Return to the Old House Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
What to do with old wood floor?

Posted by sweetearth23 (My Page) on
Mon, Sep 19, 11 at 20:09

We have an 1860's farmhouse, with original wide plank floors (don't know what kind of wood). One area, which will become an entry/study and guest bathroom, has a painted floor of ancient vintage. Ideally, I would love to finish the floors with Tung oil, but sanding them down enough to get the paint off completely would, I'm afraid, make them "too even"- and they would lose their worn edges and primitive character. However, some of the boards need to be replaced, and so I'm wondering whether I should just repaint the floor, which would be easier and cheaper, although my heart's not in it. If so, can I use a non-glossy paint? Or how could they be sanded without losing what makes them special?
What would you do?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: What to do with old wood floor?

I'd probably go for a liquid or gel type paint remover to get rid of the paint and then take it from there.


 o
RE: What to do with old wood floor?

I tried a soy paint remover with little success. It didn't work very well and took forever, and a floor guy who looked at it said sanding was the only way. I'm willing to brush up on my paint removing skills and give it another shot, though. Any recommendations for remover?


 o
RE: What to do with old wood floor?

I'd go for the real paint removers, not these non-odorous/no strength modern trends. Do it at a time when you can open all the windows for ventilation. If the paint is milk based, it will still be difficult, but it will do better with the meth-type strippers.


 o
RE: What to do with old wood floor?

be careful to choose a paint remover that won't raise the grain too much. removing the paint will be time consuming but it is doable. i have seen videos of people using peel-away on the ENTIRE EXTERIOR of their house. so at least you aren't doing that.


 o
RE: What to do with old wood floor?

Use a real & nasty stripper like Strypeeze follow up with the liquid version, Kutzit, to clean the leavings, and report back if you have enough brain cells to type.
Wear a respirator for high-VOC work while using, and open windows. Seal off room from the rest of the house.
Casey


 o
RE: What to do with old wood floor?

We had heart pine floors that had been treated badly & painted in our 1858 house. I knew the floor guy & he was instructed to sand as minimally as possible, NOT fill anything, & repair/replace only large pieces that absolutely needed it; I would do the oil finish.

We have lots of small chunks missing, splintered edges, wide cracks, burn marks in front of the fireplaces, deep stains, 10,000 tiny nails that were impossible to remove & too destructive to countersink, etc - & yet we have great looking floors (of course, I'm prejudiced, lol).
Photobucket
I tried using paint remover & a small belt sander in an unused area & barely put a dent in the paint - the wood was just too rough & absorbent when it was painted.


 o
RE: What to do with old wood floor?

I feel like I'm losing brain cells through the normal channels, so speeding up the process makes me nervous! But I guess it's worth giving paint removers another shot in one of the corners...
antiquesilver - your floor is spectacular! That's what I was hoping for, but the floor guy warned me that sanding it enough to get the paint off will sand off the character and history. I'd love to keep the dings and imperfections (not sure about nails vs. sander, though!), so that's the dilemma.
Thank you, everyone.


 o
RE: What to do with old wood floor?

Find a floor guy who has lots of experience with old houses & knows that a high gloss gym floor is NOT what you're after. It doesn't need to be sanded down to the point that it looks like newly milled, unmarred lumber with perfect edges.

Count on surprises, too. My guy had originally planned on a weekend to sand 2 rooms & a short hall but after making the first pass, it was discovered that there was some cupping that had been leveled & hidden by the paint & heavier sanding would be necessary. He wound up by putting about 40 hours in it instead of 2 days. The wood was sanded to the point that oil/stain/finish would penetrate & the floor would be smooth - but not oversanded.

The small nails that I referred to are the thousands of almost invisible headless ones that attached carpets or linoleum over the years & invariably leave the outline. Removing them is virtually impossible (without leaving a trail of destruction far more damaging than the 'outline') & countersinking them would leave a hole larger (& more obvious) than the nail; they don't shred the sandpaper of a commercial sander.


 o
RE: What to do with old wood floor?

Has anyone tried using a cabinet scraper on a floor? I guess the nails would make short work of the sharp edge, but if you don't have too many protruding nails it might work.

If the paint is thick, stripping with a heat gun or infrared (Silent Paint Remover) might work. A picture might enable more detailed advice.

Karin L


 o
RE: What to do with old wood floor?

A cabinet scraper's no good for stripping paint; you would spend too much time resharpening the delicate edge.
But a 1 1/2" wide paint scraper's just the thing, if you slightly round off the blade so there are no corners to dig in. I have scraped many floors in my time, and it's an intense upper-body workout. Keep the scraper sharp with the file, maybe every 8 pulls when scraping paint; varnish you'll get 12 pulls before dull.
Take all prudent lead paint precautions when scraping.
Casey


 o
RE: What to do with old wood floor?

A pint scraper is like a cabinet scraper on steroids.

It does not use the delicate burr of a cabinet scraper, but brute force (weight pushing the edge down and muscle pulling it across the surface.

The old models had a ball on top to push down on (and clamp the angle of the handle to the blade) and a handle to pull with.

As soon as electric drum sanders cam into use the scraper was reserved for the corners that the drum sander and rotary edging sander could not reach.


 o
RE: What to do with old wood floor?

I'm not sure how much of a difference it makes in approach, but I don't see multiple layers of paint; it looks more like it had soaked in to unfinished wood.
This may take a while, but I'll post my results when I have some. I really appreciate all the suggestions!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Old House Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here