Return to the Lighting Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
When to use can lights?

Posted by Mom23Es (My Page) on
Tue, Jun 12, 12 at 13:42

We're building a new house. The builder and electrician have suggested a lighting plan for us to use, and I'm concerned about the number of recessed can lights. It's not that I'm against using them, but I'm not sure about having them in hallways and walk-in closets. I'm more used to the traditional flush mount lights. Is there a reason to choose one over the other?

I'd appreciate any advice. If someone could point me in the right direction to a "how to select lighting" article or discussion I would really apprectiate that too.

Thanks!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: When to use can lights?

Can lights are cheap and easy to wire. I don't like them, but I'm still installing them by the score, mostly kitchen and living room, and in a sloped ceiling in my workout room/den. I just don't have enough minutes in the day to select attractive surface mount lights for most rooms, and Title 24 limits what I can do in my California kitchen. I'm using LED in the kitchen, and probably in the LR and maybe in the den.

Flush mount lights will probably provide much better light to the sides. My master BR has his-and-hers can spotlights over the bed for reading, plus a central ceiling fixture plus lamps. For my walk-in closet (not huge, 6x8) and for my similar size pantry and for my 7x8 laundry, I am using a fixture with four 4ft fluorescent tubes -- I like to be able to see what I'm looking for. My hallways are a mix of surface mount and semi-recessed.


 o
RE: When to use can lights?

The first step would be to figure out how much light you'd like in each space.
The second step would be determining if there would be layers of light (multiple sets of light sources controlled separately) and options such as dimming, automation.
The third would be to determine the style of the fixtures that could supply the light.

There are reasons to choose recessed cans and others that rule them out.
Reasons for
1. Style.
2. Ceiling height.

Reasons ruling them out
1. Physical limitations above the ceiling - height, obstructions, ...
2. Style - swiss cheese ceiling.
3. Architectural style - vaulted/ curved ceilings, ceiling height > 10 ft.
4. Cost of installation.

In lower cost homes, there might not be any recessed cans or flush mount lights. Instead, only wall sockets are provided for torchieres or table lamps.


 o
RE: When to use can lights?

Detractors of recessed lighting always seem to throw in the "swiss cheese ceiling" comment, but properly done, recessed lighting has an elegant, balanced, geometric look, nothing at all like the random placement of different-size holes in swiss cheese.


 o
RE: When to use can lights?

Lee676, I agree.

In addition, traditional recessed cans have a limited cone of light since the bulb is encased inside a can. With LED lamps like the Cree CR/ LR series, Sylvania RT series, this is no longer true as the emitters are all forward facing and close to the surface.

Common approaches to lighting
The cheapest approach is to not provide any surface or flush mount points.

The next is to provide a mount point in the center of the room.

If a room is fairly large say 15' x 15', the centrally located surface mount fixture will probably not provide sufficient light for the room.

To remedy the situation (after the fact),
1. Floor and /or table lamps could be used.
2. Additional surface mounts/ pendants installed.
3. Wall sconces are added where they are deemed necessary.
4. Recessed cans added where they are deemed necessary. This results in a haphazard placement of holes in the ceiling.
5. T8 fluorescent lighting is used. The light distribution will improve since the light source is a long rectangular object. If a light box is used, the same limitations of a "bulb in a can" apply i.e. - the light spread will be constrained.
This is the cheapest and probably the least desirable due to over-illumination, lighting quality (- colors may not look correct) and the inherent slow start up of fluorescents.

The third approach would be to put in a number of recessed cans / fixtures to illuminate a space. This could be quite involved (under statement), but the results would be worth it.

Proper planning is required for lighting. It starts with figuring out the desired levels of illumination for each space.


 o
RE: When to use can lights?

Except for very small rooms, I usually avoid using a single flush mount fixture, as it will produce shadows if you move to the sides of the room.

The white integral trim baffles on my CR6's reflect alot of light, which throws a fair amount of illumination sideways. But at the cost of additional glare if you look up at the lights, compared to traditional PAR30 or PAR40 floodlamp bulbs inside a black step baffle or aluminized reflector. The latter are available in three dark colors for the Cree lamps (except the "CR4" but those are probably on the way too), but they negate the price advantage of not having to buy separate trims that you'd get if you stick with the included white trim.


 o
RE: When to use can lights?

Thank you all so much for the advice. Apparently my DH had informed the builder that we wanted lots of can lights. I guess that would explain the excessive use of them.

Lee676- what do you consider a "small" room. I'm unsure about our mudroom and laundry room. Laundry has a couple windows is about 10'x8.5' and the builder has a fluorescent light in there. I really hate fluorescent lights! The mudroom has no natural light and is about 9'x8'. There is just one ceiling light proposed in there now.

Also, how difficult is it to add sconces later? I feel like I want a pair in our music room, but I just can't picture where yet. I think I need to wait until after we move in and get the grand piano and other furniture in place first.

Thanks again everyone! :)


 o
RE: When to use can lights?

I would consider 8' x 6' a small room.

Putting in additional wire in the areas where the lights could be and the necessary space(s) for switch(es) would make it much simpler to install additional sconces after the grand piano and furniture is moved in.


 o
RE: When to use can lights?

There are fluorescent lamps available that give off light similar to an incandescent bulb (the link below is for 4' T8 tubes of the type used by newer lamp fixtures and can be easily swapped out; old fixtures designed for T12 tubes (1 1/2" thick rather than 1") will need the ballast replaced with a modern one designed for T8 bulbs). Alternative, if you want a cooler, natural daylight look, go with a 5000K daylight bulb with good color rendering.

10' x 10' probably the largest room I'd consider lighting witha single fixture. A common fluorescent lamp that uses the 4' tubes disperses light well because its large size

Sconces can be added later as long as you can fish a wire to the location - easy if there's a basement below or an attic above, and still not too hard if there isn't and armored cable can be pulled through using a fished tape reel.

Here is a link that might be useful: Osram/Sylvania 2700K T8 fluorescent tube


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Lighting Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here