the front of the house isn't quite a traditional turret, it's more of an Orel, I suppose, but the house, built in 1903, is a good example of the late, less stylistically complex, Queen Anne.

This house is one I almost bought a number of years ago. It's a B&B below Pittsburgh. It's a rare member of the private home Richardson Romanesque wing of the Queen Anne style. Romanesque Revival was very popular in western Pennsylvania.

When I was considering purchasing it I e-mailed a professor of architecture whose website I found. It discussed a lot of different American architectural styles, and I wanted a better read on what I was looking at.

His first line in his reply e-mail was "MY GOD what a lovely house!" :-)

Unfortunately, several hours later I found out that I had missed buying it.

Anyway, it has a more distinct turret on it.


 o
RE: House in It's a Wonderful Life

I'm thinking Mansard also.
PS: I have a "It's a Wonderful Life" themed kitchen....


 o
RE: House in It's a Wonderful Life

I wasn't thinking....too interested in figuring out how to load songs into my new Ipod nano, I guess (which I have successfully completed, oh goodie,goodie)
Italianates and Second Empires are related. The mansard roof was very modern and cutting edge back when it was introduced. Other features of those houses can go back and forth. You can take an Italianate, change the roof and turn it into a second Empire and vice versa very easily.

I guess the mansard roof just wasn't registering in my brain at the time.


 o
RE: House in It's a Wonderful Life

Here's a great piece on the film from the LA Times

Here is a link that might be useful: Story on It's A Wonderful Life


 o
RE: House in It's a Wonderful Life

A couple of little errors in the article...

Jimmy Stewart wasn't a fighter pilot -- he piloted B-24 bombers in combat and was decorated for heroism.

The movie also took some heat after its release because some saw its portrayal of Mr. Potter, the American entrepeneur and industrialist who only wanted to grow America, as anti-American.


 
 

 

 


Click here to learn more about in-text links on this page.



iVillage GardenWeb: The Internet's Garden & Home Community  
  iVillage Home & Garden Network