Return to the Old House Forum | Post a Follow-Up

advice for getting estimates?

Posted by blackcats13 (My Page) on
Fri, Aug 22, 08 at 0:27

Not sure if I should post this here or in maybe remodeling (or both?), but I post here most often, so I'll start here. We are going to start getting quotes for fixing roof and siding. We will need done:

1. very soon, replace bottom 2 courses of rotting siding (can't afford to do whole house yet)
2. very soon, side around 2nd story window PO put in and never sided, looks like larger window was replaced with smaller for some reason (years ago according to neighbors, it "seems" to be well protected, hopefully). Or maybe put original sized window in instead.
3. within 1 or 2 max years, new tear off roof w/radiant barrier, possibly some flashing (spelling?) done in the meantime
4. NEEDS to be done but will have to wait a little bit, eventually replace all siding (insulated)

Our house was built in the 1920's. I've never done this before, what kind of things do I need to ask and watch out for when getting this info?

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: advice for getting estimates?

Get in at least 3 contractors, general or specialized to the particular 'fix', and see what they say about how they'll approach each job, how long it'll all take, how much they'll charge (and how much they'll want upfront - if anything - for materials), and whether they have references you can call. Make your decision on various factors, not necessarily just the lowest price.

RE: advice for getting estimates?

I would also ask what their clean-up/removal procedure is. Make certain that your agreement includes them hauling away old materials and thoroughly cleaning your property of all debris and work materials. Make sure that any fees you'll be charged for disposal are disclosed up front.


RE: advice for getting estimates?

Join Angies List. It's worth the money.

RE: advice for getting estimates?

I'd tackle this as siding and windows this year and then the other projects in the future. I doubt you'll get firm prices for the roof now - most estimates are good for only a fairly short period.

Replacing the bottom 2 rows of siding - assuming you have real wood, replace with cedar. It's the longest lasting. If you have Hardie Planking or another composite, stay with it, but make sure the contractor is a Hardie installer. Do you need siding around that 2nd story window if you stay with the existing window? If so, same thoughts.

However, do you want to go back to the larger size window? Do you want the new window to match other existing windows? If you go with a larger, you're going to need to know if a large enough header is still in the wall, but that won't become clear until the wall is opened for the window. Depending on what you decide, ask if the contractor is a certified installer for that type of window - Marvin's warranty gets questionable if a non-Marvin installer does the work. Price the windows on your own so that you'll have an idea of markup when quotes come in.

Do you have landscaping around your house that will be impacted by this work? You're going to need to consider that. Unless you move plantings, they're going to get damaged or killed. Or could you have the work done say in March, before things start growing?

I agree with the disposal questions. I agree with joining Angie's List to get referrals of contractors. I agree with talking to at least 3, but preferably 5.

RE: advice for getting estimates?

March is exACTly when plants are about to 'pop' - late fall or winter is the time to move conifers, and deciduous plants should be moved in March, but before work starts.

RE: advice for getting estimates?

Everything is still underground in my neighborhood in March. My point is - choose a time depending on your climate. Move plants when appropriate, too.

RE: advice for getting estimates?

Thanks everyone for the great advice! I am going to make a checksheet that contains all these questions and considerations. We actually joined Angie's list a couple months after we started looking for a house, when we realized that EVERY house we looked at needed at least 1 major fix. I think we have 4 or 5 people picked out, 2 have been called so far.

DH says old larger window is nowhere to be found, so I think for money reasons we'll have to stick with the little window and side in around it and the bottom of the house for this year. I'm interested to get the roofing price anyway, just so I can start to get a feel for how much a roof costs! It's extremely common here (maybe everywhere?) for 1 company to do both roof and siding and maybe windows too, so I figure they may as well give me a quote while they are there. Maybe I'll just throw it on the credit card to have it done and not do anything else for awhile ;) It's really the most important thing anyway.

We can't really match the windows. Most of them are original double hung wood w/out dividers in decent shape, except front living room window and the upstairs windows are vinyl or something. Eventually I'd like them all to be wood, but that is far in the future.

No, not real wood siding. To me it looks like cheap junk composite, but according to neighbors when it was put on (20 years ago???) it was top of the line. DH is most interested in getting the most durable composite available.

I hate the little landscaping that is there, so no worries on that count!

RE: advice for getting estimates?

One little tip that I have used......... when I had a roof estimate done, I talked to my insurance man and asked him who he recommended. And then I called the wholesale roofing supplier --spoke to a secretary and asked who she would use.

First of all, the secretary knows who pays their bills, who has fewest complaints, who does the most work from referrals. They also will talk to you where the salesmen might just hand you some names.

It worked great for me and I have since done with great success with floor covering installers.


RE: advice for getting estimates?

Oh! Neat advice, thanks!!

RE: advice for getting estimates?

This might sound silly, but I found it really helped to be courteous and NICE to contractors... a smile goes a long way at that initial meeting. Most of them want to do a good job and make you happy.

Also, type up a list of project details and give it to each contractor you meet with. For example, if you want them to remove all debris, say "remove all debris." That way, you can be sure the bids you're comparing are for the same work. Contractors aren't always great at taking notes (they've got other stuff on their minds), and are usually happy to get a written list of your expectations.

And if (for example) the first contractor you talk to says a beam is rotten and needs replacing, don't hesitate to ask the second contractor for his opinion on the beam. He/she might have a different solution.

Every estimate you get will teach you something. You can get an excellent education by talking to experienced contractors.

Best of luck with your projects!

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Old House Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here