Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
livebetter

ActiLift - Tide vs Ariel?

livebetter
13 years ago

Larsi mentioned using a German Ariel product with ActiLift technology.

I recently noticed this Tide product also with ActiLift.

They are both P&G brands so would this technology be the same? Would Tide with ActiLift do just as good a job as Ariel?

Which brings me to another question I was thinking ... if these brands - Persil and Ariel - are so fantastic - best made detergents in the world - why do the manufacturers not sell them directly into the North Amercian market?

I mean Henkel makes and sells other brands in NA like Purex. Why not sell Persil?

Just curious if anyone has some insight on this.

Clearly I lose sleep at night pondering the world of detergents :)

Here is a link that might be useful: Tide with ActiLift

Comments (6)

  • larsi_gw
    13 years ago

    P & G make both Ariel for European market and Tide for the North American market.

    Since both Ariel and Tide belong to Proctor & Gamble...I assume ActiLift is the same technology (hence the identical name).

    I think the difference is that Ariel in not available for NA, and Ariel with ActiLift comes both in a liquid and powder, where it seems that Tide with ActiLift is a liquid.

    Persil is a "high end" detergent, and would be too expensive for the NA market!

  • livebetter
    Original Author
    13 years ago

    I was under the impression that Persil was not that expensive in Germany. I think we pay such high prices for it here as it has to be imported.

    I emailed Henkel Germany directly (recently) regarding distribution in Canada (Miele Canada no longer imports Persil as they have their own Miele Care line). They informed me that they do not market or ship directly to Canada therefore; anyone selling it here is getting it from a distributor (hence I would assume the higher cost).

    My point was  if it truly is the best detergent ever  why would it not be marketed and sold worldwide?? Henkel has many other brands it sells worldwide in different categories  IÂm just curious what the reason is. Why they make brands like Purex or 20 Mule Team Borax for NA but not sell Persil here??

  • sshrivastava
    13 years ago

    @larsi: Persil is only as "high end" in Germany as Tide is here. I believe it costs the same in Germany as Tide does in the US. The markup on imported Persil is ridiculous! It's either due to high prices charged by distributors or resellers have simply decided that's what consumers are willing to pay.

  • cynic
    13 years ago

    I was talking to some friends who said Ariel is available at some Home Depot stores. No idea which variety (assuming there's more than one of course) but I found that interesting. I don't frequent HD so I haven't personally seen it.

  • sshrivastava
    13 years ago

    For those interested in Henkel's various products throughout the world and why they are sold in those countries, look here. A lot of the formulations are specific to the challenges in the regions where the products are sold, especially those in Africa. It's an interesting perspective.

  • larsi_gw
    13 years ago

    Sshrivastava,

    Being German, I can tell you that Persil is still considered a "high-end" brand in Germany (and all of Europe). You are very right though, that imported Persil to the USA and Canada is ridiculously priced. Persil in Germany is not a cheap as Tide or Cheer is, here in N.America though. Taken right from Henkel's website, they even call their Persil a "premium detergent":

    "Our product developers again succeeded in significantly improving the performance of our European premium laundry detergents Persil, Le Chat, Dixan and Wipp".

    It also depends on what store, and what part of Germany one shops in (sadly, East and West still vary in terms of value and pricing). I would say a comparable sized bottle of Tide in the USA would be about $6.50, where the Persil would be about $10.00 in Germany. So....Persil in Germany is SO, SO much cheaper than in the USA, but still not as affordable as Ariel, Dash, Aldi or Lina!

    I have enough German Persil liquid and German Ariel Liquid to last me roughly a year (maybe more). I stocked up in June 2010, when I was in Germany & Sweden!! :)

0
Sponsored
Re-Bath
Average rating: 4.9 out of 5 stars12 Reviews
Pittsburgh's Custom Kitchen & Bath Designs for Everyday Living