JOIN NOW LOG IN
iVillage GardenWeb iVillage GardenWeb THE INTERNET'S GARDEN & HOME COMMUNITY ADVERTISEMENT
Blogs Forums Photo Galleries Ask The Experts Tools & Directories        
Return to the Laundry Room Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
ISO Medium capacity front loader with normal cycles heater

Posted by rand_6 (My Page) on
Thu, Nov 12, 09 at 11:44

I am looking for a medium capacity front loader with a supplemental heater in which the heater works on cycles other than only sanitize.

As this will be a third floor install I would also like one not particularly prone to balance and vibration problems. (I am installing it right next to wall where joists mount so it is a fairly firm part of the floor but I would like one known for stability and vibration reduction as it is not going to sit on a concrete slab.)

I remember some years ago that the kenmore version of the duet sport had heat for other cycles, does it currently? Is there even a kenmore version of the sport since I don't see any 3.4 cubic foot kenmores. Also the price differential used to be about $10 more for the sears kenmore and now the difference between the duet sport (eg at best buy and elsewhere for $500) and the kenmore (seems 3.7 cc kenmore is $770) is 50% more money.

Requirements:
-3.4 to 4.00 cf
-heating on cycles in addition to sanitize
-120 volt
-low vibration or at least somewhere in the range of the models known to have better vibration compensation
-extra rinse option

Strong preferences:
- warm water rinse option (not necessarily heated but using standard mixing)
- cost below $700

thank you in advance for any advice!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: ISO Medium capacity front loader with normal cycles heater

No matter what you look at, be sure that you can return the machine if there's vibration issues. Samsung's VRT versions have gotten good reviews for vibration and there's a model or two that would be under $700 if you shop. Not sure if you'll get anything with a heater for under $700 though!

Your best bet would be to go look for machines with the criteria you require, then check price. Then see about issues with vibration. You might be able to shore up the floor a bit to help.


 o
RE: ISO Medium capacity front loader with normal cycles heater

I was looking at the Frigidaire after consumer reports indicated that the Frigidaire Gallery had excellent results in the vibration testing, but incredibly the upscale Frigidaire Affinity, of the same 3.5 cf capacity has the worse vibration scores! I saw the affinity has a heater.

Frigidaire claims they have the same suspension and mechanics!!!

Crazy. The gallery is $525 at sears although they will give it to me for $499 and the affinity 800 is 585 and they will give it to me for $560.

There seem to be about five or six t models with heaters one can get for under $700, indeed under $600. but most are sanitary only.

I just don't get how CR is rating one Frigidaire 3.5 CF as the worst in vibration and one as the best, when Frigidaire says they supposedly have the same guts.


 o
RE: ISO Medium capacity front loader with normal cycles heater

FL vibration depends not just on the mechanicals, but also on how the computer board is programmed. The Gallery might be programmed to require a better balance. Presumably this means it spends more time trying to distribute the load.


 o
RE: ISO Medium capacity front loader with normal cycles heater

somehow I doubt they would have their more expensive line have more vibration with a software adjustable factor such as more time distributing the load, or if they did inadvertently wouldn't fix it given the consumer reports findings.

I think it is more likely the drive system, balance or suspension inside are in fact different.

FYI I downloaded a bunch of Frigidaire service manuals and sadly I see the temperature settings have been being lowered by a few degrees every couple of years


 o
RE: ISO Medium capacity front loader with normal cycles heater

Might want to spend a couple of minutes watching this before buying Frigidaire.

Here is a link that might be useful: Frigidaire issues


 o
RE: ISO Medium capacity front loader with normal cycles heater

" * Posted by mysteryclock (My Page) on
Wed, Nov 18, 09 at 17:06
"Might want to spend a couple of minutes watching this before buying Frigidaire."

Doesn't really phase me. guy says it is seven years old. So the completley new replacement cost of his model is $500 (current price for the newer version of his Frigidaire gallery at sears) . That is $71/year.

I would bet dollars to donuts that this is exactly the average cost per year for front loaders whether you buy a $1500 machine which would have to last 21 years or a $500 machine lasting 7 years to get the same depreciation cost per year

I have a $420 GE top loader which is dying after four years with what it turns out from reading is a VERY common problem, across a dozen models over three years. Motor wont work on gentle wash, slow spin and just clicks. Part is $250. Timer dial (over $100) is also failing.

Every brand has problems. LG, Bosch and Miele have nightmare prices on parts and very thin service infrastructure with people waiting weeks or longer to get sa service call and their machine fixed. GS/Whirlpool and Frigidair whcih are much easier to fix are made cheaper and cheaper. Speed queen starts out so absurdly expensive for what you get that they make no sense either.

That is why I am looking at the sub $700 range and why I am interested in the $500 machines look at sears current prices on gallery at $500 and affinities at $550 to $570). I intend to chuck it when there is a problem because I simply believe that all frontloaders have problems.

I lived in Europe. Front loaders there have much smaller drums. Simple physics tells you the centrifugal forces of a 25% smaller drum is not 25% less but about half. (you calculate on squares not liner reduction of size)


 o
RE: ISO Medium capacity front loader with normal cycles heater

Centrifugal force varies linearly with the radius. Look at it this way: The basic formula for centripetal acceleration is

(v*v) / r

For a constant RPM, v varies linearly with the radius. So you've got a second power of the radius in the numerator, but it's divided by the radius in the denominator, leaving you with a linear relationship to r.

Centrifugal force does vary as the square of the RPM.


 o
RE: ISO Medium capacity front loader with normal cycles heater

I have an 8-year old front loader that I'm hoping to get at least 10 years out of. It cost me about $600, but I don't consider it a throw-away. When I pay hundreds of dollars for a large appliance, I'm not expecting to throw it away after 7 years.

Maybe I'm too idealistic *smile*.

-Roger


 o
RE: ISO Medium capacity front loader with normal cycles heater

roger sadly that is old school. the economics of parts and labor vs replacement cost make it so.

I was responding to the video. I don't find it a shocking indictment of Frigidaire per se that a seven year old front load machine failed.

They are no longer "durable goods" they are sold and marketed like electronics, indeed the ever increasing number of electronic components within the washers, practically guarantee some problem after seven years.

So you expect to get 10 years out of a $600 washer. The guy got seven years out of a $500 washer. It will cost him $500 to replace it.


 o
RE: ISO Medium capacity front loader with normal cycles heater

suburbanmd (My Page) on Thu, Nov 19, 09 at 18:26
"Centrifugal force varies linearly with the radius. Look at it this way: The basic formula for centripetal acceleration is (v*v) / r"

No, you are describing centri*petal* force. Mass causes increase in centri*fugal* force through squares of mass. It does NOT vary linearly!

You square the mass of the load!

If you are assuming people will be putting the same amount of wet clothes int eh 4 CF as the 2.5 cubic foot the forces wont change much. But if you are spinning 10 lbs of wet clothes instead of five lbs the forces are NOT merely doubled -- they are FOUR times as much!


 o
RE: ISO Medium capacity front loader with normal cycles heater

I don't understand your physics, sorry. Anyway, if by your own reckoning you can own a large Miele for the same price per day as a Frigidaire Gallery, why not get the Miele? It's more solidly built, and its temperature settings are chosen to do laundry well, not to earn tax credits for the manufacturer.


 
 

 

 


Click here to learn more about in-text links on this page.



iVillage GardenWeb: The Internet's Garden & Home Community  
  iVillage Home & Garden Network