Return to the Laundry Room Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Posted by lola3816 (My Page) on
Fri, Dec 15, 06 at 2:02

SA8 was rated as the #1 HE detergent in Consumer Reports. Is it really anygood? Where is it sold?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Hi, SA8 is an Amway product and you can buy it on line at Quixtar. I have added the link below. Good luck!

Here is a link that might be useful: Quixtar.com


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Ughhh. once again another flawed report from CR. Sears Ultra Stain Fighting Formula is listed as a conventional detergent. It is not! It's an HE product and Sears hasn't sold a conventional detergent for many years. Secondly, they have tested a select number of odd products in the HE category. Had they tested the entire lot of HE detergents, the results would have been quite different, but then again this is CR. Never used SA8 product, but the cost per load seems relatively high! $35 for 10 lbs.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

I read somewhere that the Sears line of detergents are pretty much Tide repackaged for Sears. Does anyone know if that's true? Proctor and Gamble makes Tide. Is there a mark anywhere on the Sear's products indicating that Proctor and Gamble makes it?


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

I just wanted to say I am currently using the SA8 powder.A friend told me about it and I am very pleased with the cleaning and the rinsing.You should try it-you won't be disappointed.About the sears formulas,they do have one for the conventional washers. It is item #9835 180 loads in an orange box.All the Sears for the he machines come in the buckets or liquid. The "Stain Fighting Formula" comes in the conventional and an he version. The one in the CU test was the conventional formula in the box. Check these out online or in the store.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Proctor and Gamble makes Tide. Is there a mark anywhere on the Sear's products indicating that Proctor and Gamble makes it?
Sears' detergent is made to their specifications by a company named Huish, not by P&G.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

FWIW, Huish also mankes Kirkland, Safeway, Sun, and Clout detergents, and many others. However, the formulations do seem to be different, with the Sears HE being a favorite of many people here. - DR


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Apparently I was in error. Sears still does sell the conventional Ultra formula, although not carried in our market segment. It is too completely different formulas as I recall with the HE version using enzymes and changing the core structure. IMHO the original formula cleaned better than the HE version. Don't really know who makes it, but it's a very good product.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Gain was #2, is that right? Is it a good HE detergent?
I need a new detergent so checking them all out.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Quixtar/Amway SA8 with BioQuest HE powder
Tide HE powder
Sears Ultra Plus with Oxiclean HE powder
I have used all three and they clean equally well.
The Sears is the cheapest.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

So, is the concensus that powders clean better than liquid detergents? Ever since I bought my front loader I prefer to use liquids. I do a lot of laundry in cold water and I'm afraid of the powder detergent not dissolving completely. What were the top rated liquids?


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Tide HE liquid
Gain HE liquid
Cheer HE liquid
All three are rated excellent in cleaning and excellent in keeping dirt off clothing in Consumer Reports.
Quixtar/Amway SA8 with BioQuest HE powder is rated excellent in cleaning and excellent in keeping dirt off clothing and excellent in keeping dye off clothing in CR.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Most HE powders will dissolve in cold water, though it helps if the machine has a controlled cold temp insted of tap-cold. The conventional wisdom is that liquid detergents are better on greasy dirt and powders better on everything else, but it really depends on the detergent. Since finding powders we like we hardly ever use liquids anymore, and I think many others on this forum have made the same choice. - DR


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Did they happen to rate Method? I've got a large supply of that from my washer purchase. It seems ok, but the wife said she still prefers Tide. Not sure out of habbit or actual cleaning results. I've not noticed any issues with Method.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

I use Method HE for my bath towels, as it seems to leave them soft and doesn't suds as much as other brands.

My mainstay detergent is Sears Ultra Plus HE. I cut it 1/3 with STPP, which helps handle heavy soiling.

By mistake last summer I bought a box of Sears Ultra Plus regular powder. For grins, I gave it a shaken jar sudsing test and compared it to the Sears HE powder I already have. I couldn't see any difference in sudsing, so my conclusion was that these two products are essentially the same thing.

The Costco product scored high in the CR ratings, but my own experience indicates it's unacceptably too high sudsing to be even just "HE Compatible". Additionally, the dosing instructions on the packaging is screwy - it recommends you add MORE of the detergent to an HE washer than to a conventional top loader. Someone at Costco/Huish got their information backwards on that one. But even at reduced levels, the Costco/Kirkland "HE Compatible" products still give up too much suds.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Of course I don't know if the SA8 formulation has changed since about 2002, but then European Ariel and Top (From Japanese Lion) topped SA8 by far in a report back then.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

I have been using SA8 for years. It is wonderful. As far as the cost, you use a lot less than regular detergents. I think their scoop is 1/4 cup. A box of SA8 will last my family of 4 for months; a bottle of liquid Tide usually lasts me a few weeks. I used SA8 when I used cloth diapers and they always came out clean.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Where do you get SA8?


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

I really the the ENORMOUS tub o' Ultra Plus HE powder from Sears! I use 1Tablespoon (1/4 of the measuring cup in the tub) & it cleans like nobody's business in the nearly new Bosch Nexxt 500. I have a pretty big box o' HE powder from Kirkland I use in the 5 yo Frigidaire FL at the beach & find it does an outstanding job on some really grungy clamming/oystering togs (tough cleaning). I do use Spray n' Wash for individual stains but that's it! Will be digging into the ENORMOUS tub for over 1000 loads at the current rate - great cleaning & I love the price (<0.01$/load LOL!) - can't beat that!


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

I have also used SA8 in the past and it is very good. I had also heard that it is excellent for people with septic systems as it doesn't clog it up. I do not have an HE machine but my sister does and used to use the SA8 but felt that it was to sudsy for her new HE machine - I don't know what brand of HE machine she has or if the SA8 HE formula has changed since she last tried it.
SA8 also has a powdered bleach which is tremendous! I use it all the time, even on my colors some times and it doesn't wash out all of the color.
You used to have to go through a distributor to get the SA8 detergent, but I don't know if that's still the case. My mom became a distributor years ago and stills keep her "distributorship" current for her SA8 devotees. I think she might get a better price as a distributor? but I think she's always given her customers the same price.
ALso, I have recently been using the laundry detergent from Sam's Club and have had no problem with it. I do not currently have an HE machine, so I don't know how it work in one of those.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

In case there are others who are looking for a good detergent, since i know this is a post from long time ago, I am a longtime SA8 user and it faaaar out beats any other detergent I have used, and i have used a lot. I have used it on my newborn's clothes, and my newborn had very sensitive skin.
I have a washer that requires HE detergents (BOSCH), and I have used both TIDE HE and SA8. I washed my clothes in TIDE HE and had to rinse TWICE, and STILL had suds residue in the door. SA8 NEVER does that. And it cleans SUPERB. I almost feel like a salesperson saying this, but it's true, just try it. And quixtar members pay $28.10 for 150 loads. That's not expensive.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

I have not been able to find evidence that the Ultra Plus Detergent at Sears is made by Huish. There are none of the visible imprints of the Huish H on any of the packages I have.

Also, I have seen the detergents described as "Desoto" Laundry Detergent on sears.com

SA8 is a great detergent - as long as you buy the powdered variety. The liquid is not-so-great.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

I have a kenmore elite canyon capacity, and the water doesn't even cover the clothes. the clothes don't come clean and they smell after wearing just a short time. I use the Sears ultra HE detergent. I don't see suds and i use as directed. Does anyone know of a product for this maschine that is in powder form? thanks so much


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Try the SA8 powder. It is a Great product and you also use very little of it.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Thank you, sounds like alot of people like it. I'm trying to find something in a local store and not online right now. I tried to use hot water instead of warm, and use a full scoop, (tech said I only need half) but husband's t-shirt still smells the same. I just don't think there's enough water to get dirt out or stain. Still working on it and I'll keep the SA8 powder in mind. Thank you so much.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

From what I understand about your washer the cycle for sheets and towels use the most water. Have you tried that before to see if it cleans better and with a deeper fill?


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Thank you. I did do a load on the sheets and towel cycle and the clothes did smell a little better. ;) I'll probably continue that. Thank you so much!!!!!


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

I use
Fuller 86 Powder Laundry Detergent. and it does a super job ! it only takes 1/8 of a cup.
I do not like amway products, and I really dislike Tide.

Here is a link that might be useful: Fuller Brush


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

We have used SA8 religously for 27 years and would never consider using anything else.


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

i love SA8. all the rest are trying to be something there not. my detergent is concentrated last longer. you save alot more money in the long run. i now sell SA8


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

Do any of the Sears detergents have enzymes?


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

We use the Sears Ultra Plus Stain Fighting Formula and it has enzymes. BTW, we love it--it cleans well and leaves our clothing and towels soft!


 o
RE: SA8 detergent rated #1 in consumer reports!

I love SA8, it is a wonderful product especially if you have sensitive skin like i do. It dissolves just as fast in cold water as in hot water. Also one 3kg box of SA8 with bioquest is so concentrated that it would take 4.3 boxes of tide quick dissolving powder to do the same number of loads. Just think of only having to buy detergent 2 maybe 3 times a year. It is not expensive. If you are ever willing to try it just visit my website. https://cncconnection.mychoices.biz. Sign up as a client (it is totally free and safe!) and order away. The best part is that it is delivered straight to you home so you won't ever have to make another trip to the grocery store again for it! If there is any questions feel free to contact me my email is CC.CONNECTION@HOTMAIL.COM
Happy Shopping!!!
Carlie and Clayton Stromberg
St Albert, Alberta, Canada


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Laundry Room Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here