Return to the Old House Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Horse hair plaster cracks

Posted by bknouse (My Page) on
Sun, Feb 19, 06 at 0:29

Help! We are moving into an old farm house that has cracked horse hair plaster walls in the living room. What's the best way to patch these cracks? Upstairs the walls have been drywalled over, but I don't want to do that downstairs so any suggestions? I'm a beginner so take it slow on the instructions. Thanks!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

The fiorst thing to do is find out if the cracks move with the weather and seasons. If they do the repair methods are limited.
If the cracks do not move, they can be filled with setting type drywall compound like Easysand. Mix it about as thick as peanut butter and force it into the cracks using a 5 or 6 inch drywall knife.


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

The cracks don't move and they aren't very wide. Someone told me to use some type of mesh tape? and do the cracks like you would drywall tape between dry wall sheets. But as I've said I know nothing. Just patching the cracks sounds easier then dealing with tape and mudding over it. Thanks for the info.


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

Try just mudding first.
Mesh tape and setting compound works well for wider cracks, but anything less than 1/4 inch will usually close up fine.
Do not bother trying regular joint compound. It shrinks and makes a mess of plaster walls.
So called 'patching plaster' is also not good for much of anything. It dies not have sufficient lime and retarders added to work very well.
Easysand90 is a setting type compound ( a modern version of plaster and lime) that set in about 90 minutes. If mixed thick it will have minimal shrinkage.


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

Thanks, I'm heading to HD tomorrow so I will get some Easysand90 and give it a try.


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

I've also heard but never tried to "v" out the crack with a sharp pointed object such as an old style can opener.Lightly scoring over the crack and removing any loose debris before filling. Brickeye-good idea/bad idea? Have you ever heard of this?


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

If you V a crack it is wider at the bottom than at the top. It is an attempt to make a key that will hold a patch.
It is really not required with Easysand or Durabond. They stick just fine to the old surface.


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

Thanks!


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

At HD they had no idea what Easysand was, so any idea where I get this stuff? Or is this Durabond stuff as good or more easily available? Thanks.


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

Go to your local paint store,Duron,Ben Moore,Sherwin Williams,etc.


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

HD usually has Easysand. It is in the aisle with the drywall joint compound in buckets.
Durabond is actually a beter material, but it is so hard it cannot be sanded. I would not recomend it for someone without a lot of experience.
Most paint stores also carry Easysand.
Get the Easysand90.


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

Your best bet is to remove the plaster and put up drywall


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

wlg2_2, I think you've just uttered the dirtiest words in the "old house" language... :)


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

I think brickeye would agree that even severely damaged plaster can be repaired....we're talking about minor cracking here. To suggest drywall ,ruining the integrity and originality of the plaster, is like suggesting an earl schieb paint job on a rolls royce!


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

Thanks for the info. I will check out the paint store. Replacing them is not an option, first of all I can't afford it, second the damage is SO minimal. My sister has bigger cracks in her dry wall then I have in my plaster.


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

There is almost never a good reason to remove paster unless it is truly falling down under its own weight.
To replace a 2 coat plaster wall is not cheap.
Veneer plaster has hardly bettter sound qualities than drywall.
I cannot tell you how many times I have been called after plaster came down, drywall went up and the owner wants to know why the house is so noisy.


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

There was a great coverage by Tom on how to repair holes in plaster walls on Ask this Old House this past weekend. The hole was patched with two layers of drywall (to make up the thickness of the total plaster), then veneer plaster spread over drywall and finished smooth.

I was interested in the whole thing as I am busting holes to gain access to knee wall crawl spaces and will have to patch those, but I was particularly interested in the finishing technique as I also have many hairline cracks in the plaster which I want to skim coat over with veneer plaster.

I don't know if the website for ATOH has details of the features of each episode.

Ted


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

I have horse hair plaster that is finished with an "orange peal" texture. I need to make repairs and want to know how to recreate the "orange peal" texture?????


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

I haven't used Easysand or Durabond, but I've repaired cracks by using a tool to V out the crack and then filling it with plaster and sanding flat when dry. I was very happy with the results.


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

"...filling it with plaster and sanding flat when dry."

Plaster should actually never be sanded to make it smooth.
Sanding roughs up the surface compared to a correctly troweled finish.


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

Since there seems to be good answers received on the intitial question, how about a variation of a plaster problem?

We have a 1858 wood framed farmhouse with plastered walls. In one wall there is an old brick chimney that goes up inside the wall (it is a thick wall in this location). The plaster on each side of this chimney is applied right over the brick.

We have a problem with the brick in the chimney wicking up moisture at its foundation from the dirt in the crawl space which is transfered to the plaster. This causes the plaster to soften and sluff off with bubbled paint over it.

I have previously scraped the bad plaster off coated the brick with Thompsons Water Seal and then filled in the area with joint compound sanded and repainted. The problem returns.

Would there be another product or technique that we should use?

Thank you for you responses.


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

Get the moisture out of the crawl space.
With good drainage it rarely wicks more than about 12 inches.


 o
RE: Horse hair plaster cracks

We've had excellent results using a simple mix of 50% joint compound and 50% plaster of paris repairing settling cracks in our 1870's home. We have painted horsehair plaster walls, and blend the patch in by using a tad of joint compund mixed with the paint to recreate the multiple layers of rolled paint texture. Oftentimes, the patch disappears. Never sand it, apply it in multiple layers if necessary. A depression is OK pending another coat, a ridge is forbidden.

Sounds bizarre, but its worked excellent for us.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Old House Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here