Return to the Lighting Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Closet lights - fluorescent, halogen or LED??

Posted by akrobin (My Page) on
Thu, Oct 23, 08 at 18:52

My husband and I are doing a major remodel of our new house and since he's away from home, I get the job of managing it all. It's been a great learning experience, but right now the lighting is making me crazy. I've got a couple of questions, but will break them down by topics.

I want to put lights inside our closets (96" x 24", with sliding doors)...attached to the header above the door, hardwired, with a switch outside the closet. Everything I see online is either battery operated or fluorescent. I'm not opposed to fluorescent, we have CFL's in all our lamps, but it doesn't seem like the best application for fluorescent lights. I want something that will be happy running for five to ten minutes at a time, a couple times a day.

Halogen lights seem like a good alternative. I like the idea of using a two or three bulb direction spotlight or short track light, so that I can aim the lights into different areas of the closet.

Has anyone done this or seen it done? Do you know if halogen lights fall under incandescent or fluorescent when it comes to code? And what does it mean when the say that an incandescant light must have a "closed lens"? The halogen light I am looking at does not protrude at all from the shade. Does that count?

Finally, does anyone have experience with LED lights in closets? Seen any that aren't battery operated?

If this wasn't challenging enough...check out my next question: Low Voltage Light Transformers - Magnetic or Electronic?

Thanks, in advance, for your help!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Closet lights - fluorescent, halogen or LED??

I use low voltage halogen for my closet.
The important thing is how well the light shows the true colors of your clothes.

Halogen is the best. It has a very high CRI (color rendering index). Fluorescent bulbs are notoriously bad with their CRI. LEDs generally are not good either. Now, the Cree recessed lights have great CRIs. Not as good as halogen, but still in the 90%+ range.

If you're thinking of a track, and the clothes won't be affected by the heat, go with low voltage halogen.

As for transformer. They're both technically good. Fixtures with integral individual transformers are usually electronic.
Both have positives and negatives. It sort of depends on what your light fixture is.

Sorry for the vagueness on the second question.


 o
RE: Closet lights - fluorescent, halogen or LED??

Thanks for that. Are halogens really so hot that they would affect my clothes?

My transformer question is actually a separate post, with more details on my dilemna...you know, in case you want to check that one out too. I could use all the help I can get.


 o
RE: Closet lights - fluorescent, halogen or LED??

Per NEC section 410.8(B), the only types of luminaires allowed in a closet are:

(1) A surface-mounted or recessed incandescent luminaire
(fixture) with a completely enclosed lamp
(2) A surface-mounted or recessed fluorescent luminaire
(fixture)

Also, per 410.8(D), there are the following restrictions on location:

(1) Surface-mounted incandescent luminaires (fixtures) installed
on the wall above the door or on the ceiling,
provided there is a minimum clearance of 300 mm
(12 in.) between the luminaire (fixture) and the nearest
point of a storage space
(2) Surface-mounted fluorescent luminaires (fixtures) installed
on the wall above the door or on the ceiling,
provided there is a minimum clearance of 150 mm
(6 in.) between the luminaire (fixture) and the nearest
point of a storage space
(3) Recessed incandescent luminaires (fixtures) with a
completely enclosed lamp installed in the wall or the
ceiling, provided there is a minimum clearance of
150 mm (6 in.) between the luminaire (fixture) and the
nearest point of a storage space
(4) Recessed fluorescent luminaires (fixtures) installed in
the wall or the ceiling, provided there is a minimum
clearance of 150 mm (6 in.) between the luminaire
(fixture) and the nearest point of a storage space

I note that "storage space" is defined in 410.8(A).

I doubt that track lighting is considered "surface-mounted luminaires." In any case, it is rare for a track fixture to be "fully-enclosed."


 o
RE: Closet lights - fluorescent, halogen or LED??

I have a similar closet where I have mounted 2 14W T5 fluorescent Juno fixtures. They turn on instantly (unlike all my other CFL) and provide plenty of light. The model Juno fixture is UFL22.

Here is a link that might be useful: Juno UFL22


 o
RE: Closet lights - fluorescent, halogen or LED??

Thanks for all the good info. It's not exactly the answer I was looking for, but there's no point in installing something that is not to code. The Juno lights look like they could work. It seems odd though that they all switch on/off from the fixture...I was hoping to wire it to a switch outside of the closet.


 o
RE: Closet lights - fluorescent, halogen or LED??

I have the Junos on a wall light switch and not on the switch on the light fixture. It was no problem.


 o
RE: Closet lights - fluorescent, halogen or LED??

We are going with CFL's in closets and laundry room. The rest of the house will be LED. I'd save money and go with CFL in areas you don't use very much.


 o
RE: Closet lights - fluorescent, halogen or LED??

we're doing exactly the same as sherwhy.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Lighting Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here