Return to the Old House Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Bouncing 2nd Lvl Floors

Posted by ellie256 (My Page) on
Wed, Jul 22, 09 at 11:59

We bought a remodel 16 years ago. The front 1/2 is over 100 years old with new dry wall, electric etc. The back 1/2 was new construction.

We have recently painted 2 upstairs bedrooms and pulled the carpet. One of the rooms in the older part of the house has a bounce in floor - not bad enough to crack the ceiling downstairs but the light fixture shake a little. The floor has tongue and groove wood flooring that is probably original to the house and no sub-floor.

How do we firm up the floor and make it more stable before replacing the carpet?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Bouncing 2nd Lvl Floors

The floor or ceiling gets torn out to strengthen the joists by sistering and/or cross strapping.

A functional steel beam covered in wood to appear as a larger wood beam could also be used in the room below.

Adding flat layers of plywood will have minimal affect, adding 1x lumber perpendicular to the joists is marginally better.

Living with it if it is not a structural issue is the most common solution for older houses built before stringent building codes.


 o
RE: Bouncing 2nd Lvl Floors

Okay, since the floor is exposed, then the least intrusive would be to remove the tongue and groove and sister the joists.

When sistering joists - I think of make-shifting a joist hanger and running the new joist next to the old joist - the entire length. This is connected to the old joist by construction adhesive and screws. Is this the correct way to do this?


 o
RE: Bouncing 2nd Lvl Floors

"...connected to the old joist by construction adhesive and screws."

16d nails are fine.
Use a nail gun to avoid damage from repeated hammering to drive the new nails.
Very old lumber can be VERY hard.

Construction adhesive has no structural value. There is no reliable data and application methods defined.

Very few screws have any structural ratings either.
Bolts at least have a defined rating, but going over 3/8 inch diameter and using fewer fasteners often exceeds the crush strength of wood (especially the new wood).

Fasteners also need to be correctly distributed to make the pieces of wood behave as a single unit.


 o
RE: Bouncing 2nd Lvl Floors

"Fasteners also need to be correctly distributed to make the pieces of wood behave as a single unit."

Now I'm concerned. How do we make sure that this is correctly distributed?

We will use 16d. Haven't uncovered the tongue and groove yet so really don't know the joist specifics. The room is 11'1" wide. I am guessing the joist is 8".


 o
RE: Bouncing 2nd Lvl Floors

The nailing pattern typically uses two lines of nails down the length of the joist about 1/4 of the width in from the top and bottom (larger members might go for 1/3).

Each alternate nail in each row is then staggered up about 1 inch to avoid creating to close a line (causes 'zipper' failure along the row of nails).

The separation is about the joist height, with nails then added about the middle of the joist vertically and horizontally between the other nails.

It does take a pretty significant number of nails to make the members act as one, more than a straight loading calculation requires.

The likely lack of any grading on the old wood can be an issue for some AHJs, while others are willing to assume a low grade and go from there.

You are likely to find full dimension wood (often right off the sawmill blade), and possibly larger sections than are commonly used now. You may even find wood that still has round features left from the tree.


 o
RE: Bouncing 2nd Lvl Floors

3 nails every 16 inches, no less than one inch from the top or bottom. Use a clamp as necessary to hold the members tight where nailing. If nail shank is not in wood between the new and old, it may allow the members to move separately.
Casey


 o
RE: Bouncing 2nd Lvl Floors

"3 nails every 16 inches, no less than one inch from the top or bottom."

That is a new work spec, not a retrofit spec.


 o
RE: Bouncing 2nd Lvl Floors

Well the joists are 2" x 6" - 12" center. They are 11'4" long. I thought we would find at least 8" joists.

The good news . . . the builders that placed the drywall in this portion of the house did put in insulation so we do not have to blow in insulation.


 o
RE: Bouncing 2nd Lvl Floors

I was incorrect . . those are 16" centers. So 2" x 6" 16" centers w/ electric running through them in 2 places.

How do you sister joists when there are 6 electric wires running through them? 4 in one hole and about 3 foot away 2 more wires through another hole.


 o
RE: Bouncing 2nd Lvl Floors

Hey Ellie,

I've been reading your thread with interest, as we've got an under-joisted attic (1x6 on 16", if memory serves). Obviously much worse than yours, to the point that we're afraid to go up there.

So, I forwarded your thread to my husband, and got an interesting response from him:

Yesterday, I finally read the equation for deflection (was related to something at work)
I knew it was some power of the height, but here it is:

deflection = force * span^3 / (width * height^3 * elasticmodulus)

So the difference between 2x8 and 2x6 is a factor of 2.4 wow!

And I didn't realize that the span was cubed, learn something every day.


 o
RE: Bouncing 2nd Lvl Floors

"So the difference between 2x8 and 2x6 is a factor of 2.4 wow!"

Actually about 2.3

You have to use the net dimensions of the lumber, not the nominal.

2x8 is 7.25 wide, while a 2x6 is 5.5 wide.

2x lumber is 1.5 in thick, and 1/2 inch under for 6 in or less in width, but 3/4 in under at 8 inches and over.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Old House Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here