Just wanted to add a picture of the trim. It is important to us to try to remodel the home in keeping with the original time period.

Hard to tell ... Could be anywhere from 1880s through 1940s.

The trim is a style that was popular for decades, sort of a modest Victorian influence on a basically plain functional trim (sometimes called "farmhouse Victorian).

The roof shape was a common way of building small house roofs for a long time.

Pick an era you like between about 1880 and 1930 and you can't be called wrong.

What is the floor plan like? The "workman cottage" and the basic bungalow were extremely popular between about 1900 and 1930

I think that is a Cape Cod style. Cool house!

Hip-roofed one story cottage with inset porch.
The trim is classical revival. Noting the egg & dart pressed molding. It's yellow pine, at that time called Georgia pine, because that was where it was being harvested.My house, remodeled in 1907 has the same wood, but a different style of molding, understandably. Don't paint it! it's great. I have spent years stripping mine so it looks like yours!
Casey

lazygardens, Thank you for the advice. The original floor plan was two small bedrooms off a large common room. The kitchen and bathroom were added off the back of the house.