Return to the Laundry Room Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Our new Washer is.....

Posted by GregRod (My Page) on
Mon, Jul 29, 13 at 11:55

Ok.

So our New Washer is the MVWB850YG1 otherwise known as the Maytag Bravos HE XL (850). We decided that we had enough with Samsung, LG had issues with exploding washers, plus I did not like the plastic wash basket hangers in LG units. We have had issues with our Fridgidaire kitchen appliances so those were off the list and the GE's were too expensive. Yes..SpeedQueen is a solid unit, but we got used to the bigger loads that got rid of laundry faster (when combined with our moisture sensor dryer) so the smaller SpeedQueens were not going to work.

I asked around here and there and read as many reviews as I could. Mainly people seemed to like the Maytag Bravos. Most complained about the water level issues and harshness on clothing. Very few complained of breakdowns. (Although there were some..holding my breath!)

The washer was delivered early this past Sat so we had a some time to play with it this weekend.
I will give you my thoughts between the old Samsung WA456 and the New Bravos 850.

The WA456 and the Bravos are about the same size. The WA456 is 4.5 Cu's and the Bravos 4.6.

The Bravos has 13 cycles and the WA456 had only 10. A huge upgrade in the Bravos is that once the cycle has started, the user can actually pause and select other cycles. The Samsung, if you missed selecting an added feature like soak the machine would not allow it. The user would have to turn off the unit and then reselect. If this was done after the clothing got wet, then the sensors would pick up the extra weight from the added water and then add too much water for the wash.

Bravos...Better .

The balancing is better right out of the box with the Bravos.
With the Samsung, before first use and even after the user must calibrate the washer or else the machine may not balance correctly. The result would be loads that would spin, fail and the washer would add more water to the load to balance. This would cause the machine to wash forever or until balance was achieved. The Bravos, loaded and no problems with calibration. However, the weigh and balance does take a while longer with the Bravos. Bravos is better!

The Samsung has the Aquajet feature which sprays a torrent of water over the top of the clothing and basically churns up the laundry detergent for better cleaning. The Bravos has the PowerWash/PowerSpray feature which sprays the detergent laced water over the clothing. My opinion is that the WA456 Aquajet is stronger at accomplishing this, but is a fail for the following reason. It appears that if the water is too hot when using the WA456 Aquajet it blows the seal gasket in the Aquajet ring. This causes leaks and repairs and is a flaw in design. The PowerSpray in the Bravos uses a recirculating pump to spray the laundry. (The new Samsung WA50 does use
the pump as well)

Bravos better because it does not have the Aquajet ring issue and accomplishes the same thing.

The Bravos seems to be better built than the Samsung. It seems solid in frame and metal cabinet. Both machines are very quiet with a slight edge going to the Samsung, but the wash/agitation clearly is better in the Bravos.

Some people complain that the Bravos is rough on clothing, but I prefer seeing my clothing take a beating to get out dirt. The Samsung, while it did clean ok kind of swished the clothing about in the water. The Bravos impeller is the closest I've seen in terms of movement to the old style washer agitator motion. I can clearly see that it is doing a much better job at cleaning than the Samsung.

The water level in the Bravos is low on Normal, Whites, Sheets. It does add more water in the Bulky setting. (Comforters etc).

I washed a few shirts and shorts in the bulky setting and thought this is way too much water. Some people prefer more water, so they'd love this setting, but I actually see that the low water settings are better for cleaning in the Bravos. The impeller plate really turns the clothing over and pounds the fabric. Our whites came out much cleaner in the Bravos than in the Samsung. Plus the water for the wash in the Bravos was hot. The Samsung Water Levels were higher than the Bravos, but with the higher water level it just did not seem to really pound out the clothing. It cleaned, but not as good as the Bravos.

Bravos is better in cleaning. It also has an extra rinse that can be added for the wash. The Samsung did not have an extra rinse although it has a pre-soak where the Bravos doesn't.

Both the Samsung and the Bravos have a 10yr warranty on the motor. The basket is 10yrs on the Bravos and was only 3yrs on the Samsung. The Samsung had a 2yr on the board. The Bravos boards are only covered on the 1yr parts and labor. Both machines have the same 1yr parts/labor warranty.

Now..I am a realist! I thought that the Samsung WA456 was the best thing ever. I do think that the idea was good but the execution was poor. I mean..the machine broke down 6 times in 6 months until we got rid of it for the Bravos. Therefore, I will not claim that this machine is the one to buy or claim to be overjoyed.

This initial thought for the Bravos is that I am impressed...SO FAR.

Only time will tell.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Our new Washer is.....

Glad you are liking your Bravos. I have been a Maytag user for the past 31 years, although I know todays are just Wpool models with some tweaks, then the Maytag name. I will say, I did see a Bravos on You Tube that a guy washed a mattress pad(always a mattress pad) and his flew all to pieces. I think most of that happens because the Normal cycle was used. He was upset and said Wpool told him too bad but that was because it was out of warranty. Seems as though all the HE top load have some bugs to be worked out yet, just like the front loaders did. Enjoy your new Maytag and hopefully it will work great for many years.


 o
RE: Our new Washer is.....

Yes...Mattress Pads..(waterproofed) are supposed to be washed at the lowest spin. If people read the manual...these things would not happen.

I know whirlpool owns Maytag..but I am wondering what the differences are under the hood. For instance, why do Whirlpool Models not have the Ten Yr motor warranty but the Maytags do?

Has to be some diffrences...right?


 o
RE: Our new Washer is.....

Thank you GregRod for such a thorough review of your new washer. Please keep us updated on how you still like it since it sounds like a good machine.


 o
RE: Our new Washer is.....

Thanks for the thoughtful review on your new Bravos. I have a 2010 model that I've posted about several times in various threads. I'm still liking my washer a lot, I usually use the bulky cycle for more water in the load because I feel it's gentler on the clothing. I've never had a stain fail to disappear in the Bravos, unlike every other machine I've ever owned.

I need to get the circuit board replaced in my Bravos dryer, the machine fails to stop drying in auto mode. I have to set my oven timer to be sure the dryer doesn't over-dry things like sheets and towels.


 o
RE: Our new Washer is.....

Not sure about the motor, but I wonder if it isnt the same and they just offer the different warranty with Maytag seeming like an upgrade when they really dont have many motor problems with either brand.
At one time when they were still doing the conventional TL full fill, I read where Maytag used synthetic trans. oil and that was supposed to be a "plus".

One of the pluses now for the Bravos is the Cold Wash and Power Wash cycle-right? I have seen the "Cold Wash" advertised with the Tide CW Detergent as a joint venture between the two P&G and Wpool.

I have two friends that have bought new Samsung TL's. They both seem to like theirs so far. One has the model with the Aqua Jet but no leaks and the other one has a different model, not sure which. For HE TL machines, the Fisher/Paykel impeller model turns the clothes over better than any impeller model I have seen. Not sure how they would hold up.

Keep us updated on the likes/dislikes as you use your new Bravos.


 o
RE: Our new Washer is.....

Yes..cold water wash is a new item on the Bravos.

I bet the new Samsung WA50 with the Aquajet will be fine. The WA456 which was the model we had was awful. I think each issue we had with it lead to a snowball effect until it just scrapped out

Last issue was the clutch and motor gave out.

With so much time leaving work for repairs, we just decided to give up on Samsung. Left a bad feeling for us..


 o
RE: Our new Washer is.....

Second week...so far so good..


 o
RE: Our new Washer is.....

So for we are almost 3 months in on the washer and it's working very nicely.

Cleans clothes like a champ. (which is more than I can say for that Samsung garbage-it ended up in the dump)


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Laundry Room Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here