Return to the Old House Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Latex paint over oil base paint?

Posted by heypearly (My Page) on
Thu, May 3, 07 at 9:13

I admit to being an "old timer" so my gut says you can't put water based paint over oil. Every paint store I've gone to for advice as to "HOW?" just gets me a different answer.

The oil paint is on all the trim in my 200+years old house. NY state is tough on VOC's and it's nearly impossible to buy oil paint any way.

Anyone able to advise me about how to proceed? Would a primer like BIN be enough to block the 10 year old oil paint? THANKS!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Latex paint over oil base paint?

The two don't mix either way... oil over latex or vice versa. You have to prime it first. I didn't and I put oil over latex on my concrete porch that was painted pink... let's just say it's now gray and pink speckled. =D I don't think the age of the old paint is anything to worry about... just make sure you scrape up any that is chipping and get a good primer.


 o
RE: Latex paint over oil base paint?

A light sanding and any good bonding primer will do the trick,there are many out there,Ben Moore Fresh Start is a good one,but all paint stores sell them.


 o
RE: Latex paint over oil base paint?

Latex goes over oil just fine.
The problem is in getting good surface adhesion sine oil (especially older stuff) is often very smooth.
Light sanding or washing with TSP (the real stuff, not the substitute) will provide a good surface for a bonding type latex primer.

Oil over latex is often a problem.
Latex paint is more flexible than oil paint, and putting a hard film over a softer film can often cause cracking problems. At the very least the hard film properties of the oil paint are compromised.
You can make it stick, but if you already have latex it is better to stick with latex.

Some of the newer acrylic paints work as well as oil (alkyd) used to, and even have full gloss formulations now.
They often need a little Floetrol to level out nicely though.


 o
RE: Latex paint over oil base paint?

I get a kick out of all the different answers this question produces. Almost every answer on every website is different. Some say that you can't use oil paint over latex but the opposite is OK. Others say that you can't use latex over oil but he opposite is OK. Yet other say that they aren't compatible and neither are OK and yet others say that both combinations are fine. :-) My own experience tells me that oil based paints over latex work fine as long as the old paint surface is clean but that latex doesn't work well when painted directly over oil-based paints. (This is just the opposite of the advice given by another person here.) But I suspect that, with proper surface preparation and the use of the CORRECT primer, either paint can be used over the other. I would be particularly careful with preparation and priming when using water-based paints over oil paints. Whenever I have seen severe peeling and bubbling from the use of a combination of paints, it has been latex over oil. As oil-based paints get restricted and are less available, it will be more difficult to find oil paints in the future.

TSP is an outstanding product for cleaning surfaces before painting. It removes all oil, etc., and it even etches the surface if it is mixed strong enough.


 o
RE: Latex paint over oil base paint?

Hi,
I am a N.Y painting contractor. Now days a lot of waterbourne paints are equal to or better than oils. We usually use 100% acrylics. Acrylics are waterbourne, retain color better, have better elasticity, mildew resistant and other great charecteristics. You can use waterbourne over oil, but you should never use oil over waterbourne. First clean your substrate well, using tsp and a pressure washer, then sand and scrape as needed,caulk, prime with a 100% acrylic, then top coat. Most of the time we use Sherwin Williams products, we warranty all of our work, but will only do so when using Sherwin Williams products, they have a great line of acrylic primers and acrylic paint for your top coat. Visit us on the web www.kelloggspainting.com to learn more about acrylics.

-Kellogg's House Painting N.Y

Here is a link that might be useful: interior-exterior house painting contractor ny


 o
RE: Latex paint over oil base paint?

prime with a 100% acrylic,
Just be sure it is a bonding primer made for glossy surfaces, not all 100% acrlic primers are labeled this way.


 o
RE: Latex paint over oil base paint?

We are using SW Duration Exterior paint on our 1920s home. Three fancy porch columns where I scraped, I didn't get all the old oil based paint off(dh won't let me scrape anymore which is fine with me lol.) SW Duration doesn't require a primer even on bare wood. We've been painting the house trim (four porches!) for a number of years now and the single coat over oil based that I did 4 years ago on those columns is still in fine condition. I'm sure there are also places where dh didn't get every speck of the old oil based paint off and everything that we have done is good. The single coat done last year on new wood where we are repairing our porches is beautiful. (20 below zero winter and hot summer and lots of crazy variation in temps this year). The wood that comes primed looks fine too, but the paint actually didn't go on as easily.
The house has aluminum siding and dh is repairing trim with and an epoxy in many places, and the paint over both these substances looks very good too.
I love this paint. It is a pleasure to paint with. It is very expensive however. We bought 5 gal buckets when it went on sale.
good luck! Post a pic when you are done! I will too but it will be in 2012, I estimate.
kathy
ps there is only one coat on those 3 columns because dh wants to go back and fix them when everything else is done (that is scrape them again to get the patches of old paint that I didn't get.)
pss carefully collecting the paint chips on drop cloths is a bummer, but you just know when its that old its got lead in it - so wear a mask when scraping too!


 o
I want my paint to crackle

If I paint latex on oil or oil on latex, will it crack and peel just a little, or would it be a lot? I'm thinking I'll put fine sand into my second coat so I'll be able to sand it off, and the sandy parts will sand off easily, leaving my first coat color exposed so it'll look old - like the old paint underneath will show up. Will this work?


 o
I want my paint to crack and peel for effect.

If I paint latex on oil or oil on latex, will it crack and peel just a little, or would it be a lot? I'm thinking I'll put fine sand into my second coat so I'll be able to sand it off, and the sandy parts will sand off easily, leaving my first coat color exposed so it'll look old - like the old paint underneath will show up. Will this work? If not, what will create this effect on old furniture?


 o
RE: Latex paint over oil base paint?

"If I paint latex on oil or oil on latex, will it crack and peel just a little, or would it be a lot?"

A LOT

Don't skimp on the prep work, I'm dealing with the previous owners latex paint over oil.. I have to strip it all, as I can't even sand it.. it peels.. LIKE RUBBER.

You first need to figure out what the base coat is, sand it clan it, and use a BONDING ADHESIVE PRIMER. Once that is done, you can use either oil or latex (make your choice!)


 o
peeling paint

lovely peeling latex paint.... ugh.
From Sunrise - work in progress


 o
RE: Latex paint over oil base paint?

"lovely peeling latex paint"

Bad prep work.

Latex cab go over oil but you need very good prep work.

A bonding primer can help, but only if the oil paint is CLEAN.

TSP or spic-and-span clean.

Oil over latex is a really bad idea.

The oil film is much harder than a latex film, and it WILL crack and crackle.

They way you obtain a crackle finish is by putting a harder finish over a softer one.

It really matters what order the paints are applied.

Luckily latex, (even acrylic) paints are softer than alkyd (oil) paints once cured.


 o
RE: Latex paint over oil base paint?

Prime it with zinnser oil base primer. Fill nail holes, sand, clean, then paint with any latex paint.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Old House Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here