Return to the Laundry Room Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Laundry Detergent Survey

Posted by kirbyultimateg (My Page) on
Mon, Jan 3, 11 at 20:50

Laundry Detergent Survey: What brand of laundry detergent do you use?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

I use Tide HE original scent liquid detergent.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

liquid Tide usually, but I find Era does just as good a job at a much CHEAPER price


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

I used Tide and Gain HE PRoducts, I recently tried the new Wisk HE too, it smells much better than the old version and it seems to clean just as good as the P&G products at half the price


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Cult of Persil here for general clothing/fabrics. A few other brands for more specific needs (delicates, linen, mop heads/microfiber cloths/cleaning cloths.)


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Persil Color Gel, Clorox Green Works or Ariel Gel for most clothes. Vaska Herbatergent for sheets, towels and blankets.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Mrs. Meyers or BioKleen Premium for whites and lights. Charlie's soap for wool, delicates, darks.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Kirkland (Costco) HE. Great price and it does a good job at cleaning. I have used it for a couple of years now.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Persil Universal Megapearls for whites.
Currently using Persil Megapearls for color, Tide Free or Cheer liquid for colors, but will probably go back to Cheer powder after using the up detergent that I currently have.
Vaska for silk and wool items.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

The new Method pump in Unscented. One detergent for everything, small bottle, lasts a long time. I don't have the time or energy to obsess about soap and it works well for me. They have a couple scented ones, too, if you like the smelly stuff.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

My family uses Sears Ultra Plus Free & Clear powder alone. I add STPP, and non-chlorine bleach for some loads.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

For the past 15 years, we have used Biokleen All-Temperature liquid, to which we add about a third of a cup of 20 Mule Team borax each load.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Tide HE liquid for everything.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Persil Color Megaperls for darks, Persil Universal Megaperls for bright colors and whites, and Vaska for towels, sheets and silk/delicates.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

sshrivastava - why the Vaska for sheets/towels? Just curious. I can see it for delicates (that's what I use it for) but I use Persil on my towels and sheets.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Persil Color Megaperls for darks and Persil Universal Megaperls for lights


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Country Save for everything. Bleach to clean washer after pet blankets or rugs have been washed.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

@badgergrrl - Nothing leaves my towels and sheets as soft as Vaska, and since those items are rarely soiled with anything challenging the Vaska is a good fit.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Almost all washes: Ordinary Cheer powder (3/4 T per load); a pretty inexpensive, good quality product, reasonably accesible (but only at Target in my area) and very effective in my normal hot washes (120-180F), in my FLs and with my water chemistry. Have used it more or less exclusively for more than a decade. Used to make comparisons with everything I could find, but grew out of my detergent mania phase. (There's hope for you, too.) I believe Cheer is an enzymatic detergent, w/o OBAS. Or at least the stuff I'm using is that way. I see it has a new box which sometimes means that they've been messin' around with the formula. I keep a two or three year's supply on hand, so I'm insulated from immediate catastrophe.

For wools and delicates: Perwol powder and Eucalan.

For down items (jackets comforters and pillows): Downe

Stain treatment: Spray and Wash, Charlie's All-pupose liquid, and the remaining 20+ year old bottles of liquid ERA that are left over from when I had a TL here in the country.

Additives (rarely used, but always keep on hand): STTP, sodium perborate, borax and washing soda.

Never use FS of any kind. I think the last bottle I had on hand to quell oversuds finally got gummed up, so I tossed it.

Oversuds remedy: Ivory soap grated with a Microplane, stored tightly capped.

Have remnants of several dozen candidates (Persil, several var., Charlie's, Tide, a slew of "natural" detergents) now mostly relegated to litter box washing in order to use them up. I didn't find them satisfactory for laundry but they're great for washing out cages and general household cleaning.

L


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Pretty much what is on sale. There are some brands I will not purchase though. Lately in my rotation has been Arm & Hammer, Tide with Dawn, All, All Free, and various flavors of Gain. I have been using the Arm & Hammer, or All mostly on our bed sheets, and dark clothing and things like the Tide and Gain on our whites due to optical brighteners. But, we don't get our clothes super dirty at our house except in the summer when I am out doing a lot of gardening. So I don't have a lot of stains to worry about. If I can find a sale and use a coupon, and the laundry ends up being someplace between 10 cents to 15 cents a load, I will stock up on several bottles.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

For me, it depends on what I'm washing:

~ White and light-colored laundry (including sheets): Tide HE w/ bleach liquid (wish it came in powder form), plus OxyClean if washing in hot water

~ My guys' dark work clothes & jeans: ERA HE liquid

~ Dark office/church clothes: Tide HE Total Care liquid

~ Bright colors: ERA HE or Tide HE Total Care, depending on fabric (both liquid)

~ Delicates/Handwashables: Tide HE Total Care or Woolite HE (both liquid)

I also have Sears Ultra Wash Stainfighting powder detergent (very low-sudsing, for any type washer). I used it on jeans and other everyday clothes until I got the ERA HE liquid. I only use powder in warm or hot water, not cold, as it doesn't dissolve well in cold water.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

I have a new FL washer and am still experimenting, but continue to use Kirkland Free & Clear liquid and have for years.

I use Tide with bleach - original scent only - for sheets and towels. I like it especially after illness or for houseguests. Plus my kids have dust mite allergies and I believe this helps.

I use Kookaburra wool wash on woolens, and am not sure if I will try that in my new washer or not. Typically I have done these by hand.

I'd love to try some of those euro detergents but we have contact allergies to some scented detergents and it is just not worth it to deviate from what we use.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Charlie's Soap Powdered Laundry Detergent. If I have to rewash (DH, DS1 & DS2 can get pretty muddy and greasy on their dirtbikes) I use All in the curvy jug.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Costco's cheap house brand stuff. In a top-loader.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Persil or Ariel oxyanillos for whites (picture of a FL washer on the bag), Costco enviro friendly or Mrs. Meters (enzymes, no OBA) for darks, Vaska for sheets and not so dirty loads. Charlie's Soap for rugs, pet items.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

I like the Tide Advanced Power HE Liquid which seems to be only available at Costco.
At about $19 with the $2.50 off coupon for 170oz size is about .23 cents a load.
I think it is the same as the Tide HE Plus Bleach Alternative.

Also use a little Woolite on a few delicate's.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Tide HE Orig Liquid and Tide HE Coldwater Free Liquid. I also have a 200 oz. container of Tide Orig Liquid left (non-HE) for hand washing and rare trips to the laundromat.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Persil Universal and Oxydol (in the green bottle)


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Strange I haven't seen Sun w/color safe bleach mentioned. I've been using that for a while now and have been pleasantly surprised by it's mildly fresh scent and it's ability to clean ordinary clothing, towels and sheets. It's very low sudsing and seems to leave my clothes soft even though I have very hard water and do not use softener. It has a texture of homemade detergent that uses washing soda as an ingredient.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Updated, now that Tide HE powder DOES come with bleach:

Tide w bleach (HE powder) for white cottons and towels
ERA HE for darks and everyday clothes
Tide Total Care HE for delicates and dress clothes


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Tide HE Free & Clear liquid
Tide Ultra HE powder for rewash/heavily stained items


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Country save for most things most of the time. I also keep cheer powder and persil mega pearls on hand for colours and towels. For the very rare times I do a cold wash I use method cedar and lavender. Lately I'm finding anything with scent is causing to break out so I may drop everything but the country save.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

First few years for me was Sears HE stain fighting powder.

Then I used Tide HE w/ touch of Downy.....Then finally, I've been using Gain HE powder

I like them all and a box lasts me forever.

I've been thinking about trying Country Save. It gets rave reviews on Amazon but I've never heard of it. I recently came across it looking for something else online & started reading reviews. I don't grocery shop so I don't know if it's available in the store, but I put in on the list so hopefully they have it at Kroger or Meijer


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

I've used Biokleen for several years and love it. I usually add about 1/2 cup of borax for good measure. I like Method's other products and would probably use their clothes detergent if I couldn't get Biokleen but Biokleen is made about 15 miles away from. Yay for being able to shop locally!


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

I've read the previous replies and feel like such a simpleton here....many of these detergents I've never even heard of! I buy my "washin powders" at Wally World and they are mostly the cheaper brands....Gain is my current "suds du jour."

My mom always used Cheer when I was growing up. But, as an adult now, I have to steer away from the more premium brands. I am really not an allergic type at all, but oddly enough, I found out years ago that I get the big time itchies with Cheer.....and near terminal itchies with TIDE!


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

pupwhipped, if you are looking for a bargain detergent then give Sun detergent a try. It's available at Dollar Tree for $1 so it's a great way to try it and see if you like it without spending a lot. The box is small, so even if you don't like it, you won't be stuck with a big box of something you can't use.
I get the Sun w/color safe bleach and it cleans great, rinses well and has a mild scent. It might be available in larger sizes at some of the other dollar type stores.

If you do give it a try, let us know how you liked it. Everyone is always touting the expensive brands, but I think the cheaper ones work just as well. I never did like Tide.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

I dig it, I will check it out. I seem to flip flop back and forth....have also used Purex in the past. It's funny, whenever we visit my MIL, and I do laundry there, I like whatever brand she has. It always seems to smell so good. So I come home and buy "what she had" but it never seems as good at my house. Weird, to say the least. HA!

I will never buy Tide again. The itchy episode was many years ago, but it took me awhile to get over it. Makes me itch just to think about it.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

I used many brands in past and always went back to Persil.
My newest favorite one for now is Mrs. Meyers.
One cupfull for 5kg washer and two cups for the big one.
They have so many wonderfull scents. It cleans well and rinses out good.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Use Tide HE for my new front-loader, and the Aldi store brand (was happy to see they make an HE detergent).


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

I use Tide Original powder for whites, and sometimes Gain original scent powder for whites too.
For light and medium colors I use one of the following, whichever hits my fancy: Gain, Purex, Trend (Trend is a great powder for a really low price at Dollar General), Foca, Roma and they are all powders. For dark or black cloths I use Woolite liquid (can't find it in a powder anywhere, I've looked). Also for light colors and medium colors I also occasionally use Charlie's which I like, and All Small & Might liquid, which I really like too (and i've found it very good on whites too).


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Cannot for the life of me understand so many people's desire to use scented detergents and rinse agents. I want nothing left in my wash, detergent or scent. I use Kirkland Ultra Free & Clear, All Free & Clear for granddaughter's diapers, and Woolite Extra Dark Care for darks. No fabric softeners (yuk) ever. Double rinses always.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

I have been using the purex liquid and powder for the past month or so. We tried the wisk he liquid and my husband formed a horrible allergic reaction to it and we haven't had a problem (knock on wood...) since switching him back to purex. I do have a box of the sears detergent too I use every so often to change things up. I don't use any liquid softner but add vinegar to every load and use a bounce dryer sheet with each load when they go in the dryer. I find my clothes have basically no scent just a very faint bounce sheet smell to them which is good. I also do the extra rinse option on my wash machine.


 o
RE: Laundry Detergent Survey

Persil mega pearls all the way! I think I have tried everything on the market including Charlies. I always go back to Persil.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Laundry Room Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here