Return to the Lighting Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Please tell me how to light mudroom lockers

Posted by OntarioMom (My Page) on
Sun, Apr 14, 13 at 15:24

Hi all,

We will have a mudroom entrance off of our garage which is basement level. The ceilings is this area are 8 feet. The room does not have any windows although some natural light can be seen from foyer entrance up half a storey and the nearby bath when door is open. We currently have four 4inch pot lights roughed in as shown on plan (walls are still wide open). The salesperson at the lighting store was concerned the open lockers will be dark as the flood pot lights will only light so far. She suggested installing two additional ceiling fixtures and placing two track light fixtures pointed at the lockers. We could also pay to change two (or more) of the pot lights to fixtures and just keep the other pot lights. Perhaps there is an option to light the actual open lockers with some sort of low voltage lighting and keep the pots for general lighting. Any thoughts?

I appreciate your help.

Carol

 photo mudroomlightingapril_zpsd619e536.jpg


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Please tell me how to light mudroom lockers

Did you look at phantomlighting.com?


 o
RE: Please tell me how to light mudroom lockers

Thanks for this idea, Davidtay. I took a quick look at the site, and will go back and read more. What style of lighting offered by phantom lighting would you think is best is this situation?

BTW, each locker will have a top and bottom shelf, but the bulk of each locker will be one opening with hooks for coats. The lockers will not have doors.

Carol


 o
RE: Please tell me how to light mudroom lockers

The product is a custom made lighting system intended for use as concealed lighting.

Even if you end up not getting their product, their website should be inspirational.

The lights could be run vertically along the sides or on the bottom side of the upper shelf.

As all their systems are custom made to fit, when measured, cut and fitted properly, the fit and finish should be very good.

Alternatives
1. Use eW profile or Maxlite bars.
2. Flexible led rope lighting pinned in place.
3. Puck light.

Your cabinet maker or contractor should be able to help conceal the wiring if they know what you'd like to use.


 o
RE: Please tell me how to light mudroom lockers

Wow you are a wealth of information, David. You have given me lots of options to review. Thank you!

Carol


 o
RE: Please tell me how to light mudroom lockers

Davidtay and others, we are definitely considering David's options to light the actual mudroom lockers. If money allows we would love to have light inside the actual lockers. As a lower cost option we are also considering just replacing all four of the pots with fixtures. Do you think that would bring light to the lockers? The electrician told us to change the roughed in pots to fixtures at this point would not involve much of a labour charge. The ceilings are only 8 feet so any fixtures would need to be flush mount.

Thanks for your help.

Carol


 o
RE: Please tell me how to light mudroom lockers

It depends on the depth and width of the lockers. Would the labour charge increase the total price?

Another option would be to plan for the locker lighting and install the necessary wiring which would work with solution. The actual lighting could be installed later.

Cree CR series recessed lights actually produce quite diffuse lighting. Either the CR4 or CR6 would work fine with 8' ceilings.


 o
RE: Please tell me how to light mudroom lockers

Hi Davidtay,

Thanks for your reply. The depth of each locker is 25 inches and width is 25 inches too. The total dimensions of the mudroom, including the lockers, is 11 feet 5 inches deep and 9 feet 3.5 inches wide. (for the narrowest part).

I think your idea to rough in lighting for the actual lockers is spot on. We will do that for sure. The cost to switch from roughed in pots to rough in for fixtures will only cost an hour of labour so not a big cost if fixtures would light the space better than the pots. Do you think fixtures would light the space better than pots (ceilings are 8 foot)? We are happy to use the Cree series if that works as well as fixtures. The current roughed in pots are 4 inch. Thanks!

Carol


 o
RE: Please tell me how to light mudroom lockers

It may work, assuming that the bulbs used produce more light than the cans and the fixtures are well placed. I presume that the number of fixtures will be less than the number of cans roughed in.

The style will be different.


 o
RE: Please tell me how to light mudroom lockers

Yes we could reduce the number of lights to 3 instead of the four pots. More than one lighting store representative claimed the four pots will not light the space and we should have done fixtures instead. Maybe they just want to sell us fixtures LOL. I will put some more thought into the pros and cons of pots vs fixtures. Thanks for all your help, Davidtay.

Carol


 o
RE: Please tell me how to light mudroom lockers

Heard that before, but that's not surprising since most folks still think in terms of watts. It might be difficult estimating the actual light output from the fixture as the bulb will most likely be obscured.

FWIW, I had a room lit using a fixture fitted with GE 2D 55W Biax (rated output 3900 lumens). At times, a torchiere (also fitted with a GE 2D) had to be used as well.

Refitted with 5 Cree LR6 @ 600 lumens each (derated since the dimmer reduces the output by 5%). Net result - the LR6s gave better lighting - brighter, better color rendition.


 o
RE: Please tell me how to light mudroom lockers

This is very interesting. So do you think the four pots (4 inch ones) with good quality bulbs like the Cree will light as well or perhaps better than 3 fixtures? In other words I should leave the rough in as is. I will still rough in for low volt lights to individual lockers so I can add light here when funds allow?

Thanks!

Carol


 o
RE: Please tell me how to light mudroom lockers

It depends on the bulbs used, the loss through the fixture shades/ covers.

I'm not against having flush mounts or ceiling fixtures. They can add style to a room, perhaps more than recessed lights.

On the other hand, estimating the amount of light from them can be challenging.

Since you'd be living there, take the time to see which route makes the most sense.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Lighting Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here