Return to the Lighting Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
What is wrong with undercabinet Fluorescents?

Posted by tallcane (My Page) on
Sun, Jun 17, 07 at 22:14

Why does it seem like most people go with xenon undercabinet lights? I would think todays fluorescents would make a great choice, especially since you can get a "warm" bulb. What am I missing?

I am about to select undercabinet lights and am trying to figure out what I should not go with fluorescents...


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: What is wrong with undercabinet Fluorescents?

halogen is being replaced with xenon

xenon is cooler than halogen, slightly warmer color temperature, longer life than halogen, dimmable with magnetic or electronic dimmers depending on power supply

fluorescent is cooler and won't warm up cabinet contents as much, longest life with up to 20,000 hours, energy efficient, but not possible or expensive to dim with some fixtures. With some fixtures there are different color temperatures available at high color rendering index.

fluorescent being a linear light source usually provides a more even light. Incandescents create bright spots that can often be seen in the reflections from polished surfaces. Some fixture manufacturers offer sand blasted glass lenses to help with this.

Hopefully others will add to this. There is a lot involved in making this choice.


 o
RE: What is wrong with undercabinet Fluorescents?

I don't think there's anything inherently "wrong" with them. They are, as dim4fun mentioned, difficult or impossible to dim, at least in the US. That's a problem for some people. They are also so diffuse and shadowless that the tend to flatten the appearance of textured surfaces, and often don't show off fancy counter and backsplash materials very nicely. Beyond that, a lot of people carry around prejudices and negative associations with fluorescents that are hard to overcome. Fluorescent technology has improved a great deal, but many people made up their minds long ago.


 o
RE: What is wrong with undercabinet Fluorescents?

due to California's Title 24 lighting requirements, there's no way I could have even considered halogen or xenon under-cabinet lights, so I have undercabinet fluorescent lighting (always have, but these are new). I like them a lot. They're Juno brand. I have no need to dim the fluorescents, they're either on becuase they're in use, or they're off.


 o
RE: What is wrong with undercabinet Fluorescents?

"Why would you want to dim these...?"

I'd want to because, in my little house, kitchen lights are the first lights I turn on in the morning. Turning the lights on full blast at 5:30 A.M. is equivalent to placing a bell over my head and whacking it with a sledge hammer. I only need a few footcandles, just enough so I can work the coffeemaker. Later in the day I might not care so much.


 o
RE: What is wrong with undercabinet Fluorescents?

We have put in new flourescent undercab lights and are very happy with them. We have three different sets on separate switches, so we just turn on the ones where we're doing something on the countertop that requires task lighting. Otherwise the ceiling lights (also flourescent) provide plenty of ambient lighting for general activities in the kitchen. There's one cabinet on the sink wall and the light under it stays on pretty much all the time, which gives us a good night light. We've never felt the need for dimmers.


 o
RE: What is wrong with undercabinet Fluorescents?

My undercabinet light over my sink stays on 24/7. It finally needed changing after 10 years. Can you believe that? It's amazing!!


 o
RE: What is wrong with undercabinet Fluorescents?

Thanks for this posting. It was exactly what I was wondering. If I'm not concerned about dimmability, it seems like Fluorescents would be the way to go -- with a Spectra bulb.

The lighting saleslady was recommending xenons...due to the all the colors in my house. (Yellow kitchen, brown granite, cream cabs) After reading on this forum about the heat, I'm not sure that any of the xenon advantages win me over for my needs. Plus they are double the cost.

If I'm missing something, someone please let me know. I have to decide quickly. I sent out questions to my lighting specialist about the possibilty of dimming the fluorescents and that I'd like to get lights that are nice enough that they don't hum. Other than that, I hope I've considered everything.


 o
RE: What is wrong with undercabinet Fluorescents?

I just went to look at lighting tonight. I was amazed at how different the new fluorescents are. I thought they looked great. It seems to me the perfect choice if dimming is not an issue. I saw LED too, but the light was too cold. Maybe its just the brand?


 o
RE: What is wrong with undercabinet Fluorescents?

The highest quality LED fixtures look pretty good. The lowest quality not so good. LED manufacturers are struggling with warm color temperature, high color rendering, high light output and low costs. You can't have it all.

One model of Alkco under cabinet fluorescent can be made with dimmable ballasts.

Look at Maxim and Color Kinetics under cabinet LED lighting. They have built in drivers dimmable with electronic low voltage dimmers. I recommend the warmer color for residential applications.


 o
RE: What is wrong with undercabinet Fluorescents?

I am also looking at fluorescents for undercabinet use. Found some linkable hardwire-in with a very low profile and T5 bulbs, but the mounting brackets push them down lower than I thought they'd be from looking at the profile. Hoping to avoid needing much of trim piece to hide them. I'm also disappointed in the amount of light they produce, although it may be adequate. Dh likes the price, but I'd rather pay a little more and get something very thin and brighter. Any suggestions?


 o
RE: What is wrong with undercabinet Fluorescents?

My undercabinet fluorescents were installed 15 years ago and still work fine but I'm not in love with them. They buzz annoyingly and I dont use them much. Are the new fluoroescent fixtures better? Is it the housing or the bulb that has improved so it doesn't hum?


 o
RE: What is wrong with undercabinet Fluorescents?

Both have improved. The ballast is probably your noise source.

Here is a link that might be useful: Juno under cabinet


 o
RE: What is wrong with undercabinet Fluorescents?

Oh, interesting. Thanks! We are looking to tile our backsplash early next year so perhaps that would be the time to switch to something improved and quiet! Do they still run off standard electrical wiring? I can't use anything that requires a transformer and generally, fluorescents aren't low voltage.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Lighting Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here